Forums > Sailing General

Comfortable seaworthy 25-30 foot yacht

Reply
Created by MorningBird > 9 months ago, 24 Dec 2015
Ramona
NSW, 7722 posts
30 Dec 2015 5:59PM
Thumbs Up

Well Jerry is not going to see that sort of money for a Folkboat. $33,000 for stainless steel fittings! Nice fit out in side but still has exposed deck head. Self tailers would have been nice if your throwing money about.

CoolRunnings
NSW, 159 posts
31 Dec 2015 3:39PM
Thumbs Up


Having just come off the back of building another boat,I can certainly where the value was set in that Folkboat.

I mean,the brand new rig and sails were probably upwards of $15-$20k alone,never minding the paint job,engine and all the other ancillaries that were included.

This boat was reduced again about a year ago to around $65k from memory and I could not see them making an absolute 'killing' at that rate.

Does anybody know if Jerry is still in the game?.He was very well respected in the field and I know many of the 'Halvorsen' crowd would engage him for work.

BTW-Happy New year people!-C.R.

Ramona
NSW, 7722 posts
31 Dec 2015 6:04PM
Thumbs Up

CoolRunnings said..

Having just come off the back of building another boat,I can certainly where the value was set in that Folkboat.

I mean,the brand new rig and sails were probably upwards of $15-$20k alone,never minding the paint job,engine and all the other ancillaries that were included.

This boat was reduced again about a year ago to around $65k from memory and I could not see them making an absolute 'killing' at that rate.

Does anybody know if Jerry is still in the game?.He was very well respected in the field and I know many of the 'Halvorsen' crowd would engage him for work.

BTW-Happy New year people!-C.R.


I can see where some of the money went. Does not mean it has added value to the vessel. It's simply over capitalized. The cost of labour is what has done the damage. I for the life of me can not see how there is $33,000 worth of stainless steel fabrication there. Similar M26's sell for well under $20,000 with a good diesel. This folkboat is an excellent resto but with an outboard and at $24,500 is going need that one special customer when other Folkboats in good nick sell for under ten grand.
http://yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/folkboat-26/178296

MorningBird
NSW, 2698 posts
1 Jan 2016 8:51AM
Thumbs Up

Ramona said...
SandS said..

Ramona said..
Here is a really nice old mans boat. Needs a furler though!

http://yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/currawong-30/176666







BARGAIN !!!!!


Nicer interior fit out than mine! Not sure how they get to the stern gland though.

Through the cockpit locker?

mike_e
NSW, 71 posts
1 Jan 2016 9:13AM
Thumbs Up

Hi MB. Have you considered a young 88 ? Awesome boat. plenty of room to cruise with our family of 4. Great open cockpit and good headroom below. Fit out configurations vary and construction can be grp or timber core/west systems. There are a number for sale at the moment but not all advertised. Couple of examples here......
http://m.boatsonline.com.au/boats-for-sale/used/sailing-boats/young-88-cruiser-racer-yungsta/165873
And


MorningBird
NSW, 2698 posts
1 Jan 2016 12:34PM
Thumbs Up



A good selection there Cisco.

That Searle 26 looks like a nice little boat. I don't know anything about them. Anybody got any knowledge of them? The Compass 30 is nice.

The Cavs look alright but not for me.

Sailing the Clansman 30 is like swimming in a cold shower, the wettest yacht I have sailed on (raced on one out of RANSA). They are also have very little internal space.

Chris 249
NSW, 3515 posts
1 Jan 2016 3:12PM
Thumbs Up

The Compass 30 is moored near me. It's never moved as far as I can see, but looks to be in good condition. Not a hell of a lot smaller than the S&S, though - probably similar in beam or even a bit wider.


cisco
QLD, 12361 posts
1 Jan 2016 10:14PM
Thumbs Up

I like the Holland 30 "Scandal". It has been for sale for a long time (at least 18 months) and I am sure it could be had for $19 - $20,000. I am wondering why it has not sold yet.

The Compass 30 looks good too. A completely different yacht to the Compass 28s and 29s.

@ Lazzerae. I see that Lazy Daze is up for sale in Cairns or Thursday Island. Plenty of Compass 29s for sale.

HG02
VIC, 5814 posts
2 Jan 2016 12:08AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
cisco said..
I like the Holland 30 "Scandal". It has been for sale for a long time (at least 18 months) and I am sure it could be had for $19 - $20,000. I am wondering why it has not sold yet.

The Compass 30 looks good too. A completely different yacht to the Compass 28s and 29s.

