Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk

GTC: All Australian Womens Team?

Reply
Created by hardie > 9 months ago, 14 Feb 2010
hardie
WA, 4129 posts
14 Feb 2010 9:57AM
Thumbs Up

Speaking to Binny who speaks to other women windsurfers, and the idea has been floated of an all womens team, representing all states of Australia, that one day could compete against future womens teams from around the world.

Most women who are involved in the GTC seem to love it, love being part of a team, but feel they dont often make a contribution to the team, and would like a womens team where they may make a contribution in one category of one session in one month in one year!

So whaddyareckon Ladies, do you want a team of your own?

lao shi
WA, 1338 posts
14 Feb 2010 11:14AM
Thumbs Up

Keep yer hands orf our wimmin![}:)]
Seriously though, if there are international women's teams on the horizon I think it sounds like a great idea.
Or have a female team ranking. I am sure Nebbs could do that in a flash
Then there could be competition between the women's divisions of the Aussie teams. Perhaps a future alternative.
At the moment I get the feeling that the benefit of being part of a team where people learn from and talk / socialise with others might outweigh the competitive element and not just for women.

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
14 Feb 2010 11:25AM
Thumbs Up

lao shi said...

Keep yer hands orf our wimmin![}:)]



Cheryl AUS841
WA, 35 posts
14 Feb 2010 12:45PM
Thumbs Up

I think it is a great idea and I would be very interested. Sure it's good to be part of a team in your area but after a while you start to wonder if its worth even wearing your GPS because you know none of your results will count anyway.

If there was a national women's team more women may join up or post more often.

So are there any other women interested in forming a team?

Cheryl

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
14 Feb 2010 1:15PM
Thumbs Up

lao shi said...
Or have a female team ranking. I am sure Nebbs could do that in a flash
Then there could be competition between the women's divisions of the Aussie teams. Perhaps a future alternative.


Most mens teams only have one or two ladies on them, so it's hard to get a team ranking where only the ladies scores are counted.

Hmmmm... I suppose we could have virtual teams, so someone could still be a member of a 'normal' team as well as a virtual 'ladies only' team. Might get a bit confusing though, "Which team are you in" "Ummm well I'm a Pinna, but also a member of the Sandgroping Women team"...

The other alternative is to create a national team just for women.

Paul Kelf
WA, 678 posts
14 Feb 2010 1:51PM
Thumbs Up

AUS841 said...

I think it is a great idea and I would be very interested. Sure it's good to be part of a team in your area but after a while you start to wonder if its worth even wearing your GPS because you know none of your results will count anyway.

If there was a national women's team more women may join up or post more often.

So are there any other women interested in forming a team?

Cheryl


Hey Cheryl, it's not just the women that feel that way, maybe I should be in a girl's team

I am competing against myself as I'm so far behind the other guys & I can't even beat myself lately

hardpole
WA, 604 posts
14 Feb 2010 2:38PM
Thumbs Up

Paul Kelf said...

Hey Cheryl, it's not just the women that feel that way, maybe I should be in a girl's team

I am competing against myself as I'm so far behind the other guys & I can't even beat myself lately


I know what you mean Paul, my score very rarely actually counts in the DAY, but I dont think ones ever been in the monthly final score.

But you can always aim at improving your PB's which is what its all really about and that is satisfying enough for me.

I want a team for left handers born in 1959 - maybe my scores will count then

But I have no objection to an all womens comp / team.

I suppose it does bring up the idea of something like golf handicaps. That way the person with PB's (better than their handicap) would be contributing more than the person with huge scores. Perhaps that could be the "alternative" view of the comp so it all stays as is for the real comp but there is the option to view the handicap one instead (more work for Nebs).

The handicap could be something like the average of your best three previous scores plus some constant so we get positive numbers (they look better).

so for me my best three 2 secs have average of 32.3 so if I sail 27.8 (Saturday at Hardys) then my score could be 27.8 - 32.3 + 20 = 15.4

But a fast sailor who's best three 2 sec average is 40.8 and who sailed 28.8 on Saturday would get a handicaped score of 28.8 - 40.48 + 20 = 8.32

I dont know how golf handicaps are calculated but they are a pretty succesful system so it may be worth copying that. Perhaps averaging ALL your scores in the last 12 months would be fairer to reduce the effect of one of excellent days.

