Forums > Wing Foiling General

Armstrong and me, end of a love story.... Searching for new adventures

Reply
Created by GiovanniITA > 9 months ago, 27 Aug 2022
GiovanniITA
12 posts
27 Aug 2022 12:38PM
Thumbs Up

Hi wise friends
after beeing engaged with Armstrong foil for one year ish , I've sold all my beloved toys (725,925 1250 etcc...) and now I'm a single, in search of the new fresh love story....
I'm 57 y.o, 57 kg, experienced (at least in time spent on foiling...) wingfoiler, at the moment really confused on finding my new foiling partner.
I'm searching something with the same or maybe better glide and pumping abilities of HA series, but with more mast stiffness, in order to feel a more direct connection with the foil, that I couldn't find in high speed (either waves or just flat water...) with Armstrong (85 A+) and that probably was the cause of my inadequate confidence or reliance on the foilset.
I'm testing at the moment Fanatic free 800 all carbon (82 mast), 680 fuse, that's really stiffer than Armstrong, but doesn't give me the same pleasure in terms of glide and pumping....
I'm tempted to get the Cabrina h series in size 800/650, but received some bad reviews about the rigidity of the mast....
F-One, Axxis, or lift foils in HA, also tempt me, but I haven't got any direct feedback ....
Have heard about Cedrus project, but in Italy is really hard to get one..
I like riding small waves in low wind (12/18 knots, comfor, zone with 925) and also bigger waves in 20 + knots (with 725), but definitely not ride dangerous places such as One Eye.... Basically easy, relaxed riding in full reliance with the foil set.
Thanks in advance for the precious advices....

omg
292 posts
27 Aug 2022 1:39PM
Thumbs Up

Why no sabfoil 945?

GiovanniITA
12 posts
27 Aug 2022 2:34PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
omg said..
Why no sabfoil 945?


Too big, 1300 cm2... and Al fuselage

Sheps
WA, 131 posts
27 Aug 2022 4:08PM
Thumbs Up

Lots of people are really enjoying the Axis Art wings with standard aluminium mast which is very stiff. Add a high modulus mast if you have loads of cash. I ride the 1099 and 899. The glide is next level whilst pumping and turning ability is also very good. The 1099 if feel a bit hard to handle in heavy wind chop but I'm hoping the new carbon high modulus mast will help that. Mostly I ride the 899 on these days and it's crazy fun. Adrian Roper is such a good designer and makes it hard to consider other brands. So much interchangeability. So much quality. Such good design.

warwickl
NSW, 2353 posts
27 Aug 2022 6:35PM
Thumbs Up

Depending upon one's weight and pumping skills, for me at 76kg 899 and 799 ARTs with 350p stab covers everything ??

Windoc
442 posts
27 Aug 2022 11:50PM
Thumbs Up

At your 57 kg I'm really surprised you find the Armstrong 85 mast unusable. At over 90kg it's my feeling that I really only start to feel undesired flex with my 1125. All of the smaller HAs and HS foils feel really good to me on the 85. This being the case, it sounds like Armstrong has had enough criticism of flexible connections and a softer mast flex and possibly lots of us who just don't know any better have adapted to the so called "engineered" flex. I am hoping to see a stiffer Armstrong mast in the near future as the entire system is so nice to use and customer support is amazing. Good luck in your new relationship .

CoreAS
923 posts
28 Aug 2022 3:06AM
Thumbs Up

Slingshot phantasm carbon mast is one of the stiffest masts on the market!

At 90kg I used the phantasm 82cm mast with ptm926 front wing in winds from 11-22knots, its very smooth in the swells and pops in the air with ease.

King Crash
NSW, 319 posts
28 Aug 2022 8:44AM
Thumbs Up

I would suggest demoing a few brands, I won't plug anything without firsthand experience, just don't settle for what the kool-aid is pushing. ART is okay, but there are a lot of problems with it. And more band aids than any other brand to try and make it alright (advanced fuse, 325 tail).
I would suggest the following:
Kujira for carve.
FOne Eagle for the best of carve and glide.

