Forums > Sailing General

In search of a cruising yacht - advice appreciated

Reply
Created by Windjana > 9 months ago, 31 Jan 2015
Charriot
QLD, 880 posts
3 Feb 2015 1:36PM
Thumbs Up

sorry to disappoint you McNice
but.....there is shortage of nice blokes
..........they don't stay single for long,
...........married one don't get many chances to be happy again

McNaughtical
NSW, 908 posts
3 Feb 2015 2:46PM
Thumbs Up

Yes, you are right about the shortage of nice blokes.....
.... I like the McNice name

Windjana
WA, 405 posts
3 Feb 2015 12:18PM
Thumbs Up

Lots of information to digest there guys!

I am ordering a few books of reference form boat books, looking forward to them arriving on the front door step.

I have a looonnng shortlist - if there is such a thing, of boats I think would be suitable. Ranging from a well equipped Mottle at $50k to a $190k catamaran! Plenty of good mono's to choose from in the $100k - $200k range. As LMY mentioned, early days yet in the search for the right yacht.

Ramona, I was a Greenie (Sparktrician for non Navy people) in the RAN.
Joined as a JR in 1980, did 9yrs, served on Brisbane and Moresby then got out and got a job earning some decent money.

FreeRadical, thanks for the advice and I have been snooping around Koombana Bay SC in Bunbury. I'm planning to buy the boat while I am over east late this year or early next, so that should give me a lot more to choose from. Although I would like to cruise up the top end, I'm not sure whether I would bring the yacht all the way back to WA or not at this stage.

Has anyone got any thoughts on GRP vs Steel vs Aluminium?

Thanks to everyone for all the advice so far.

Cheers!



Savannah
QLD, 45 posts
3 Feb 2015 2:24PM
Thumbs Up

N&Z, I too was a JR 1983 & served on Brisbane, when were you there

LooseChange
NSW, 2140 posts
3 Feb 2015 3:41PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Savannah said..
N&Z, I too was a JR 1983 & served on Brisbane, when were you there


I spose as long as you weren't birdies or them other things he was bangin on about, Cisco would be happy with that.

Savannah
QLD, 45 posts
3 Feb 2015 2:49PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
LooseChange said..

Savannah said..
N&Z, I too was a JR 1983 & served on Brisbane, when were you there



I spose as long as you weren't birdies or them other things he was bangin on about, Cisco would be happy with that.


Nah mate, I was a Dibbie

Windjana
WA, 405 posts
3 Feb 2015 12:54PM
Thumbs Up

72 intake, July 1980 to May 81 at Leeuwin.
Would've been about 82 - 83 I was on Brisbane, getting old and crusty, can't remember the exact dates.
Did Rimpac 82 not long after that transferred back to the west.

Windjana
WA, 405 posts
4 Feb 2015 6:57AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
FreeRadical said..
Hi NowandZen,

As Cisco mentioned, we (syndicate of 4) bought a Delphia 40 In Airlie Beach and brought it over the top to Perth. RiffRaff on this forum is doing the same in a Delphia 40 as well.

I think the very first thing to consider for WA (Perth) is a home for your boat. Unless you can lower the mast, you're looking at a marina berth, which will cost a bit and have been difficult to get over recent years. With the declining economy, it might get a bit easier though. A lot of marina pens go from 12m LOA size to next 15m and the price jumps accordingly (like several thousand dollars per year), just something to consider in the equation.

Get out and see a few of the boats advertised for an initial look, look at various sizes, prices, ages etc. You'll start to know what is of interest and narrow the range of variables very quickly. Generally there's not the range nor competitive prices in WA compared to East, but enough to get you started, and you never know what you'll find. Also check out the boats are around the marinas. Bavaria appear to be popular here, there's quite a few in our marina. I don't know exactly why?

Browse Yachthub etc a couple of times every week and checkout what's for sale, watch the prices, what sells quickly, what reduces over time etc.

Our boat is at Hillarys, send me a PM if you'd like to take a look/sail. Our club is quite social and crew spots are easy to get, come along on weekend race days and at the briefing you'll get a ride. I'm sure just about all clubs are the same and it's a good way to check out lots of boats and speak with owners as well as get some experience.




