Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

Why does the government want us to open up?

Reply
Created by FormulaNova > 9 months ago, 26 Sep 2021
This topic has been locked
kiterboy
2614 posts
27 Sep 2021 5:38AM
Thumbs Up

So why aren't the double-vaxxed allowed to travel freely?

Tequila !
WA, 1028 posts
27 Sep 2021 6:10AM
Thumbs Up

What Mao Mclownan did the following day after he got re-elected early this year?
Answer: opened the borders to Eastern States (Vic). It was all about securing the election first.

Why he is saying only April next year?

Because will be around when the Feds will call the Election.

Its all about playing politics, not health.

And for the komrades who think we can be locked forever, this will change when commodities fall to normal prices.

Then a call to "diversify" our WA economy to services, tourism etc. This happened in 2014, 2015, 2016.

I dont recall several media outlets w pieces about lunatics putting Trump tattoos, alas we have a few tattooing the local emperor.

Scary times

airsail
QLD, 1565 posts
27 Sep 2021 8:23AM
Thumbs Up

The quicker Qld can join NSW and Vic with Covid cases the better, at least then we can look at returning to a relatively normal life. We are living in twilight zone at the moment in Qld, the virus is coming, can't be stopped, just get it over with.

Subsonic
WA, 3374 posts
27 Sep 2021 6:45AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
bjw said..
"A short sharp lockdown", do you mean like Victoria had?

WA is a small population. It's much easier to manage. But if restricting freedom of travel, people being able to use a house they own, attending a funeral, seeing loved ones and killing tourism businesses sounds fine to you. Then I'm thinking WA needs better a education system.

The virus is waiting for you to open. It's unlikely it'll disappear, you can delay it's arrival, by restricting your own freedoms, but it will arrive.





Hmm, spend a week in lock down whilst the contact tracers get on top of it, then open up completely again, no virus. Or let everyone wonder around and spread it, with some half assed restrictions in place, and get to the not so happy place nsw is in now. Locked up long term, virus everywhere.

it was last xmas it became apparent things were going to go south for nsw. She was letting people into an outbreak area for xmas visits. Im not sure where Gladys was educated, but If she cant see why thats a bad thing, and she, the states premier is the shining example of it, perhaps its the nsw education system that needs serious review.


yeah, for sure we have a smaller population, but thats got nothing to do with why we are virus free. the much larger part of WAs population still live in densely populated areas. we're not all on farms. We're virus free because marky mark shuts us down as soon as theres been an infection wondering about. And manages our borders with the other states depending on how their situation is going.

I love the "its coming for ya" attitude, and you are right. The virus will be everywhere eventually. But in the meantime i'd rather lose freedom for a week here and there and open up to the rest of the world when everyone is vaccinated, than sit at home indefinitely, not able to visit anyone, or get out on the water because the virus is running rampant outside.

FormulaNova
WA, 15090 posts
27 Sep 2021 7:16AM
Thumbs Up

I think in NSW's defence, Delta was a surprise. I think the rest of Australia are lucky that it wasn't them that got hit with it first as they would have had the same thing happen, WA included.

NSW successfully got rid of previous strains, and I think the premier thought, or only had, the previous approach to go by. Unfortunately Delta spreads quicker, so a slower approach didn't work.

I don't think Gladys is doing a bad job, its just that she doesn't have much to work with. A large population, a huge intake of returning people, and states that have blended borders with NSW.

Its easy to say that they should have shut down hard, easy in hindsight, but I don't think any other state would have done it differently. They are all balancing public opinion, with the economy, with the best way to stop these infections. Its not an easy task. I think if she had done a hard shutdown people would have been complaining it wasn't needed. They had already done that with the previous strains.

It doesn't mean that our PM should force all the states to open up as well. That's just lunacy and if anyone is doing it its just him catering to politics and public opinion.

KiteboyDave
87 posts
27 Sep 2021 7:40AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..
I think in NSW's defence, Delta was a surprise. I think the rest of Australia are lucky that it wasn't them that got hit with it first as they would have had the same thing happen, WA included.

NSW successfully got rid of previous strains, and I think the premier thought, or only had, the previous approach to go by. Unfortunately Delta spreads quicker, so a slower approach didn't work.

I don't think Gladys is doing a bad job, its just that she doesn't have much to work with. A large population, a huge intake of returning people, and states that have blended borders with NSW.