@ Lazzerae. I see that Lazy Daze is up for sale in Cairns or Thursday Island. Plenty of Compass 29s for sale.


Either would be OK depend if you wanted wheel steering and furling main as in the compass 30 it also appears to have reasonable instruments on board .
The compass looks like it more set up for cruising than the Holland
Also wonder how long the rigging was done on both boats and also the sails.
To me the compass would be a better buy as far as use as you get older a little more user friendly if the furling main works OK
There both not a S & S 34

cisco
QLD, 12361 posts
1 Jan 2016 11:57PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
HG02 said..

Either would be OK depend if you wanted wheel steering and furling main as in the compass 30 it also appears to have reasonable instruments on board .
The compass looks like it more set up for cruising than the Holland
Also wonder how long the rigging was done on both boats and also the sails.
To me the compass would be a better buy as far as use as you get older a little more user friendly if the furling main works OK
There both not a S & S 34


Ex racing yachts make the best cruising yachts. It is easier to slow down a fast yacht than it is to make a dog yacht go faster.

I am only comparing design and price not condition and equipment level. The first thing I would do with the Compass is get rid of the "in mast" furling main. Too much weight aloft, not relevant on a 30 footer and too complicated. Second thing I would do is get rid of the wheel steering for the same reasons.

The Holland may have a deeper and shorter fin and maybe a spade rudder. Apart from that they are quite similar yachts.

No. Neither of them are S&S 34s. He wants to get rid of his S&S 34, buy a smaller yacht and have some change in his pocket with which to buy a classic sports car.

Sounds like a plan to me.

Donk107
TAS, 2446 posts
2 Jan 2016 7:39AM
Thumbs Up

Hi Cisco

I was actually thinking the other day about whether a x racer would be a good buy

in the 3 or 4 years that I have been racing I have seen boats racing run aground and pushed a lot harder in rough weather than you would do if cruising sometimes resulting in gear failure

In a race you are always trying to push the boat a bit harder to get a good result

Any thoughts would be appreciated

Regards Don

Ramona
NSW, 7722 posts
2 Jan 2016 8:43AM
Thumbs Up

I thought long and hard about a Holland 30. The pick of the boats for the average user definitely comes from the early halftonners. The cockpit layout excludes several of them though. I don't want to be sitting on a deck and I definitely don't want to depend on a handful of friends hanging off the side holding her up. In this price range there are lots of choices but other considerations like ease and cost of up keep should be considered so I would avoid sail drives. The Compass 30 would be a good choice with out the furling main, wheel steering and saildrive!

Ramona
NSW, 7722 posts
2 Jan 2016 8:48AM
Thumbs Up

MorningBird said..

Ramona said...

SandS said..


Ramona said..
Here is a really nice old mans boat. Needs a furler though!

http://yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/currawong-30/176666








BARGAIN !!!!!



Nicer interior fit out than mine! Not sure how they get to the stern gland though.


Through the cockpit locker?


There isn't one. That locker in the rear is just for gas bottles. Probably there is a panel that lifts out in the quarter berths. Anything you buy will not have the access the SS34 has.[early ones]


cisco
QLD, 12361 posts
2 Jan 2016 9:14AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Donk107 said..
Hi Cisco

I was actually thinking the other day about whether a x racer would be a good buy

in the 3 or 4 years that I have been racing I have seen boats racing run aground and pushed a lot harder in rough weather than you would do if cruising sometimes resulting in gear failure

In a race you are always trying to push the boat a bit harder to get a good result

Any thoughts would be appreciated

Regards Don


As with any yacht purchase it is always "caveat emptor", let the buyer beware.

cisco
QLD, 12361 posts
3 Jan 2016 10:26PM
Thumbs Up

HG02 said..
http://www.gumtree.com.au/s-ad/paynesville/sail-boats/cavalier-28-1991-shallow-draft-lift-centreboard-vgc/1034669733


The Cavalier 28 is a great yacht designed by Laurie Davidson and very similar in design n to my Lotus 9.2, ie beam carried well aft with transom hung rudder.

The prospect of a Cav 28 for $18.000 from Johnathon Frearson is what motivated me to drive to Sydney to buy a yacht. It needed majors so I did not buy it and then went to Lake Macquarie and bought my Lotus 9.2 for $10,000 more.

As yacht number 7 I believe it is the best decision I have made in my life.

MorningBird knows the yacht, he having spent 6 days and nights aboard her between Lake Macquarie and Bundaberg, and I am sure such a yacht would fulfill his requirements perfectly but he ain't going to get her or one the same for no $20,000 or less.