Dont get me wrong, I have no problems with the way things are now but if we want to make more people feel they are contributing to the team this might be a way of achieving that.

My 2 cents worth.





hardpole
WA, 604 posts
14 Feb 2010 2:40PM
Thumbs Up

I can't even beat myself lately


You may want to rephrase that

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
14 Feb 2010 2:45PM
Thumbs Up

My sense of it is that there may be a "Womens Business" thing about it, just women bonding in a women's team?

lao shi
WA, 1338 posts
14 Feb 2010 2:46PM
Thumbs Up

Being serious, I just wondered whether it would be feasible to select a second team category average only from women's scores to make a women's ladder.

I am sure that it is more complicated than it sounds. It would mean that most /all sessions counted if there are only a couple of women on the team and would encourage recruitment for those teams that only have one? Scores can count for full team ladder also.
If you had an all Australia team surely it would give the same situation where a number of the best sailors scores will count most of the time.

As we have found it is good to have depth in your team as people go away / get injured and get better so that they can score for the team.

Binny
31 posts
14 Feb 2010 3:06PM
Thumbs Up

For me to be be part of a woman's team, would mean that I could make a contibution to the team, by backing up others etc, and this would give me the motvation to go sailing. i find that too easily work or family take priority, but being part of a team where my contribution counted may sway me to do for myself rather than for others.

CheekyMonkey
QLD, 53 posts
14 Feb 2010 7:16PM
Thumbs Up

There is an all womens team already in the competition - Board Crazy Girls, based it SE Qld. I post regularly but we haven't posted a team result this year as we are down to 4 members and because of Jo's commitment to formula racing, we seldom sync up our sailing. If we could get 6 or 8 girls in the team who sail regularly (most weekends) I'd be all for switching.

Sharon.

Windxtasy
WA, 4017 posts
14 Feb 2010 5:29PM
Thumbs Up

I've only just joined the GPS challenge and I'm not yet sure of how it all works, but Ladies' scores being generally too low to contribute to the team score is somewhat discouraging. Sure the GPS challenge is to improve oneself, but you can do that without being part of a team at all. The concept is to encourage people to sail together. The current set up does little to encourage the guys to coordinate sailing with a female team member.

There does need to be a separate ladies table at least. As there are so few women in each team the two sailing in one session would be difficult to achieve very often. Maybe the two per session rule could be suspended for ladies until numbers are sufficient? Perhaps that's where a state or national women's team would be more practical - just to get a team with sufficient numbers to maximise the chance of getting a score at all. Compete against women in the other states and countries...
Women are unlikely to rank higher than last against the guys very often, so we need other women's teams we can really compete against.

(What am I talking about? I'm dreaming. I'm just a beginner. It will be ages before I am really competitive, if ever, but it would be nice to know there is a chance of it at least. It's nice to dream. Against the guys?... no chance at all.)

Oh, and this is nothing about "secret women's business and female bonding". Socially I'd rather be in a team of guys any day!

We don't want to leave the teams we are a part of, but dual membership of our own team plus a state women's team would be good. Certainly warrants more discussion and brainstorming.

and Nebbian, I don't think "Sandgroping women" is a suitable team name!

CheekyMonkey
QLD, 53 posts
14 Feb 2010 7:45PM
Thumbs Up

I like the idea of a "virtual" ladies team.

I think the site has some fantactic functionality that more than compensates for a lady's abiltiy to contribute to a team result and provides more than enough motivation for me to wear my GPS every time I sail.

At under 58kgs I've resigned myself to the fact that I'm going to struggle to compete with the "big boys" but I have set myself goals like breaking into the top 150 2 sec times. I also watch the women's individual results for 2010. I know those things are individual and not in the spirit of the Team Challenge, but that's what makes the GPSTC so special - being part of a team yet also able to motive yourself on an individual level.