JohnnyTsunami
136 posts
28 Aug 2022 8:43AM
Thumbs Up

I'm in hood river and a lot of folks go with the no limitz mast here and axis or another brand for the foils. I assume for the stiffness.
You would need to bolt them all to a wall and hang weights off the top to actually be able to tell (how axis does it). Or flip your friends board over and give it the wiggle test. Hard to say.

I had a guy here tell me the axis aluminum is stiffer than the high mod, but they advertise it as 35% stiffer. I lost faith in them when my 1,000$ masts would not stop ventilating.

Hwy1North
220 posts
29 Aug 2022 1:11AM
Thumbs Up

First and foremost, go with a brand that you can purchase and get service from easily without having to pay $100's of dollars and weeks on end for "warranty." Second: stiffness is a matter of feel and not performance imo. I am very used to the flex of my Takuma carbon rig and anytime I get on an Axis mast, I hate it. The only time I can say flex has been an issue is using a 1440 wing and not shimming the fuse to wing connection thus leaving a little wobble. Slop in the system is very bad. But I also don't run a long mast. Lots of guys I know are much heavier than you and use the Armstrong 85cm mast with much success. Maybe the wings you are using are just not well suited to your style. HA wings can be a blessing or a curse, as can the lift profile of front foot pressure vs. a more neutral wing like the Takuma 1095 that I love.

Sounds like you are able to test different brands which is truly a luxury. Please post your rig when you settle on one!

Dcharlton
320 posts
29 Aug 2022 1:52AM
Thumbs Up

In an area where everyone's on Armstrong, I'm the lone Axis guy and I love them, the versatility, the quality the fun are pretty amazing. I'm 95kg and find the Aluminum mast works just fine with the ART999.

DC

airsail
QLD, 1537 posts
29 Aug 2022 5:15AM
Thumbs Up

I've done some garage testing of foil masts, eg, bolt it to the wall, hang weights of it and measure the deflection. The Phantasm is the stiffest I've found, though I haven't tested the new Sabfoil Kraken or the Cedrus.

capster
WA, 49 posts
29 Aug 2022 4:48AM
Thumbs Up

I'm also contemplating moving away from Armstrong. Love the carbon/titanium construction, no tefgel or retightening of bolts. Weight is good, could be stiffer. The 1125 is good, but the balance is somewhat off (could be setup, but tried a lot of tuning). Also the price is high, then tip performance is to be expected.

Have the new gong ypra and mast w/titanium fuselage on order, we'll see if it can fill the shoes after Armstrong....

CJ2478
NSW, 484 posts
29 Aug 2022 9:35AM
Thumbs Up

Good thread, I was in a similar position and just setup my new setup. I came from riding the 725 on 72 mast (85 was too flexy and sold it) and now am riding a lift 90ha, nolimitz 78 mast, foilparts tail adapter and a kujira 178 tail and really liking it.
When I bought my armstrong stuff, a major reason was the zero maintenance benefits, however as time has gone by the inside of the mast against the surface of the fuse has worn away alot (even without regular disassembly). I guess saltwater gets in there and crystalises and this causes abrasion when in use. Now I have this sloppy mast and fuse (worth almost $2k) that doesnt work very well and I see this as a major fault in their system and a very poor sustainability outcome (after 1.5 year use and so much energy required to extract the raw materials).

GiovanniITA
12 posts
30 Aug 2022 5:48PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks for your advices
I've just placed the order for Axis art 799 and 999 Al mast , crazy short advanced fuse and 325....
I'll let u know ASAP....

Alysum
NSW, 1030 posts
30 Aug 2022 8:04PM
Thumbs Up

Since you're based in Italy I am surprised you're not interested in Sabfoil ?

mindhoc
NSW, 94 posts
30 Aug 2022 8:26PM
Thumbs Up

Konrad for the win!

johndg
WA, 223 posts
30 Aug 2022 8:13PM
Thumbs Up

I use the Cedrus mast with Axis and Lift adapters. Rode Armie to start and was happy and the tried the Axis hps, then Art foils and bought them. Wasnt using Armstrong so sold them.
Heard about Cedrus through the Progression podcast and they sounded good. And the ability to change foil brands without a complete gear change.
I am happy to have made the decision.
Foiling is new sport and it is in a growth "arms race" now. Some product will be good, some not so.