Its easy to say that they should have shut down hard, easy in hindsight, but I don't think any other state would have done it differently. They are all balancing public opinion, with the economy, with the best way to stop these infections. Its not an easy task. I think if she had done a hard shutdown people would have been complaining it wasn't needed. They had already done that with the previous strains.

It doesn't mean that our PM should force all the states to open up as well. That's just lunacy and if anyone is doing it its just him catering to politics and public opinion.

If you compare the response to the virus from Gladys and Dan it's pretty clear who handled it better.

Victoria is broken, Melbourne was the world's most liveable city. Two years later it stinks of urine, nurses are urged not to wear their uniforms after hours out of fear of attacks from nazis, the city has been in hard lockdown for the longest time in the world, cases are accelerating at a greater rate than Sydney and the city features on the news every night for all the wrong reasons.

Ian K
WA, 4162 posts
27 Sep 2021 8:03AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote

Kamikuza said..

What's your point?

What's the point? I thought the point was obvious. It's an airline company conspiracy. They sell super cheap flights to Bali. Complimentary champagne, mood lighting. chances are you'll hook up with a girl who's not from Rockingham. Then they've got you for life, BAFing about the planet, his folks her folks...

Kamikuza
QLD, 6493 posts
27 Sep 2021 12:35PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Ian K said..



Kamikuza said..


What's your point?


What's the point? I thought the point was obvious. It's an airline company conspiracy. They sell super cheap flights to Bali. Complimentary champagne, mood lighting. chances are you'll hook up with a girl who's not from Rockingham. Then they've got you for life, BAFing about the planet, his folks her folks...



Jackass

FormulaNova
WA, 15090 posts
27 Sep 2021 10:59AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Ian K said..
What's the point? I thought the point was obvious. It's an airline company conspiracy. They sell super cheap flights to Bali. Complimentary champagne, mood lighting. chances are you'll hook up with a girl who's not from Rockingham. Then they've got you for life, BAFing about the planet, his folks her folks...


Hey Ian, this is no place for casual racism. Rockingham people are people too! I think

Where do you think the future generations are going to come from?

kiterboy
2614 posts
27 Sep 2021 1:04PM
Thumbs Up

Double-vaxxed people should be exempt from lockdowns.

GreenPat
QLD, 4096 posts
27 Sep 2021 3:04PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..

Things are too quiet in 'general' at times and you can have a thread that is topical but doesn't get bogged down into conspiracy theories. At least I hope so.


Exactly. I don't see any reason to lock this one. Yet. The other ones have all descended into conspiracy/antivax/shouty arguing, hence their locks. We realize with the closing of HW that people are going to want to chat about politics somewhere and 'general' is the next logical place, so we've been pretty lenient (IMHO). But stuff was just getting silly over the last couple of weeks.

Ian K
WA, 4162 posts
27 Sep 2021 1:23PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote

FormulaNova said..

Where do you think the future generations are going to come from?

I don' know I only mentioned Rocky hoping to wind you up. You're not living next door to Mark are you?



Carantoc
WA, 7189 posts
27 Sep 2021 2:11PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Ian K said..
This flitting around the planet on a whim is why families are spread out in the first place. It's only a very recent blip in human history that we can do it...


Get your point but not sure it is the point.

Humans have been migrating all over this planet since ... since humans evolved. Humanity colonized the whole planet by migrating out of east Africa in a process that has been ongoing for the best part of a 100,000 years.

It may be far easier to travel in the last 50 years, but I'd argue the issue is not the ability to travel but the opportunity to.

The only thing that is a blip is having the opportunity to travel removed by administration or governance. It is not often that humanity has not been 'allowed' to travel.

We are not trees or plants. We have legs and have evolved with curiosity and the itch to see what is over the horizon. The concept of nation states and fixed borders isn't very old either. The idea that individuals are prevented from access to a piece of land due purely to a line on a map is even less old.


FN asks why ScoMo wants to open the country. Seems a weird question if he is seriously asking it and I'd suggest the answer is very simple if you look at it from the opposite perspective,

Why doesn't the government want to keep us locked up indefinitely ?

KiteboyDave
87 posts
27 Sep 2021 4:15PM
Thumbs Up

Scomo should hold vaccines and funding from rogue states who refuse to open. There is a point that all states need to agree that we become one country again.

Number
WA, 108 posts
27 Sep 2021 4:22PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
KiteboyDave said..
Scomo should hold vaccines and funding from rogue states who refuse to open. There is a point that all states need to agree that we become one country again.


