Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk

2007 GPS Team "Challenge" Begins 01/05/07

Reply
Created by hardie > 9 months ago, 12 Apr 2007
Gestalt
QLD, 14629 posts
16 Apr 2007 10:06PM
Thumbs Up

quote:
Originally posted by hardie

Thanx for all thge replies so far.

It will be impossible to keep everyone happy on this one.

I think the "Keep It Simple" philosophy needs to win out here. Re GPS Max Display, it is simple, verifiable for every sailor after each run, no need for downloads, and The most respected speed sailor in Aus came up with some technical reasons for it. This is not the World Champoinship of speed, ISSR ratified, it's just for fun and participation.

The GPSSS is for the more serious and technically minded, so no need to duplicate what they are doing, if ya only wanna be deadly serious then stay with the GPSSS.

At this stage there hasn't been a huge amount of interest with only one team from WA and one team from NSW, and one victorian individual. If Sponsors wanna try and push it by advertising it more seriously, and get more interest, then I'll leave that to them.




Hi Hardie,

i wouldn't worry to much about the slow response rates. i believe with all of these things it's a case of build it and they will come.

one thing i have found organising events over the last year is that not everyone will hit the send button. with some events i've done i've had only 4-5 people email me but have seen 20-30 turn up on the day. i think that just reflects the surfer heart that lies within most windsurfers. casual and relaxed. it's good to see you trying none the less.

you can count me in on things. i know that there are a few guys in brissy talking about it.

my 2 cents worth :-

i'm not bothered either way if it's max speed display or 5x10 sec average. i'll still have fun. although the 5x10 sec average has been adopted by most for very good reasons. some of the tracks i have verified in the past have had max speeds of 2000 knots. plus each gps reads differently so the averages make it more real. but max display opens it to people with lesser featured gps devices.

i think for prizes lucky draws work the best. gives the average blokes a chance.

my last idea and one i have had for a while is to do something which may apeal to your "Comrades" and is seeing things from a different perspective too! why not have a rocket air category. gps devices also measure height. give the wave guys something to go for.
all you do is minus the max height from the average heaight taken from the session when sailing along normally.

yoyo
WA, 1646 posts
17 Apr 2007 10:58AM
Thumbs Up

"why not have a rocket air category. gps devices also measure height..."

Not with any accuracy. Vertical accuracies with consumer gps units of 10-20 meters are not uncommon.

see here for detailed explanation..

weather.gladstonefamily.net/gps_elevation.html

Yo

Gestalt
QLD, 14629 posts
18 Apr 2007 12:25AM
Thumbs Up

quote:
Originally posted by yoyo

"why not have a rocket air category. gps devices also measure height..."

Not with any accuracy. Vertical accuracies with consumer gps units of 10-20 meters are not uncommon.

see here for detailed explanation..

weather.gladstonefamily.net/gps_elevation.html

Yo



bugger, didn't realise it was that inaccurate. read through the links. cheers.

but as i am ever the optimist. wouldn't the inaccuracy be substantially reduced if you take the average height away from the max height. all you are left with is a figure in meters.

25
WA, 319 posts
17 Apr 2007 11:01PM
Thumbs Up

Great initiative Hardie
I'll have a team in this dig too - I'll advise my team mates in due course - soon - hopefully
Vando / Kato etc - this is the 2007 GPS Winter Storm "Challenge"
This is not the late spring / summer challenge
Get out the fat rubber guys!
There is method in Hardie's madness [I think]
The more the merrier!
Remember - the reason we wear these things on our arms is that we are inherently competitive people - ever with ourselves

wesdawindat
WA, 133 posts
18 Apr 2007 7:54AM
Thumbs Up

All sounds like fun, I'de be keen if i could jump on a Perth or say Mandarah team. New to Perth and an ex Sandy Point tryhard speedster.
So could get back into my favourite part of winsurfin, crashin 35kn+, breaking gear. Windsurfing Shops here i come....!

Lenny

wesdawindat
WA, 133 posts
18 Apr 2007 8:08AM
Thumbs Up

Hey while i think of it, what sort of winds do we expect here in the winter, i may may need to update a sail or 2 for local conditions?

Cheers Lenny

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
18 Apr 2007 8:21AM
Thumbs Up

quote:
Originally posted by wesdawindat

All sounds like fun, I'de be keen if i could jump on a Perth or say Mandarah team. New to Perth and an ex Sandy Point tryhard speedster.
So could get back into my favourite part of winsurfin, crashin 35kn+, breaking gear. Windsurfing Shops here i come....!