Life is short so enjoy.

warwickl
NSW, 2353 posts
31 Aug 2022 6:36AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
GiovanniITA said..
Thanks for your advices
I've just placed the order for Axis art 799 and 999 Al mast , crazy short advanced fuse and 325....
I'll let u know ASAP....


You will love the 799.
I have the 899 and 799 with 350p stab, me 76kg.

King Crash
NSW, 319 posts
31 Aug 2022 7:32AM
Thumbs Up

Damn you drank the kool aid

GiovanniITA
12 posts
1 Sep 2022 11:54AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Alysum said..
Since you're based in Italy I am surprised you're not interested in Sabfoil ?


I think they don't have the same ability in design and testing new foils as the "wing and prone oriented" brands have....

GiovanniITA
12 posts
1 Sep 2022 11:59AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
johndg said..
I use the Cedrus mast with Axis and Lift adapters. Rode Armie to start and was happy and the tried the Axis hps, then Art foils and bought them. Wasnt using Armstrong so sold them.
Heard about Cedrus through the Progression podcast and they sounded good. And the ability to change foil brands without a complete gear change.
I am happy to have made the decision.
Foiling is new sport and it is in a growth "arms race" now. Some product will be good, some not so.

Life is short so enjoy.


The idea of Cedrus is great, I've tried to get one in Europe, but couldn't find the way... Maybe I've to write directly to the factory...

stanley71
WA, 223 posts
1 Sep 2022 12:42PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
johndg said..
I use the Cedrus mast with Axis and Lift adapters. Rode Armie to start and was happy and the tried the Axis hps, then Art foils and bought them. Wasnt using Armstrong so sold them.
Heard about Cedrus through the Progression podcast and they sounded good. And the ability to change foil brands without a complete gear change.
I am happy to have made the decision.
Foiling is new sport and it is in a growth "arms race" now. Some product will be good, some not so.

Life is short so enjoy.


seen your setup in action John, really nice

johndg
WA, 223 posts
1 Sep 2022 3:36PM
Thumbs Up

With Cedrus you have to order it online. You pay a deposit of $usd 500, then you get contacted discuss your requirements, mast length, adapters and then wait. When made you get an invoice, once paid it comes pretty quick. I paid $200 duty on it. In total around 2000 aud landed with the then exchange rate. Axis and lift adapters.

Have had no issues. Justed checked yesterday and it was all tight.

Check out the progression project podcast for an interview.

johndg
WA, 223 posts
1 Sep 2022 3:36PM
Thumbs Up

With Cedrus you have to order it online. You pay a deposit of $usd 500, then you get contacted discuss your requirements, mast length, adapters and then wait. When made you get an invoice, once paid it comes pretty quick. I paid $200 duty on it. In total around 2000 aud landed with the then exchange rate. Axis and lift adapters.

Have had no issues. Justed checked yesterday and it was all tight.

Check out the progression project podcast for an interview.

stanley71
WA, 223 posts
1 Sep 2022 4:18PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
CoreAS said..
Slingshot phantasm carbon mast is one of the stiffest masts on the market!

At 90kg I used the phantasm 82cm mast with ptm926 front wing in winds from 11-22knots, its very smooth in the swells and pops in the air with ease.