Alewi62
QLD, 158 posts
14 Feb 2010 8:28PM
Thumbs Up

I like being part of a mixed team. It is one of the few sports where ladies results can be compared to mens. Today two of my division scores counted toward the team results.
We already have a ladies table of results for pb's for the year and all time pb's.
Are there any international womens teams?
I would be for a virtual team if there was one as long as I could stay in my current team. Helga Sunshine Coast Vikings

ka72
QLD, 581 posts
14 Feb 2010 9:03PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
alewi62 said...

I like being part of a mixed team. It is one of the few sports where ladies results can be compared to mens. Today two of my division scores counted toward the team results.
We already have a ladies table of results for pb's for the year and all time pb's.

I agree with Helga, I also like be part of a mixed team and quite often our results are counting to the teams ranking, go girls.

I would be happy to join if I could stay in my current team. I only see the point at this stage if there were other international women's team???? haven't seen any yet.

Like Sharon said I also feel like there is already enough motivation for me to wear my GPS every time I sail. I also like the way I can keep the historical data to see how many times I sailed in a particular month last year for instance when everyone on the beach is saying there is much less wind that last year or whatever I have checked my post and mostly find I am sailing the same amount of sessions, or can track which months are more windy.
Astrid
Sunshine Coast Vikings

decrepit
WA, 12767 posts
14 Feb 2010 8:31PM
Thumbs Up

nebbian said...
[>>>>>>
Hmmmm... I suppose we could have virtual teams, so someone could still be a member of a 'normal' team as well as a virtual 'ladies only' team. Might get a bit confusing though, "Which team are you in" "Ummm well I'm a Pinna, but also a member of the Sandgroping Women team"...




I think one virtual team per state could work, that would keep it fairly simple, and enable interstate and international competition.

Choosing a virtual captain may present a problem but.

Cheryl AUS841
WA, 35 posts
14 Feb 2010 9:08PM
Thumbs Up

Looks like most are in favour of a virtual team. State teams might work until there are some overseas teams to compete with.

Mobydisc
NSW, 9029 posts
15 Feb 2010 12:41AM
Thumbs Up

Only WA and Queensland have more than one females participating in the GTC. Is the purpose of this proposal to get more females involved in the challenge?

Windxtasy
WA, 4017 posts
14 Feb 2010 9:46PM
Thumbs Up

Mobydisc said...

Only WA and Queensland have more than one females participating in the GTC. Is the purpose of this proposal to get more females involved in the challenge?


I guess that's why a national team was proposed rather than state teams.
I like the idea of state teams though.
The purpose of the proposal is so the ladies can feel their results actually contribute to a team total somewhere.
I think that would encourage more women to join.

graceman
WA, 323 posts
14 Feb 2010 9:46PM
Thumbs Up

I think this is a good idea except
I am not sure about this, as a few blokes in our team use Annika as a benchmark
And Cheryl gives us a whomping too
I think Cheryl and Annika have both contributed to month end scores in our team

Victor B
WA, 130 posts
14 Feb 2010 11:35PM
Thumbs Up

I don't want to steer off topic, or hijack a topic that was raised for female feedback - totally agree with whats been said for all the reasons raised. However, I also think this concept has touched on a general feeling as well.

Is there any chance the competition could also explore a grading concept?

Perhaps have a, b, c grades within teams? As a relative newcomer to the sport of windsurfing (3.5 seasons) sometimes I also wonder why I bother posting when the majority of the worthwhile scores are regularly accumulated by the top two or three in our team - who have 10-15 years of experience. I often look at the people close to my skill level and compare my scores times with them to push myself.

I think a grading system would provide an incentive for new sailors; with achievable goals being incremental (going up a grade) rather than aiming at being the "best" overall. I wouldnt be using the master/grandmaster etc - as this relates purely to age and I am a Master (????) with 3 years sailing.

Back on topic...Totally agree that a women's team is great idea.

Sterlings
QLD, 73 posts
15 Feb 2010 7:23AM
Thumbs Up

Hi All
Yes I agree with Sharon. We are the only all girls team and rarely post these days. I doubt that Jo will be doing much this year due to her RSX training for the Youth Worlds. She has lost interest and has bigger fish to fry.

