Forums > Windsurfing General

free race board vs full slalom in top speed, can free race be as fast ? in your opinion

Reply
Created by Tardy > 9 months ago, 30 Aug 2020
LeeD
3939 posts
11 Sep 2020 3:23AM
Thumbs Up

DaveV....
Isonic 111 has a 49cm tail.
Futura 111 had a 44 cm tail.
Also, Futura has much less area behind the cutout.
For downwind powered up, less area is faster.
For upwind and acceleration, MORE area is quicker.

Tardy
5260 posts
11 Sep 2020 3:47AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Margo91 said..
That 120 F-Race is quite a fast board, managed to get 8ht place on Estonian 1day speed event with that board in chopy sea conditions, with 7.0 Loft Blade and Select 37 fin. All other competitors, at least top15, did use 100L'ish slalom boards.Same location and wind direction as in this video





Thanks for that margo ,great speeds .I'm impressed . .it definitely sails like a smaller board ,looks like a nice sailing spot .

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8225 posts
11 Sep 2020 5:05PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Margo91 said..
That 120 F-Race is quite a fast board, managed to get 8ht place on Estonian 1day speed event with that board in chopy sea conditions, with 7.0 Loft Blade and Select 37 fin. All other competitors, at least top15, did use 100L'ish slalom boards.Same location and wind direction as in this video





Great video.. looks like a beautiful place to sail.

duzzi
1120 posts
11 Sep 2020 11:40PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
LeeD said..
DaveV....
Isonic 111 has a 49cm tail.
Futura 111 had a 44 cm tail.
Also, Futura has much less area behind the cutout.
For downwind powered up, less area is faster.
For upwind and acceleration, MORE area is quicker.


Yes, that was I meant when I said "it is a slightly smaller board". The 2020 has smaller volume, thinner rails, more V, smaller tail ... kind of apple and oranges. Anyway, I think it is, at least for me, a moot issue. As I mentioned before I am not really willing to sail a board that size as it should (overpowered) ...

LeeD
3939 posts
3 Dec 2020 7:10AM
Thumbs Up

Futura is easier to sail, so can be faster than Isonic in rough water, and for most sailors less than pro slalom caliber.
In 7 years with my JP Supersport, I have been passed a handful of times, maybe 3 times by Chenda Herstus, a former Kanaha Slalom Masters Champ.
Besides him, I can't think of any windsurfer...including dozens with sail numbers and logos, who can stay with me for any run.
From 1st day, I thought my '12 Supersport was clearly faster in top speed than my '10 Futura.
Currently have 84 JP Pro Slalom, 85 Naish Freeride, 95 Exocet Slider, 100 Tabou Speedster, 102 Fanatic Proto [2012], 109 Supersport, and 111 Isonic.

Shifu
QLD, 1992 posts
3 Dec 2020 9:15AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
LeeD said..
Futura is easier to sail, so can be faster than Isonic in rough water, and for most sailors less than pro slalom caliber.
In 7 years with my JP Supersport, I have been passed a handful of times, maybe 3 times by Chenda Herstus, a former Kanaha Slalom Masters Champ.
Besides him, I can't think of any windsurfer...including dozens with sail numbers and logos, who can stay with me for any run.
From 1st day, I thought my '12 Supersport was clearly faster in top speed than my '10 Futura.
Currently have 84 JP Pro Slalom, 85 Naish Freeride, 95 Exocet Slider, 100 Tabou Speedster, 102 Fanatic Proto [2012], 109 Supersport, and 111 Isonic.


What fin are you using with your SS?

LeeD
3939 posts
3 Dec 2020 7:37AM
Thumbs Up

All around, stock weird bump 38.
Underpowered, 40 Makani Slalom or 380 Finworks.
For sure powered, Tectonics Gold Wing 38 or
Rainbow custom 38 fron 25 years ago.
Each has it's good or bad days, depending on conditions.

LeeD
3939 posts
3 Dec 2020 8:41AM
Thumbs Up

Remember, we are talking top speed, not acceleration.
With more weight comes slower acceleration....but more glide/momentum.
And for sure, "easier" is usually faster than "high strung".
Some slalom boards are easier...Tabou and Exocet.
Obviously, pilot skill is huge.
More skill can favor full slalom, while beginner shortboarder would do best with rec Freeide or widestyle.

remery
WA, 3709 posts
3 Dec 2020 9:19AM
Thumbs Up

My Windtech 57 (90L) is faster than my JP Supersport 100.

LeeD
3939 posts
3 Dec 2020 9:34AM
Thumbs Up

Sure, for you in higher wind and possibly choppier water.
I've had Neil Sheltema boards since early '90's, used his production boards in the mid '90's. All great handling, better in higher wind choppy conditions than flat, artificial world conditions.
But I was just a lightweight rec sailor.
Possibly someone the size of Bjorn Dunkerbeck would want a much longer flat off the tail, thicker rails, lower overall rocker, and more volume back.
And a lightweight like Robbie would prefer thinner rails and tail, at least as long flat off the tail, narrower and thinner.
There is NO one fast universal board for everyone.
That's why all the options of shape, rockerline, width placement, weight, fitting placements and balance.