Hey FreeRadical,

I was wondering if you could give me some insight into your trip from Airlie Beach to Perth?
How long did it take you?
Did you have favorable winds or did you use the motor for the most part?

Cheers!

Ramona
NSW, 7727 posts
4 Feb 2015 7:23PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
NowandZen said..


Ramona, I was a Greenie (Sparktrician for non Navy people) in the RAN.
Joined as a JR in 1980, did 9yrs, served on Brisbane and Moresby then got out and got a job earning some decent money.







I was a Cerberus JR, April '64. Dibdab for the first 6 years. Had 12 months at Leeuwin in '69 as the seamanship and boatwork instructor [12 months teaching Jr's how to eye splice]. Changed over to aircrew for another 14 years. Then 26 years as a fisherman. I still think of myself as ex navy primarily!

MorningBird
NSW, 2699 posts
4 Feb 2015 8:25PM
Thumbs Up

Aircrew intake mid 72. Flying in the Fleet Air Arm till 86, with Ramona till early 80s. Then a variety of jobs including at WATERHEN and paid off from PLATYPUS in 98. A few of us on here.

cisco
QLD, 12361 posts
4 Feb 2015 11:00PM
Thumbs Up


I was a MOBI intake on the 6/6/1966. Them's some evil numbers.

Became an Engine Room Artificer (Diesel). That was being condemned to Stalwart, Moresby or Patrol Boats.

The first three and a half years of my naval career was spent at R.A.N.A.T.E. (Royal Australian Navy Apprentice Training Establishment) H.M.A.S. Nirimba. I do believe anybody trained at Nirimba during that era was highly privileged, no matter which trade they were in because the training was first class and amongst the best available in Australia at the time.

A further year and a half was spent by each trainee with "on the job" training to complete the five year apprenticeship.

Two and a half years later, the Navy and I reached an agreement that we would part company on amicable terms.

I was a tad too critical of the double standards that were prevalent during the Navy's transition from SAILSTRUC to RATSTRUC. I was an ERA2 and objected to being downgraded to PO MTP while PO Stokers less qualified than I were being upgraded to PO MTP.

Upon mutual agreement the Navy and I agreed we were not suitable for each other, four and a half years short of our agreed sign up time.

I have never regretted a moment of my Naval service but for me it was the best career change possible.

cisco
QLD, 12361 posts
4 Feb 2015 11:06PM
Thumbs Up


Back on topic.........In search of a cruising yacht - advice appreciated

Nowand Zen, think back to the best sailing experience you have ever had and the yacht upon which it happened, then, move forward from there.

Ramona
NSW, 7727 posts
5 Feb 2015 9:31AM
Thumbs Up

I think you should stick with fibreglass. I also think you should stick with aft cockpit vessels. Spend a bit of time in an aft cabin boat on a mooring on a hot still day and see if you can stand it. In a marina you can run a couple of electric fans. What most people find when they head off from temperate weather places to the tropics is deck lounging space and shade. I mean full length shade. Even in places like Sydney its nice to be able to sleep in the cockpit.

Steel has some advantages. It can handle hitting reefs etc and repairs are cheap and easy. They are becoming really cheap though as most people are realizing there is a lot of upkeep and sometimes hidden horrors. It not quite like when you were an OD wielding a Jason pistol. Yachts are built thin. Friend of mine has an Adams 45 in steel. I thought it looked very good. Its up on the hard for six months at the moment, I had a quick look at it yesterday. Trouble with these is six months blows out. The yard its in is full of yachts [Huskisson] many of these yachts I have never seen in the water.
Aluminium is fine but once again you have to be careful with maintenance. I would consider a bare aluminium hulled yacht. I had an aluminium fishing vessel built in WA when I left the navy. Biggest mistake was having the factory paint it. I used to keep her on one of the local wharves which was fine most of the time and was basically just a matter of using the correct antifoul and keep tabs on the anodes. Isolating the skin fittings from alloy etc. The trouble was when one of the other fibreglass or timber fishing vessels tied up alongside me with their copper antifouling paint. Also at low tide steel rubbish on the bottom would also created problems.

