They mention the ends being glued on. I wonder if they will offer tuttle options or convertible like Fanatic does. Would make for a sweet windfoil cross over mast.
Hopefully they have the galvanic corrosion figured out, aluminum and carbon in constant contact are not a good mix.
I'm guessing they probably float at that weight too.
I has one of these. A real nice mast. I opted for Cedrus in the end-much stiffer with interchangable adaptors.
In response to your query-very different and competing companies that have very different masts.
I just purchase a Nolimitz mast 78cm for an axis foil and I must say that I am disappointed by the fit with the fuselage (
). The fit is soo loose that all the flexion must go through the bolts. When I contacted the company, they told me that they "have heard that from a couple customers" and that they "believe it is the result of Axis' loose tolerances on their fuselage inserts". They then suggested me to "take some aluminum foil tape and add some strips to either the inside sides of the fuselage pocket or the sides of our Axis adapter". In my opinion, it makes no sense to have to shim a 1200$US mast with aluminum tape.That is indeed annoying. Unfortunately it's true no fuselage is the same. I have 2 black Axis fuse. One is tight one is loose. I wished NL made the adaptor in carbon as it's easy to fix and maintain by putting epoxy around. I've done this on my axis carbon mast to get a tighter fit.
I've a friend that has the same issue with his Axis fuse / Cedrus mast connection.
That's a worry with the NL, I have a to suite Takuma on order with a Stringy fuse.
This is a hard one. Do you blame Axis build tolerances or NL for not making something to suit? It's hard to blame a third party however when the brand doesn't have consistent standards. Here I'd say NL is in the right, sure it's an expensive mast, but I had to warranty a G2 axis carbon mast on delivery as it did the exact same.
I have a Cedrus mast and the connection to Axis fuses ( I have 3) and Lift are very good. We always see the bad news but sometimes the what we don't hear is that the majority have no issues.
That is indeed annoying. Unfortunately it's true no fuselage is the same. I have 2 black Axis fuse. One is tight one is loose. I wished NL made the adaptor in carbon as it's easy to fix and maintain by putting epoxy around. I've done this on my axis carbon mast to get a tighter fit.
You can epoxy and aluminum to aluminum connection! The only difference is you can get it apart after! Just a release agent on both parts and use the stick epoxy you kneed with your fingers. Your going to have to clean and re-epoxy the connection each time you assemble and dis assemble but it's quick and easy. Not something if your disassembling daily but it's a fine technique if you leave it assembled and even for a week trip somewhere(where you can leave the connection set up the whole time)
the aluminum foil tape is the easiest solution. put a strip on one side of the fitting, install it and never think about it again. Get used to it, the only joints that won't have this problem to some extent are correctly designed taper fits. Unfortunately, taper fits are out of style - Takuma screwed theirs up so bad that it isn't actually a taper fit and gofoil never caught on.
the aluminum foil tape is the easiest solution. put a strip on one side of the fitting, install it and never think about it again. Get used to it, the only joints that won't have this problem to some extent are correctly designed taper fits. Unfortunately, taper fits are out of style - Takuma screwed theirs up so bad that it isn't actually a taper fit and gofoil never caught on.
Go foil even screwed theirs up!! My most recent RS wings required serious modification. Aguera says the tight fit is confusing to the less technically inclined. If your crafty enough to want a tight taper your crafty enough to make it tight yourself. Although I will say it's easier to make get a bad taper tight than a non taper.
What are people's experiences of the No Limitz masts when winging, especially the 93cm?
In particular, can anyone confirm that they aren't prone to ventilation which can be an issue with the masts from some brands.
I wasn't aware of ventilation until I used a mast with such an issue. I've used many different foils from many brands all without any issue.
I don't know what causes the mast to ventilate but I hate crashing for no obvious reason, especially at speed!
I'd like to know that ventilation isn't going to be a thing if I purchase a No Limitz mast.
Yeah that's not good , have you tried another fuse
Nope... but I have tried aluminium tape... it does not last and I am left with glue and aluminum shreds.
the aluminum foil tape is the easiest solution. put a strip on one side of the fitting, install it and never think about it again. Get used to it, the only joints that won't have this problem to some extent are correctly designed taper fits. Unfortunately, taper fits are out of style - Takuma screwed theirs up so bad that it isn't actually a taper fit and gofoil never caught on.