The Lotus 9.2 is one of the best kept secrets of the affordable yachting world.

I have spent my money on buying one so I may have a bias but now that I have her I feel no desire for any other yacht. I have a big love affair going on with my Second Wind.

Meg1122
QLD, 285 posts
8 Jan 2016 6:11AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Donk107 said..
Hi Cisco

I was actually thinking the other day about whether a x racer would be a good buy




There's very few cruiser traveling in ex-race boats.

I'm guessing it's because when you live aboard and cruise, particularly as a couple or family you want to be comfortable, race yachts don't tend towards comfort or long term living aboard. They tend to have minimal, open or unsecured stowage, so that sails etc can be quickly and readily accessed and little privacy for crew members. When you cruise full time you need to have secure stowage and lots of it for all the provisions and requirements of daily life that are needed for long term living aboard. All the extras that racing boats don't have onboard are the things you need and want onboard for a life at sea.

You would most likely for a start have to incorporate more adequate stowage, work out how to stow tenders and outboards, increase ground tackle, the water line, drains etc may need to be adapted due to extra weight considerations, basically effecting the initial design concept of the vessel from weight and balance to handling at sea. I think it's a case of 'horses for courses', I personally wouldn't recommend an ex race yacht for someone who wanted to cruise. Race yachts are purpose built and designed to race with no input or thought given to long term living aboard, cruising yachts are purpose built for a crew to live aboard for extended periods, weekenders are built for limited cruising/live aboard ect, and I think each suits its own specific purpose.

Some racing boats may be strongly built (some are also lightly built and only intended to be sailed hard over just a few seasons), undoubtably they are fast, they also tend to be uncomfortable, wet, exposed to the elements, minimally equip with any of the comforts of life and uninsulated. I imagine it's fairly difficult to fit a bimini or dodger on a vast open cockpit to keep out of the weather and dry. A lot of the simple things you would want onboard to make life at sea pleasant aren't found on a racing yacht, most cruisers aren't in a hurry, I guess it's called cruising for a reason.



Ramona
NSW, 7722 posts
9 Jan 2016 8:42AM
Thumbs Up

Chatting to my mate yesterday who has just come back from a few weeks in WA. Reckons the place is awash with cheap boats and houses after the mining turn down.

cisco
QLD, 12361 posts
9 Jan 2016 10:53PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Meg1122 said..

Donk107 said..
Hi Cisco

I was actually thinking the other day about whether a x racer would be a good buy





There's very few cruiser traveling in ex-race boats.

I'm guessing it's because when you live aboard and cruise, particularly as a couple or family you want to be comfortable, race yachts don't tend towards comfort or long term living aboard. They tend to have minimal, open or unsecured stowage, so that sails etc can be quickly and readily accessed and little privacy for crew members. When you cruise full time you need to have secure stowage and lots of it for all the provisions and requirements of daily life that are needed for long term living aboard. All the extras that racing boats don't have onboard are the things you need and want onboard for a life at sea.

You would most likely for a start have to incorporate more adequate stowage, work out how to stow tenders and outboards, increase ground tackle, the water line, drains etc may need to be adapted due to extra weight considerations, basically effecting the initial design concept of the vessel from weight and balance to handling at sea. I think it's a case of 'horses for courses', I personally wouldn't recommend an ex race yacht for someone who wanted to cruise. Race yachts are purpose built and designed to race with no input or thought given to long term living aboard, cruising yachts are purpose built for a crew to live aboard for extended periods, weekenders are built for limited cruising/live aboard ect, and I think each suits its own specific purpose.

Some racing boats may be strongly built (some are also lightly built and only intended to be sailed hard over just a few seasons), undoubtably they are fast, they also tend to be uncomfortable, wet, exposed to the elements, minimally equip with any of the comforts of life and uninsulated. I imagine it's fairly difficult to fit a bimini or dodger on a vast open cockpit to keep out of the weather and dry. A lot of the simple things you would want onboard to make life at sea pleasant aren't found on a racing yacht, most cruisers aren't in a hurry, I guess it's called cruising for a reason.







Let me re qualify my original statement of opinion, "Ex racing yachts make the best cruising yachts."

Ex IOR racing yachts make great cruising yachts.

All the points you raised are valid re storage, bunks and load carrying capacity etc.

Remember that IOR stands for "International Offshore Racing Rule". I do not know what the rule was exactly but I do know it was constantly being changed due to designers producing "rule beater designs" and the measurement rule became so complicated that the IOR standard was abandoned.