If you want to reduce maintenance go fibreglass hull with an encapsulated lead keel.

jev7337
QLD, 460 posts
5 Feb 2015 1:26PM
Thumbs Up

Just another one to look at. Probably one of the more serious cruising yachts IMO. You could probably get it for under 200k and it will have most of what you need already on board.
http://yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/ovni-385/163785

cisco
QLD, 12361 posts
5 Feb 2015 11:06PM
Thumbs Up


Nice yacht but waaaaay over priced.

Ramona
NSW, 7727 posts
6 Feb 2015 9:24AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
cisco said..

Nice yacht but waaaaay over priced.


True. If you wanted to go the Ovni way budget for a holiday in Noumea.

jev7337
QLD, 460 posts
6 Feb 2015 4:19PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
cisco said..

Nice yacht but waaaaay over priced.


What do you think would be a realistic price for this one?

cisco
QLD, 12361 posts
6 Feb 2015 11:45PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
jev7337 said..

cisco said..

Nice yacht but waaaaay over priced.



What do you think would be a realistic price for this one?


I am thinking about half that price and that is only if everything is mickey spit.

Ramona
NSW, 7727 posts
7 Feb 2015 9:43AM
Thumbs Up



That is a lovely ship and well priced as well. The centreboard idea is fine in principal, enables the vessel much closer inshore but adds extra maintenance problems. The costs of just simple stuff like antifouling for that vessel would be enormous. Probably looking at 20 litres of antifoul. Would have to be done on a travel lift [or crane] so your limited to ports. I would be concerned that when the board is raised and in shallow water the boat didn't settle on some debris and get lodged in the case. Not many centreboard yachts in Australia and I think most people have the same concerns.

RiffRaff
WA, 265 posts
7 Feb 2015 7:34AM
Thumbs Up

Ramona said..


That is a lovely ship and well priced as well. The centreboard idea is fine in principal, enables the vessel much closer inshore but adds extra maintenance problems. The costs of just simple stuff like antifouling for that vessel would be enormous. Probably looking at 20 litres of antifoul. Would have to be done on a travel lift [or crane] so your limited to ports. I would be concerned that when the board is raised and in shallow water the boat didn't settle on some debris and get lodged in the case. Not many centreboard yachts in Australia and I think most people have the same concerns.



I think in the price range and size mentioned then you are most likely looking at a haul out to carry out underwater maintenance on most vessels.
I understand that a keel jamming could be a concern with a swing keel.
Not sure why antifouling would be any more expensive than any other fixed keel yacht of that size.

LooseChange
NSW, 2140 posts
7 Feb 2015 10:52AM
Thumbs Up

My main concern with a swing keel/centreboard is not much that it may jam but rather it becomes another point of potential failure.

Having said that, Ted Hood has designed quite a few centreboard boats and one would assume he knows what he is doing.

sirgallivant
NSW, 1531 posts
7 Feb 2015 11:12AM
Thumbs Up

This one works per

fe

ct

ly

ever since been built, it is an Adams after all, even after this escaped...

McNaughtical
NSW, 908 posts
7 Feb 2015 11:45AM
Thumbs Up

RiffRaff said..

Ramona said..




That is a lovely ship and well priced as well. The centreboard idea is fine in principal, enables the vessel much closer inshore but adds extra maintenance problems. The costs of just simple stuff like antifouling for that vessel would be enormous. Probably looking at 20 litres of antifoul. Would have to be done on a travel lift [or crane] so your limited to ports. I would be concerned that when the board is raised and in shallow water the boat didn't settle on some debris and get lodged in the case. Not many centreboard yachts in Australia and I think most people have the same concerns.


I think in the price range and size mentioned then you are most likely looking at a haul out to carry out underwater maintenance on most vessels.
I understand that a keel jamming could be a concern with a swing keel.
Not sure why antifouling would be any more expensive than any other fixed keel yacht of that size.



I havea centreboard... Tartan 37 S&S...I have not had the centreboard down... last time out of the water for survey it was sitting on tibmer so of course could not get board down, so have not worked out why it won't go down. Previous owner said he sailed all the way from Florida without it.