He's already doing both from Labour ran states, so it wouldn't make a big difference.

Or maybe WA should withhold funding from the rest of Australia ;)

psychojoe
WA, 2239 posts
27 Sep 2021 4:27PM
Thumbs Up

It appears to be missing from this conversation that opening shouldn't be done while lockdowns remain a possible direction.
Lockdowns are far worse than border closings.

Subsonic
WA, 3374 posts
27 Sep 2021 4:32PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
KiteboyDave said..
Scomo should hold vaccines and funding from rogue states who refuse to open. There is a point that all states need to agree that we become one country again.




That would be completely counter productive, given said states have said they will open up when vaccination targets are met.

the best thing they could do is make the vaccinations as easy to get as possible in said states. Set up vaccination hubs in peoples faces. At major events (the grand final wouldve been a good oppurtunity). have "vaccination days" at work when a nurse rocks up at work, and vaccinates everyone. I reckon half the "vaccine hesitant" are actually just too lazy, or genuinely too busy to book an appointment.

punishing a state for not wanting to open its borders earlier than they are ready for to other covid infested states isn't going to help the situation at all.

KiteboyDave
87 posts
27 Sep 2021 4:40PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Subsonic said..
That would be completely counter productive, given said states have said they will open up when vaccination targets are met.

the best thing they could do is make the vaccinations as easy to get as possible in said states. Set up vaccination hubs in peoples faces. At major events (the grand final wouldve been a good oppurtunity). have "vaccination days" at work when a nurse rocks up at work, and vaccinates everyone. I reckon half the "vaccine hesitant" are actually just too lazy, or genuinely too busy to book an appointment.

punishing a state for not wanting to open its borders earlier than they are ready for to other covid infested states isn't going to help the situation at all.

I applaud Qantas decision to punish WA for keeping the state locked up.

UncleBob
NSW, 1301 posts
27 Sep 2021 7:16PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
KiteboyDave said..

Subsonic said..
That would be completely counter productive, given said states have said they will open up when vaccination targets are met.

the best thing they could do is make the vaccinations as easy to get as possible in said states. Set up vaccination hubs in peoples faces. At major events (the grand final wouldve been a good oppurtunity). have "vaccination days" at work when a nurse rocks up at work, and vaccinates everyone. I reckon half the "vaccine hesitant" are actually just too lazy, or genuinely too busy to book an appointment.

punishing a state for not wanting to open its borders earlier than they are ready for to other covid infested states isn't going to help the situation at all.


I applaud Qantas decision to punish WA for keeping the state locked up.


It's not about punishing, it's the practical reality and liability of bringing people into a state where they don't have the option to move around at will. A little difficult to sell and to manage.

Pugwash
WA, 7729 posts
27 Sep 2021 5:44PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
KiteboyDave said..

Subsonic said..
That would be completely counter productive, given said states have said they will open up when vaccination targets are met.

the best thing they could do is make the vaccinations as easy to get as possible in said states. Set up vaccination hubs in peoples faces. At major events (the grand final wouldve been a good oppurtunity). have "vaccination days" at work when a nurse rocks up at work, and vaccinates everyone. I reckon half the "vaccine hesitant" are actually just too lazy, or genuinely too busy to book an appointment.

punishing a state for not wanting to open its borders earlier than they are ready for to other covid infested states isn't going to help the situation at all.


I applaud Qantas decision to punish WA for keeping the state locked up.


Punishment?

Qantas has no choice. It won't be viable. WA will open when ready. I hope it's after NSW and Victoria let it rip and the next wave is out of puff. April next feels about right.

KiteboyDave
87 posts
27 Sep 2021 6:06PM
Thumbs Up

The backwater should and will be punished by the dominant and superior eastern states.

I went to Perth once and thought the place was twee.

Full of uneducated bogans with huge chips on their shoulders, probably because they are just so isolated from civilisation and live in an overly policed and corrupt 'Rolf Harris' state.

Looking at their fashion and eating at some of their crappy restaurants I estimated that they must be 5 years behind even sh1t towns in eastern states.

CH3MTR4IL5
WA, 939 posts
27 Sep 2021 6:16PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
KiteboyDave said..

Looking at their fashion and eating at some of their crappy restaurants I estimated that they must be 5 years behind even sh1t towns in eastern states.


yep, checks out, no covid 5 years ago.