Agree about that 12K mast .. did all the customary mast static "press/twist test" etc and super nice setup to ride (smooth take-off and carving), unfortunately do not yet have smaller sized front/tails e.g. 800-1000/300-350 and shorter fuselages for lighter progressing riders (I am 64kg). But in all, its a super nice package and that 92cm 12K mast (+fuselage joint) is real solid esp. for the package price they are charging.

beached57
127 posts
1 Sep 2022 8:03PM
Thumbs Up

yesterday a friend borrowed my foil board with armstrong foil and came back to say he couldn't believe how loose it all felt, to the point of being unstable. and yet i am perfectly fine on it. i outweigh him by about 40 pounds. he rides armstrong gear as well. there is a lot of play when i wiggle my front wing and almost none on his.

i wonder if my extra weight has caused more 'erosion' between the fuselage and the wing? and i wonder if, since i have ridden this gear for years now, i've just adapted to the increasing looseness along the way and don't feel the instability he did? in any case, i plan on sticking with Armstrong till i actually feel something is wrong myself, which clearly the original author does.

Relapse
VIC, 616 posts
1 Sep 2022 11:00PM
Thumbs Up

If you have a carbon mast that slots 'into' the fuse like Axis, Takuma, Cabrinha etc you have to keep an eye on wear. Carbon is a very soft material when it comes to abrasion. 0.5 mm slop at the fuse translates to a lot more at the mast base. Someone I knew was having trouble with the ART999 on their Axis carbon mast, said it was really unstable. I tried it and could barely foil in a straight line yet alone gybe. Checked the connection between the fuse and mast and it was noticeably loose due to wear. A couple of coats of epoxy to tighten it up and it was light and day. Same happened to my carbon mast/fuse after 200+ sessions, was struggling with transitions I could normally do in my sleep. Noticed a bit of movement at the fuse junction, a couple of coats of epoxy and back to normal again. Hold the area between the mast to fuse junction between your finger and thumb and wiggle the foil, if you can feel movement you have a problem.

keep this in mind when you demo your mates gear, you might not be getting the true experience

patronus
478 posts
2 Sep 2022 4:07PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Windoc said..
At your 57 kg I'm really surprised you find the Armstrong 85 mast unusable. At over 90kg it's my feeling that I really only start to feel undesired flex with my 1125. All of the smaller HAs and HS foils feel really good to me on the 85. This being the case, it sounds like Armstrong has had enough criticism of flexible connections and a softer mast flex and possibly lots of us who just don't know any better have adapted to the so called "engineered" flex. I am hoping to see a stiffer Armstrong mast in the near future as the entire system is so nice to use and customer support is amazing. Good luck in your new relationship .


I am not good enough to separate 'flaws' in equipment from technique. What's the problem and symptoms of the Armstrong flex compared to say Axis?

patronus
478 posts
2 Sep 2022 4:09PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
beached57 said..
yesterday a friend borrowed my foil board with armstrong foil and came back to say he couldn't believe how loose it all felt, to the point of being unstable. and yet i am perfectly fine on it. i outweigh him by about 40 pounds. he rides armstrong gear as well. there is a lot of play when i wiggle my front wing and almost none on his.

i wonder if my extra weight has caused more 'erosion' between the fuselage and the wing? and i wonder if, since i have ridden this gear for years now, i've just adapted to the increasing looseness along the way and don't feel the instability he did? in any case, i plan on sticking with Armstrong till i actually feel something is wrong myself, which clearly the original author does.


Do you disassemble your wing from fuselage much?

beached57
127 posts
2 Sep 2022 8:00PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
patronus said..

beached57 said..
yesterday a friend borrowed my foil board with armstrong foil and came back to say he couldn't believe how loose it all felt, to the point of being unstable. and yet i am perfectly fine on it. i outweigh him by about 40 pounds. he rides armstrong gear as well. there is a lot of play when i wiggle my front wing and almost none on his.

i wonder if my extra weight has caused more 'erosion' between the fuselage and the wing? and i wonder if, since i have ridden this gear for years now, i've just adapted to the increasing looseness along the way and don't feel the instability he did? in any case, i plan on sticking with Armstrong till i actually feel something is wrong myself, which clearly the original author does.



Do you disassemble your wing from fuselage much?


only if i need to change the front wing. but i've often gone many months without doing so.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Wing Foiling General


"Armstrong and me, end of a love story.... Searching for new adventures" started by GiovanniITA