Lenny



You're welcome to join our team, however, 25 is getting a perth team togther, so whatever suits you better?

Re: winter conditions = wild and stormy to totally calm disappointment

We have some winter runs sussed which will not be publicly advertised, but if you are serious you can join us on our trecks, but public divulgement of these spots could cost you your.........

mathew
QLD, 2133 posts
18 Apr 2007 12:37PM
Thumbs Up

For the SP advantage, there are few ways that I can think of that would give us a suitable handicap:

- exclude Shallow Inlet altogether -> there are other spots where would could sail, eg: Inverloch, or out in the SP surf, the Bay in Melbourne.
- making guying part of it (aka alpha racing)
- make distance a factor -> SP is limited in length to about 1km at most and through rough water too.
- Limit us to big'ish sails, say 5.5 or bigger depending on body weight -> this should limit most of the guys speeds to something realistic.

Mathew

PS. Hi Vando, I definitely would be in the SP team and loving it...! Although I do agree that the SP advantage is a little unfair... :-)

wesdawindat
WA, 133 posts
18 Apr 2007 9:42PM
Thumbs Up

Sweet thanks hardie, sounds good can make up the numbers if ones short or whatever, look forward to it. Bring on the Fronts.

The SP advantage???? not realy sure what this is. top speed spot.
Is it the 5kn out going tide when the SWester blowin down the speed course?

Hey Mat your so tinny with the prizes too in the comps......
Any handycap ya wanna give yaselves down at the pit im sure would be welcomed

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
19 Apr 2007 8:15PM
Thumbs Up

My current thinking after reviewing all thread feedback, private emails, and personal consultations is as follows:

The challenge gives us an oppurtunity to set up a data base, similar to GPSSS.

We have 4 main team categories:

Either Max GPS or 2 sec GPS max
500m
5 x 10sec
Alpha racing

or 1 hr or Nautical mile, or 6 categories, with different states sponsoring each trophy?


A trophy for each team in the best category of each, no matter where it's set, so if anyone goes to Sandy Point and sets it there it holds.

For individuals, it's personal bragging rights only. That is, scan the data base, see what category you are in and check your performance.

What do you think my fragile little Pets?

mineral1
WA, 4564 posts
19 Apr 2007 10:16PM
Thumbs Up

Sounds bloody good to me. Best bit is I only have to play, and log and get tips from all the Guru's. Somebody is doing all the back ground work You are good at it but and we all think your a fine upstanding chap
Seriously though, big thanks for your effort here. And its only in its infancy
Will travel to play, so dont hide the good tracks too much
Mineral

black dog
SA, 42 posts
19 Apr 2007 11:57PM
Thumbs Up

sorry i think I am missing something here, any help in seeing the light would be gladly appreciated

quote:
The challenge gives us an oppurtunity to set up a data base, similar to GPSSS.


Doesn't the need4speed database on the windwarrior site offer the same thing ?
I thought the point of the need4speed was a free database and 'friendly' comp for those not interested or able to perform at the GPS Speed Sailing level or without the restrictions imposed by GPS SS .
Whats' more its for Aussie sailors recording their speeds in Australian waters
By the looks there are now categories on the need4speed for each state so if you can't claim the 'overall' bragging rights you still have the chance to claim it for your state ?

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
19 Apr 2007 10:38PM
Thumbs Up

quote:
Originally posted by black dog

sorry i think I am missing something here, any help in seeing the light would be gladly appreciated
quote:
The challenge gives us an oppurtunity to set up a data base, similar to GPSSS.


Doesn't the need4speed database on the windwarrior site offer the same thing ?
I thought the point of the need4speed was a free database and 'friendly' comp for those not interested or able to perform at the GPS Speed Sailing level or without the restrictions imposed by GPS SS .
Aussie sailors recording their speeds registered in Australian waters
By the looks there are now categories for each state so if you can't claim the 'overall' bragging rights you still have the chance to claim it for your state ?




Windwarrior is one of the major sponsors, so this team based comp will sit along side Need4Speed. Nothing is finalised yet, but I imagine at this stage that part of their sponsorship will be to set up this data base and maintain it.