The late 70s and early 80s saw some brilliant designs emerge probably the most successful of which is the S&S 34 (3/4 tonner) and others such as the Joubert Currawong 30 (1/2 tonner), the Peterson Santana 30 (1/2 tonner) and the brilliant series of Peterson 40 odd foot 2 tonners one of which I owned for 5 years.

The first two letters of IOR mean "International and Offshore" which imply a common standard of yacht capable of international travel to racing events like the earlier Americas Cup rule. If you could not sail the vessel to the race venue, you could not compete in the race.

As far as the argument goes on comfort of a so called "cruising yacht" opposed to a "racing yacht", and I have said this before, any vessel at sea under 1,000 foot long is "uncomfortable".

What is comfortable is sailing the ex racing yacht converted for cruising getting into the anchorage before 17:00 and having the pick down, firing up the BBQ and having Sundowners while the so called "comfortable cruising yacht" is still out there battling the weather trying to get into the anchorage at 23:59.

Certainly the more recent crop of racing yachts do not lend themselves to conversion to cruising yachts with their huge beams, light displacement, light construction, ultra powerful rigs that only just stay up, minimal load carrying capacity and minimal crew comforts.

It is easier to slow down a fast yacht than it is to speed up a dog yacht.

Meg1122
QLD, 285 posts
10 Jan 2016 3:25AM
Thumbs Up

Each to their own and everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

Chris 249
NSW, 3515 posts
10 Jan 2016 9:35PM
Thumbs Up

I've sailed on a race boat that has been a liveaboard for almost 35 years. It's not really an "ex"- race boat since they raced it hard for about 25 years and I think it could still race and win. They've done 200,000 miles cruising, spend a lot of time in Alaska (they just sail back and forth from NZ two up routinely) and spent a fair bit of time around Cape Horn.

The boat also has been British offshore "Yacht of the Year" about five times, has about 5 IMS wins in class or overall in the Fastnet, an IRC overall win in NZ's biggest race, and an IMS class win in the Hobart - and all the while they lived on board. The boat is very heavy and actually designed to the RORC rule which preceded the IOR, but it certainly shows the possibilities.

There was also a French couple who cruised for something like 15 years aboard a 42' stripped-out alloy lightweight IOR boat with a flush deck, tiller steering, runners, etc. They loved the boat to bits. I think there was a similar but smaller (30') boat for sale in Hong Kong a while back after cruising out from France.

As you say, it's all about personal preferences, but it certainly is possible to cruise an ex-racing boat. I've known a lot of experienced cruisers who share Cisco's views.

MorningBird
NSW, 2698 posts
10 Jan 2016 10:48PM
Thumbs Up

Fidelis, a 61ft 1960s S2H winner, is an outstanding cruiser.
Would I recommend cruising a Sydney 36 or 38. Not likely.
The ex racing cruisers all seem to be 1960s or thereabouts boats when racers were expected to finish with rudders and spars still attached to the boat. :-)

Boatin
NSW, 179 posts
11 Jan 2016 8:50PM
Thumbs Up

I like that Northshore 27

SandS
VIC, 5904 posts
11 Jan 2016 8:59PM
Thumbs Up

Their a really good Yacht !!

MorningBird
NSW, 2698 posts
11 Jan 2016 9:27PM
Thumbs Up

Yara said...
MorningBird said..

BlueMoon said..
This NS27 looks alright, new motor & rigging
http://yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/northshore-27/177481



She looks pretty good. If MB sells that is the sort of boat I think might replace her.


How do you feel about bolt-on keels?

Should I feel anything that would influence a decision? S&S34s have a bolt on keel.

keensailor
NSW, 702 posts
11 Jan 2016 10:07PM
Thumbs Up

these are the keel bolts on our 1984 NS27





MorningBird
NSW, 2698 posts
11 Jan 2016 10:27PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
keensailor said...
these are the keel bolts on our 1984 NS27








They look well spaced. Has there been a problem with NS keels?

keensailor
NSW, 702 posts
11 Jan 2016 10:33PM
Thumbs Up

No, not that I know of.

MorningBird
NSW, 2698 posts
11 Jan 2016 10:39PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
keensailor said...
No, not that I know of.

Yara got me a bit concerned. My mate Havefun as a NS and I'm confident he wouldn't have a boat with a known defect.

stevetheadven
WA, 60 posts
15 Jan 2016 10:22AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Toph said..
M26


i might have 1 for sale soon lol



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Sailing General


"Comfortable seaworthy 25-30 foot yacht" started by MorningBird