Go foil even screwed theirs up!! My most recent RS wings required serious modification. Aguera says the tight fit is confusing to the less technically inclined. If your crafty enough to want a tight taper your crafty enough to make it tight yourself. Although I will say it's easier to make get a bad taper tight than a non taper.
Are you using an old mast from when GoFoil wings and masts were a matched set?
All ours fit well from knew and it is just time and wear they eventually requires an approach to enlarging the taper.
What are people's experiences of the No Limitz masts when winging, especially the 93cm?
In particular, can anyone confirm that they aren't prone to ventilation which can be an issue with the masts from some brands.
I wasn't aware of ventilation until I used a mast with such an issue. I've used many different foils from many brands all without any issue.
I don't know what causes the mast to ventilate but I hate crashing for no obvious reason, especially at speed!
I'd like to know that ventilation isn't going to be a thing if I purchase a No Limitz mast.
I haven't experienced any ventilation issues with my NL 85CM.
As for fit issues, I did have a problem with a fit to my F-One, the fuse connection just wasn't as solid as my Cedrus. The mast had
other issue where the base plate was off 2 degrees in relation to the mast.
I bought it through Mackite, sent them couple of pics, they issue me a return directly to NoLimitz to review. Nolimitz said they could
not see anything wrong but they replaced the entire thing because the "mast got damaged in shipping
".
The replacement I got is perfect fit and all aligned. If you buy from a major retailer, they will bend over backwards to satisfy
warranty issues
Hi everyone, Kyle with Project Cedrus here. There are two entries on my blog which are relevant to this discussion, so I wanted to share.
1) projectcedrus.com/cedrus-updates/adapter-shimming/
Regarding mast/fuselage interface/fit, there's no one to blame. It can be manufacturing, simple wear and tear, even environmental. To be honest it hast not been an issue with Cedrus, at least as reported to me, and I am in personal communication with nearly every one of my clients. I was on a kite trip in Baja when I noticed my Lift wings were starting to feel a little loose on my mast, and I started to get really nervous that I was going to have to recall 200+ lift adapters from around the world at this point which would probably put me out of business
. I called Josh at the Foil Shop and he explained that all setups, even full OEM, can experience some "slop" at the connection. He recommended shimming with tape, and I've been good ever since. Only recently have other clients started coming forward, 1 in particular in Australia who was unhappy with the fit of his mast in Axis and Unifoil. I tried to help, but he was not happy with the need to shim. I respect his decision. I have another client in SoCal with 4 masts and I don't even know how many adapters and he's constantly sanding/grinding them to get a perfect fit. I get that some feel a $1,200-$1,300 mast should be a perfect fit every time, but I can tell you from a design/engineering/manufacturing standpoint, it's simply not possible without controlling the whole system and having much tighter tolerances/QC which is obviously going to increase cost. Most brands manufacture in Asia, at higher production rates, so variability is much higher than Cedrus. Many of my adapters are actually designed from CAD supplied directly from the brand, so in theory they should fit exactly the same. But in some cases, they don't... which is obvious evidence that OEM CAD (design data) does not match their manufacturing.
2) projectcedrus.com/cedrus-development/aero/
Ventilation is even more complex and can be caused by a number of things. Of course mast profile is highly impactful, with shorter chord lengths/thicker masts being more prone. However there's a lot more than that, as structural performance can play a big role. A thin mast may ventilate under high torsional loads because the profile can twist causing flow separation. Surface finish is also critical, anything from a pinhole in paint to a damaged trailing edge can cause it. Water surface conditions matter, as small chop can trap air against the mast. In short, ventilation is a lot like a car skidding around a tight corner. Sure a Porsche 911 will perform better than a Land Rover, but all cars will skid when pushed to a limit. And that same Porsche that can turn at a higher speed may not be as fun to drive at slow speeds over rough (wavy) terrain. Much like the above, expecting there to be a perfect foil setup (mast, etc) that will never ventilate is a tall order.
Great masts, but I didnt like the part where I needed an mallet to get the wings on and off, and don,t get my started about traveling with those masts wich was PITA,or the price of it in europe as they are here by far the most expensive set you can buy and because of that virt no dealers or demo gear.. converted we talk about a 4000,- australian dollars for a simple set...