Inclusiveness, Participation, Fun and Building Relationships are the key, participate and do it for fun, or get as seriously competitive as you want! Something for everyone!!!!!! Already people are forming teams all around australia, so the relationship building is already happening. The Mandurah Mob has no intentions of winning anything except increasing our involvement and having fun together.

If this proves successful, it can only grow, but hopefully with the 4 aforementioned philosophical points at its core, or else it will lose something.

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
19 Apr 2007 10:43PM
Thumbs Up

I would like the database to include state categories, as well as Age divisions in each state, and then each sub-category of measurement whether it be max gpos, 1 hr, 5 x 10 sec, alpha etc.

Gives more oppurtunities for Australian sailors who sail in Aussie waters to compare apples with bananas, or whatever that medically ill saying is

Gestalt
QLD, 14629 posts
20 Apr 2007 12:59AM
Thumbs Up

hi hardie, love your work so far.

all the categories sound brilliant. alpha being my favourite.

keeping it team based is a must for me. what do we do there. add all the times up and divide by the number of members to get the final figure from each team.

also there is a way of watching all the gps tracks overlayed on the web. for example with the alpha class it would be like a virtual slalom race.

cheers.

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
19 Apr 2007 11:10PM
Thumbs Up

quote:
Originally posted by Gestalt

hi hardie, love your work so far.

all the categories sound brilliant. alpha being my favourite.

keeping it team based is a must for me. what do we do there. add all the times up and divide by the number of members to get the final figure from each team.

also there is a way of watching all the gps tracks overlayed on the web. for example with the alpha class it would be like a virtual slalom race.

cheers.



I imagine that the team captain will lodge the "session" data for each category, ie. Mannduirah Mob 5 sailors 31kts 33kts 32kts 30kts 34 kts = 161kts divided by 5 sailors = 32.16 kts, this is logged in as the data for MM for the given category.

And yes people can be as creative as they like with the data. But the comp is team based. Need4Speed is for individuals, and the data base is also for bragging rights for individuals.

Each team can decide what they concentrate on given the conditions, eg. Today the conditions suit Alpha let's all try that...... Today the speed run looks flat and the wind howling, let's all go for max speed..//etc.......

elmo
WA, 8868 posts
19 Apr 2007 11:18PM
Thumbs Up

aaaargh begone evil gybing

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
19 Apr 2007 11:20PM
Thumbs Up

quote:
Originally posted by elmo

aaaargh begone evil gybing



The Mandurah Mob, will obviously never have the conditions that suit Alpha Racing

Crash Landing
NSW, 1173 posts
20 Apr 2007 10:15AM
Thumbs Up

so what is alpha racing?

elmo
WA, 8868 posts
20 Apr 2007 8:21AM
Thumbs Up

quote:
Originally posted by Crash Landing

so what is alpha racing?



Something Nasty designed by sadists with sailing talent who like watching Elmo's dismount spectacularly

http://www.intellimass.com/TrackData/GPS%20Alpha%20Racing%20Top%2010.htm

Crash Landing
NSW, 1173 posts
20 Apr 2007 10:59AM
Thumbs Up

thanks. Looks good. Not.

elmo
WA, 8868 posts
20 Apr 2007 9:21AM
Thumbs Up

quote:
Originally posted by Crash Landing

thanks. Looks good. Not.



Like I said.... Evil

Gybing, the nemesis of Elmo.

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
20 Apr 2007 9:30AM
Thumbs Up

I vote for alpha as well... there are many different competitions where all you've got to do is put up a big expensive sail and then sail broad. Alpha would give the poor guys a bit of a chance

Nick Willey
QLD, 3 posts
20 Apr 2007 11:50AM
Thumbs Up

How do we nominate a team for this GPS Winter Storm Challenge.
I sail in Mackay and have a team of 4 ready to go.
Call us the CQ Ripple Riders

elmo
WA, 8868 posts
20 Apr 2007 10:37AM
Thumbs Up

quote:
Originally posted by Nick Willey

How do we nominate a team for this GPS Winter Storm Challenge.
I sail in Mackay and have a team of 4 ready to go.
Call us the CQ Ripple Riders



Sorry Nick

Under the thread

"Nominate your GPS team here!!!!!!!"

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=27730

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
20 Apr 2007 6:39PM
Thumbs Up

OK we have enough interest "it's on" starts 01/05/07, just finalising rules and data base.

Make sure you nominate/register on nomination thread, and email me your details.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk


"2007 GPS Team "Challenge" Begins 01/05/07" started by hardie