CH3MTR4IL5
WA, 939 posts
27 Sep 2021 6:27PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..
I think in NSW's defence, Delta was a surprise. I think the rest of Australia are lucky that it wasn't them that got hit with it first as they would have had the same thing happen, WA included.

Its easy to say that they should have shut down hard, easy in hindsight, but I don't think any other state would have done it differently.


Well WA did it differently with exactly the same scenario. Three delta cases in late June. WA locked down straight away and the result is 12 days of lockdown for the whole pandemic.

Before that, we locked down for one case of delta in February because the evidence of transmissibility was pretty clear.

more to NSW's defence, they were following the Commonwealth playbook and their previous approach had worked.

Pugwash
WA, 7729 posts
27 Sep 2021 6:49PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
KiteboyDave said..
The backwater should and will be punished by the dominant and superior eastern states.

I went to Perth once and thought the place was twee.

Full of uneducated bogans with huge chips on their shoulders, probably because they are just so isolated from civilisation and live in an overly policed and corrupt 'Rolf Harris' state.

Looking at their fashion and eating at some of their crappy restaurants I estimated that they must be 5 years behind even sh1t towns in eastern states.


You post this and you think it is WA with a chip on its shoulder. Hilarious.

Subsonic
WA, 3374 posts
27 Sep 2021 7:23PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
KiteboyDave said..
The backwater should and will be punished by the dominant and superior eastern states.

I went to Perth once and thought the place was twee.

Full of uneducated bogans with huge chips on their shoulders, probably because they are just so isolated from civilisation and live in an overly policed and corrupt 'Rolf Harris' state.

Looking at their fashion and eating at some of their crappy restaurants I estimated that they must be 5 years behind even sh1t towns in eastern states.


Thanks for confirming that you're just here to troll again.

cauncy
WA, 8407 posts
27 Sep 2021 8:28PM
Thumbs Up

I've see number plates in WA from Victoria
With the education state on them
These are the clever ones

KiteboyDave
87 posts
27 Sep 2021 8:54PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
cauncy said..
I've see number plates in WA from Victoria
With the education state on them
These are the clever ones


WA the Rolf Harris State

Pugwash
WA, 7729 posts
27 Sep 2021 9:47PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
KiteboyDave said..

cauncy said..
I've see number plates in WA from Victoria
With the education state on them
These are the clever ones



WA the Rolf Harris State


Are you ok Dave? Bored in lockdown? Feel the need to attempt to antagonise folks on the intywebs by saying silly and nasty thing?

We've been here before and when your gone, no doubts we'll be here again.

Razzonater
2224 posts
28 Sep 2021 6:41AM
Thumbs Up

Half the reason the government wants us to open up is to get the planes off the ground again.
Billions and billions of dollars of planes globally that are not being maintained properly as their is no income.... just sitting in hangars and open air runways with bearings rusting and fuel lines clogging up...
I will be happy when we open up for sure once everyone is vaccinated but I certainly will not be getting on a long haul flight for at least 6-12 months after once all the planes have had money spent and maintenance done on them.

Im serious you want to jump on a plane from Australia to London that's had 2 flights in 24 months ....

airsail
QLD, 1565 posts
28 Sep 2021 9:32AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Razzonater said..
Half the reason the government wants us to open up is to get the planes off the ground again.
Billions and billions of dollars of planes globally that are not being maintained properly as their is no income.... just sitting in hangars and open air runways with bearings rusting and fuel lines clogging up...
I will be happy when we open up for sure once everyone is vaccinated but I certainly will not be getting on a long haul flight for at least 6-12 months after once all the planes have had money spent and maintenance done on them.

Im serious you want to jump on a plane from Australia to London that's had 2 flights in 24 months ....



You have absolutely no idea of aircraft maintenance and how it is carried out. There is scheduled hourly maintenance and calendar maintence. If the aircraft flys 10 hours, certain maintenance must be carried out, but even if the aircraft doesn't fly, every week, month etc the calendar maintenance must be carried out.


I'm an aircraft maintenance engineer, there hasn't been any downtime for engineers during lockdowns, crews are still running aircraft weekly and carrying out maintenance as required. The aircraft are in better condition now than before the pandemic as the crews have time to get all the faults fixed.



Subscribe
Topic Is Locked

This topic has been locked

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"Why does the government want us to open up?" started by FormulaNova