LeeD
3939 posts
3 Dec 2020 9:41AM
Thumbs Up

This year, although I've been concentrating on learning foil, I've sailed more than 20 days with big guys with numbers and sponsor logos on their sails and some of their boards..
JP Slaloms, Patriks, AirInsides, and Isonics.
Usually, they come in bunches, showing up together. I usually join in and never been dropped....and often with much smaller sails for rider size.

LeeD
3939 posts
3 Dec 2020 9:43AM
Thumbs Up

Of course, the ride is soon over. At 71, the end is near, especially for my weight.

remery
WA, 3709 posts
3 Dec 2020 10:08AM
Thumbs Up

I did a lot of GPS runs on the Supersport in smooth water and seemed stuck around 34. I got 37 on the Windtech pretty easily. Same sails and fin.

LeeD
3939 posts
3 Dec 2020 10:37AM
Thumbs Up

Sounds like you need to unstick your SS.
Rear straps back and out, front to find your stance width, track to just un wet, boom height to allow adjustment in flight, lines to allow straightened arms, fin big enough to lift but not drag......
Dialed in, narrower board should be faster when well powered and wider board faster when holey or underpowered.
There are plenty of days my 85 liter Naish Freeride is faster than my SS or Isonic.

LeeD
3939 posts
3 Dec 2020 10:44AM
Thumbs Up

100 SS is around 62 cm wide.
Sheltema 57.
Now measure tail ofo and diff might be more than 5cm.

wa881
WA, 218 posts
3 Dec 2020 3:05PM
Thumbs Up

Yes free race can be faster. I've got Patrik slaloms 94, 110 and 128. All quick and comfortable for slaloms. Tried the F Race 100 last year and was blown away by its comfort and speed. Defn no slower that *board or others, in fact often faster because of ability to push harder without feeling edgy, bouncy or out of control. GYbing far less technical and smoother.

I've now got the new F Race 100 and 120. The 100 is awesome in 20+ knots with a 7.0 and 6.2. My board of choice. 120 I haven;'t got the best out of yet so still playing around with combos. Defn less bouncy than the slaloms, probably a bit too sedate for my liking ATM but it has shown glimpses of speed. I'm sure it will get there. The 100 though is a confirmed weapon and I would never choose a slalom board again in that size. Maybe in the larger sizes once I work out the 120....

Madge
NSW, 471 posts
3 Dec 2020 7:26PM
Thumbs Up

A heck of a lot of it will depend on the sailor.

I have been over taken powered up on a slalom board by someone smaller with a smaller sail on a wave board.

I'm just slow........

Tardy
5260 posts
3 Dec 2020 4:37PM
Thumbs Up

hey wa881 ..i also have scored a 120 freerace ..it def has some good speed in it ..NEEDS a 42 fin i have found .for most days ..only had it for a month or so not had a good run of wind over this way ...

I'm in the throws of getting a 100 litre speed machine ..for 7,0 been tossing over 2021 100 patrik SLALOM ,a 110 slalom 2018 ,but since you mentioned it ,may consider the 100 freerace ....

I do have a 92 11 ,but being 95 kgs it is a sinker for me ..but a awesome high wind speedster .

how fast do you reckon you will get out of your 100 FREERACE .??

John340
QLD, 3363 posts
3 Dec 2020 7:41PM
Thumbs Up

I owned a 2019 F-race 100. Its a great board. As others have said, the speed is accessible because its easier to ride. I found it had a peak speed of just over 37 kts. This was in 25+kts and flat water. I've recently upgraded to a 2020 Fanatic Falcon 97. This board is a weapon. In the same conditions as the F-race I've done 38.5kts and there is definitely more to get.

remery
WA, 3709 posts
3 Dec 2020 6:36PM
Thumbs Up

The Supersport was definitely stuck. I had everything all the way back. Maybe it doesn't like tiny weed fins. I have a mate coming over this year so might give it another run this year. Maybe even stick a rig on my 80s Wright Designs speed board.

Tardy
5260 posts
3 Dec 2020 6:41PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
John340 said..
I owned a 2019 F-race 100. Its a great board. As others have said, the speed is accessible because its easier to ride. I found it had a peak speed of just over 37 kts. This was in 25+kts and flat water. I've recently upgraded to a 2020 Fanatic Falcon 97. This board is a weapon. In the same conditions as the F-race I've done 38.5kts and there is definitely more to get.