Yes, the Go Foil mast to fuse connection is solid. (pun intended.) Same with Takuma carbon. Both require "fitting" of wings to fuse.
I personally also find frustration in forking out a ton of money and then having to spend more time and money on epoxy, mold release, or beer can origami, just to stop the foil from wobbling. The reality is someone either needs to invent a connection so good, that the other companies will pay royalties and adopt the technology so it's standardized, or perhaps just give up any patents in the hope that everyone follows their idea? But that still doesn't explain to me why if you buy a proprietary system that it can't be close to perfect at least for a while until it wears down.... I find the argument that the cost of production would go up considerably for such quality control to be a bit disheartening as the costs are so high to begin with!
The Starboard QL2 is a damn good connection system. Shame their wings seem to always be a generation behind.
I rode GoFoil for years and I have to agree, their connections are solid. However, a dirty secret is just how many of those 1pc mast/fuse I've broken over the years. They develop a crack right where the front of the mast joins the fuselage and slowly get softer and softer until they break eventually.
The axis system is far superior in my opinion. Fuse to wing connection is very solid, mast to fuse is great. If only they would embrace 30mm bottom mount tails - what's up with doing a 35mm top mount with a special curvy shape???
on topic - I stopped using the NoLimitz because it is just too damn flexy. Its really hard to ride a whippy mast when you've ridden GoFoil, Cedrus, and now the Axis High Modulus.
So what were you riding and what size wings did you have on the No Limitz , which length . Got me worried now I have 2 on order. How does it compare speed wise with the Cedrus.
I have seen photos of the fuse breaking and people losing their foil wings. Hopefully it's not a widespread issue.
I have seen photos of the fuse breaking and people losing their foil wings. Hopefully it's not a widespread issue.
The fuse adaptor on the NL mast? or are you referring to the comments about GoFoil?
I am riding 899/999/1099 exclusively these days. Winging on especially the 1099 and NL mast feels very wobbly, its quite noticeable versus the Cedrus which is quite a bit stiffer. Many have been able to notice less drag from the thin NL profile versus the Cedrus or the 19mm axis aluminum mast system. I personally was not able to notice the difference in drag even though I went back and forth between the two.
nice thing about the gofoil kit is that everything floats. When or if the mast/fuse breaks nothing will sink. when I broke mast/fuse joints it never came clean off, still completely attached, just cracked through and really floppy. I guess if I tried to keep riding it maybe it would break all the way, but it wasn't possible to ride so floppy.On the flip side, I have sunk two sets of wing/fuse/tail kits by broken mast connections. One was a takuma when the M6 mast/fuse bolts sheared off. I recovered that kit the next day by searching the beach half a mile away where it washed up. The other I won't name the brand because they took reasonable care of me with the warranty process. But those parts are likely lost forever.
on topic - I stopped using the NoLimitz because it is just too damn flexy. Its really hard to ride a whippy mast when you've ridden GoFoil, Cedrus, and now the Axis High Modulus.
What is your weight please?
I have seen photos of the fuse breaking and people losing their foil wings. Hopefully it's not a widespread issue.
The fuse adaptor on the NL mast? or are you referring to the comments about GoFoil?
NoLimitz. It seems people are getting their foils replaced when it happens. It's all third hand rumors though. KDmaui's supposed to be running a NoLimitz mast in the upcoming hood river race.
Cedrus may get a little flack for its thickness, even though most clients don't report feeling any more drag. But there has never been a single structural failure/crack or other irreparable damage to the mast in over 4 years of production. I was never a huge fan of these complex conical male/female fuselage pockets, but some brands seem to have better control over their manufacturing of the joint than others. I do continue to believe that two flat and planar surfaces held together by M8 screws is a very reliable, predictable, and strong connection.
Cedrus may get a little flack for its thickness, even though most clients don't report feeling any more drag. But there has never been a single structural failure/crack or other irreparable damage to the mast in over 4 years of production. I was never a huge fan of these complex conical male/female fuselage pockets, but some brands seem to have better control over their manufacturing of the joint than others. I do continue to believe that two flat and planar surfaces held together by M8 screws is a very reliable, predictable, and strong connection.
As a gross simplification i think the thickest part is going to be annoyinng if speed/efficency is the target. If your wing is thicker than the cedrus its probably the better bet. If your wing is thinner then your going to morice that mast (compared to something equivalent thickness)