However I'm still keen but must admit to not even wearing my GPS since we are usually unlikely to get a team result. I've been thinking for a while that we need to consider the team's future. But not keen to get absorbed into one of the large all male Bris teams.

So I'm all for an Aus team with Sharon and Binny.

ps wore it yesterday and will post soon, Sharon

Alewi62
QLD, 158 posts
15 Feb 2010 8:13AM
Thumbs Up

I think everyone needs to remember that GTC is run by volunteers and while it could get bigger and offer more divisions etc, it already offers a fantastic ( free ) opportunity for both male and female sailors to gauge their personal and team progress.
Sailors who worrying about not contributing towards their team results could maybe focus on their own pb's which is very rewarding - you know that your sailing skills are progressing which is what you should be aiming for.
Anne Lewis

CheekyMonkey
QLD, 53 posts
15 Feb 2010 8:50AM
Thumbs Up

Bugger, I couldn't sail yesterday as I had family committments at Movie World - will be sailing today. This is why being part of a larger team works.

Sterlings
QLD, 73 posts
15 Feb 2010 9:39AM
Thumbs Up

Yes you are right. I can't sail today!!. or later in the week which looks good as taking Jo to fremantle for rsx nationals.

This is our problem - there are really only 2 sailors who consistently post. Makes life difficult and leads to a bit of a lack of motivation.

Perhaps those who want to join a national women's team do so and those who don't can stay in their current teams. Doesn't have to be compulsory.

ka72
QLD, 581 posts
15 Feb 2010 10:32AM
Thumbs Up

1) Don't take me out of my team. One of the best things about our team is that we sail together most of the time. A national team might compete together, but it won't sail together on the same patch of water.

2) If I wanted to be on a women only team, I could have joined one.

3) A "virtual" national team might be a good idea - if any other countries get on board. Otherwise I'm not sure how much I would benefit from it. As a promotional idea for gpstc it might be good.

4) Sounds like you men want to fix it for us. Typical!

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
15 Feb 2010 8:41AM
Thumbs Up

ka72 said...

1) Don't take me out of my team. One of the best things about our team is that we sail together most of the time. A national team might compete together, but it won't sail together on the same patch of water.

2) If I wanted to be on a women only team, I could have joined one.

3) A "virtual" national team might be a good idea - if any other countries get on board. Otherwise I'm not sure how much I would benefit from it. As a promotional idea for gpstc it might be good.



Valid Points!!

Wineman
NSW, 1412 posts
15 Feb 2010 1:18PM
Thumbs Up

ka72 said...

4) Sounds like you men want to fix it for us. Typical!


You left one out Mr Hardie
.............but she wasn't talking about you!

All valid points, but we must K.I.S.S.
The GPSTC is working, VERY successfully. Just look at the hits & also international interest.

There are various state speed tables posted using the data, so why not have various state/team handicap tables - separate from GPSTC, but using the posted data.

If, over a trial period, that can be seen to work as an acceptable option, then look at incorporating into GPSTC site later - when we are paying a contribution fee. (personal opinion)

Hardie & Nebs (plus all contributors) have done a superb job getting to this level - lets not over complicate it but utilise the resources created.

pepe47
WA, 1382 posts
15 Feb 2010 12:28PM
Thumbs Up

A lot of very valid points here. As I struggle with the last button on my fire suit I wonder what the reaction would be to a men's only team [}:)]

CheekyMonkey
QLD, 53 posts
15 Feb 2010 9:23PM
Thumbs Up

ka72 said...

1) Don't take me out of my team. One of the best things about our team is that we sail together most of the time. A national team might compete together, but it won't sail together on the same patch of water.

2) If I wanted to be on a women only team, I could have joined one.

3) A "virtual" national team might be a good idea - if any other countries get on board. Otherwise I'm not sure how much I would benefit from it. As a promotional idea for gpstc it might be good.

4) Sounds like you men want to fix it for us. Typical!


Well said Kelly. All this and sailing with the guys today has got me thinking about switching teams - my distance would have contributed to MBM today....

I still think a "virtual" ladies team would be cool. It wouldn't worry me if it didn't happen as I love the GPCTC as it is.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk


"GTC: All Australian Womens Team?" started by hardie