Thanks John

duzzi
1120 posts
3 Dec 2020 11:57PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
John340 said..
I owned a 2019 F-race 100. Its a great board. As others have said, the speed is accessible because its easier to ride. I found it had a peak speed of just over 37 kts. This was in 25+kts and flat water. I've recently upgraded to a 2020 Fanatic Falcon 97. This board is a weapon. In the same conditions as the F-race I've done 38.5kts and there is definitely more to get.

Still waiting for my Futura 71, but I will never see those speeds we do not have 25 knots and flat water ... Regarding the slalom vs freerace in general I have no problem handling a smaller slalom board and so I am not sure i will go freerace, that is Futura again, for a smaller slalom. Given how great my Exocet 62 slalom works for me I am now very tempted to get the new version next year. If I can get it to the US 230 x 62 x 95L still takes me home with my 72 Kg and has proven a great size with 5.4-6.6 ... Isonic is also getting interesting: 225 x 63 x 93L, short should work a charm when turning a slalom board in swell.

LeeD
3939 posts
4 Dec 2020 2:04AM
Thumbs Up

Remery, maybe try a weed fin that holds the tail in line, and also lifts the windward rail to UnWet. Higher booms to rake back more loads the fin, so you might actually be crabbing when at speed.

LeeD
3939 posts
4 Dec 2020 2:19AM
Thumbs Up

Tough to tell just by looking, which new board is going to be fast AND easy handling.
We know we need around 40" flat from the tail. True slalom might have slightly less for top speed and always powered sails.
Fast freeride can have more, for easy speed, glide, speed with smaller sails.
Outline can include wider OFO for slalom, so narrower for FSPeed.....acceleration vs control and top end.
Rail tuck WP back should be softer on FSpeed, but I see most new slaloms are well tucked even to between the straps.
Thickness in tail goes both ways currently, so thought in progress.
Rear strap screw is well back now, around 6" min compared to my 1985 idea of 10-29". So front screw stays the same...wider stance favor the new bigger riders.
To hold a huge slalom sail needs mast track well forwards, maybe 23" from center of front straps. Fast freeride can go less, because smaller and sometimes rec sails are used...but never near freestyle setups.

wa881
WA, 218 posts
4 Dec 2020 4:58PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Tardy said..
hey wa881 ..i also have scored a 120 freerace ..it def has some good speed in it ..NEEDS a 42 fin i have found .for most days ..only had it for a month or so not had a good run of wind over this way ...

I'm in the throws of getting a 100 litre speed machine ..for 7,0 been tossing over 2021 100 patrik SLALOM ,a 110 slalom 2018 ,but since you mentioned it ,may consider the 100 freerace ....

I do have a 92 11 ,but being 95 kgs it is a sinker for me ..but a awesome high wind speedster .

how fast do you reckon you will get out of your 100 FREERACE .??


Thanks for the advice on the 120 42 fin. I haven't used that yet but will do. I agree that it seems very fin dependent.

I would go the F Race 100 unless you really want to squeeze maybe a couple more knots out, maybe. In nasty Swan River chop I would rather be on the 100 though in anything over 20+ knots. As I said, have had the 94 V1 slalom for 7 years. Awesome board and comfortable for a slalom but the 100 is just a revelation. I had the demo last year for 6 weeks and didn't want to give it back.

MarkSSC
QLD, 642 posts
5 Dec 2020 7:45AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
LeeD said..
Depends on your skill.
A top race car driver pushes his race car to the limit.
You drive his car 10 seconds a lap slower.
But you can drive a detuned race car faster than you can drive a pro's car.


I think I read about a race where a professional (Guy Cribb) used a freeride board against other riders using slalom boards. Not sure who won but Cribb did prove on the day that his skill was the difference because even with the freeride board he was able to mix it with the guys with specialised gear. Moral of the story...if you want to go fast, improve your skills.

The Craw
WA, 228 posts
5 Dec 2020 5:57AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
remery said..
The Supersport was definitely stuck. I had everything all the way back. Maybe it doesn't like tiny weed fins. I have a mate coming over this year so might give it another run this year. Maybe even stick a rig on my 80s Wright Designs speed board.


Didn't find the 100 super sport was slow/stuck with the stock fin ,
www.gpsteamchallenge.com.au/sailor_session/show?date=2009-02-06&team=2

LeeD
3939 posts
5 Dec 2020 6:27AM
Thumbs Up

But Remery was using a self admitted too small weed fin, not the stock 36cm.
Need a pretty big weed fin to equal that much lift.

The Craw
WA, 228 posts
5 Dec 2020 7:36AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
LeeD said..
But Remery was using a self admitted too small weed fin, not the stock 36cm.
Need a pretty big weed fin to equal that much lift.


Was using the 29 super sport fin

LeeD
3939 posts
5 Dec 2020 10:27AM
Thumbs Up

Stock fin for 100 SS is 36.
29, I doubt is a SSport fin.
Read again, Remery said "tiny weed fin" .



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"free race board vs full slalom in top speed, can free race be as fast ? in your opinion" started by Tardy