LooseChange
NSW, 2140 posts
7 Feb 2015 12:38PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
McNaughtical said..


I have a centreboard... Tartan 37 S&S...I have not had the centreboard down... last time out of the water for survey it was sitting on tibmer so of course could not get board down, so have not worked out why it won't go down. Previous owner said he sailed all the way from Florida without it.



In the case of the Tartan I don't think the absence of the centreboard would affect the stability of the boat, but it would affect the the pointing ability by a few degrees.

Tartan with board down



McNaughtical
NSW, 908 posts
7 Feb 2015 2:34PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
LooseChange said..

McNaughtical said..


I have a centreboard... Tartan 37 S&S...I have not had the centreboard down... last time out of the water for survey it was sitting on tibmer so of course could not get board down, so have not worked out why it won't go down. Previous owner said he sailed all the way from Florida without it.


In the case of the Tartan I don't think the absence of the centreboard would affect the stability of the boat, but it would affect the the pointing ability by a few degrees.
Tartan with board down


Oh... cool... thanks Loose Change... so probably doesn't matter if mine doesn't come down then. She gets along fine.

MEGAMAX
WA, 83 posts
7 Feb 2015 5:00PM
Thumbs Up

A few of us here...JR 65th intake (Oct 78)...did RIMPAC 80 in Melbourne (Morningbird are you there 79-82?), RIMPAC 82 in BRISBANE (we must have been there together N&Z)(Miss Brisbane was a stunner...), was an RP and ASAC then changed over to pusser. Did 26 years all up.


MorningBird
NSW, 2699 posts
7 Feb 2015 8:42PM
Thumbs Up

I was on VS816 Squadron (Trackers) on MELBOURNE for the Indian Ocean trip in 1980. Missed RIMPAC 80 flying out of RAAF DARWIN. We might have crossed paths Megamax. I spent a fair bit of time with ASACs, on MELBOURNE, FFG SYDNEY (1984) and at WATSON.

Ramona
NSW, 7727 posts
8 Feb 2015 9:02AM
Thumbs Up

McNaughtical said..

RiffRaff said..


Ramona said..






That is a lovely ship and well priced as well. The centreboard idea is fine in principal, enables the vessel much closer inshore but adds extra maintenance problems. The costs of just simple stuff like antifouling for that vessel would be enormous. Probably looking at 20 litres of antifoul. Would have to be done on a travel lift [or crane] so your limited to ports. I would be concerned that when the board is raised and in shallow water the boat didn't settle on some debris and get lodged in the case. Not many centreboard yachts in Australia and I think most people have the same concerns.



I think in the price range and size mentioned then you are most likely looking at a haul out to carry out underwater maintenance on most vessels.
I understand that a keel jamming could be a concern with a swing keel.
Not sure why antifouling would be any more expensive than any other fixed keel yacht of that size.




I havea centreboard... Tartan 37 S&S...I have not had the centreboard down... last time out of the water for survey it was sitting on tibmer so of course could not get board down, so have not worked out why it won't go down. Previous owner said he sailed all the way from Florida without it.


I rest my case.

And for Riffraff the centreboard and the inside of the case need antifouling as well, even though a fair percentage would disappear the first time its lowered. My 40 foot fishing vessel took 10 litres of antifoul per coat. The wetted area of a 45 ft yacht is about the same. My Currawong takes under 4 litres each time I slip and is almost a pleasure to paint.

That centreboard slot must do wonders for water flow!

RiffRaff
WA, 265 posts
8 Feb 2015 8:24AM
Thumbs Up

Still don’t get it. What is the difference between antifouling a centre board / swing keel to antifouling a fixed keel. Does it use more paint?
At the end of the day we are talking about boats up to 200K for extensive cruising we are not talking about a weekender. With 200K comes ongoing costs and these costs need to be expended to protect your investment.
Things go wrong on a boat, that is accepted. I think the idea of being able to get in to an area where a draft of 2 mts plus prohibits has some merit.
I recently invested 175K on a boat which has a draft of 2.1 meters, the excessive draft is my only regret, particularly for coastal cruising.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Sailing General


"In search of a cruising yacht - advice appreciated" started by Windjana