Forums > Windsurfing   Western Australia

went kitesurfing today

Reply
Created by MattWA > 9 months ago, 17 Nov 2010
MattWA
WA, 80 posts
17 Nov 2010 7:52PM
Thumbs Up

went kitesurfing today,

It actually was good fun, after half hour of bodydragging i went for few runs on a surfboard with straps.
had bit of drama staying upwind, but it was exciting!

ive been wavesailing for about 5 years, and only just getting consistent at it..

the beginner stage of kitesurfing is def quicker to learn then windsurfing.

when you get better at it i am not sure if you get the same thrill as doing a big backie, stalled forward or arial...

but in 12 knots i reckon its def more fun then formula sailing...

red thumb me people if you want, but none of that half arse crap, give me the full red bar or like it.

Matt



P.C_simpson
WA, 1492 posts
17 Nov 2010 8:49PM
Thumbs Up

If i see you out wavesailing with boardies over you wetsuit i'm gunna have to take to you with my mast extension..

Phil27
WA, 194 posts
17 Nov 2010 9:36PM
Thumbs Up

yeah im considering it myself...only in light winds though. So many times im dogging around on my 5.8 watching kiters go past and riding a wave..especially at places like scarboro. Its just do i want to splash out on kite gear or spend that on better windsurfing gear. It has to be said that when its pumping, big swell and high winds, the windsurfers rip it up more than the kiters....decisions decisions!!!

MattWA
WA, 80 posts
17 Nov 2010 9:54PM
Thumbs Up

we are almost there people :)


want the whole thing red!



Matt

FilthyAmatuer
WA, 877 posts
18 Nov 2010 9:24AM
Thumbs Up

MattWA said...

we are almost there people :)


want the whole thing red!



Matt


+1 red thumb from me... only because you asked for it.

Troppo
WA, 887 posts
18 Nov 2010 2:34PM
Thumbs Up

Typical kite surfer can't even get a full bar.

gazza
WA, 647 posts
18 Nov 2010 5:41PM
Thumbs Up

Troppo said...

Typical kite surfer can't even get a full bar.


and also has to tell everyone he's been kiting

gazza
WA, 647 posts
18 Nov 2010 5:41PM
Thumbs Up

Troppo said...

Typical kite surfer can't even get a full bar.


and also has to tell everyone he's been kiting

Greenroom
WA, 7608 posts
18 Nov 2010 10:52PM
Thumbs Up

Stuttering Gaz?

lotofwind
NSW, 6451 posts
24 Nov 2010 5:04PM
Thumbs Up

^^^^^^Its an echo,,because the dancer forum is so empty,numbers are dwindeling

lotofwind
NSW, 6451 posts
24 Nov 2010 6:15PM
Thumbs Up

^^^^^^Its an echo,,because the dancer forum is so empty,numbers are dwindeling



^^^^^^^^^^^see,,,ECHO ECHO echo echo






nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
24 Nov 2010 6:17PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Lotofwind,

What do you do for a day job?

Not a jehovahs witness by any chance

lotofwind
NSW, 6451 posts
25 Nov 2010 9:06PM
Thumbs Up

Im a windsufing instructor
but ssshhhhhhhh, dont tell anyone.

All you guys just asumed I was a 16 year old grommet,
but Im actually a 58 year old ex-windsurfer that has seen how limiting a big board and sail can be.

I still give lessons as I have done for the last 15 years,but kiting in the waves is a hell of alot more faster,manoverable and more enjoyable for me, than on the old sailboard.
but what ever floats your old school boat I guess.

mrrt
WA, 72 posts
25 Nov 2010 10:19PM
Thumbs Up

Well, a few years back after 20 years of windsurfing my wife and I had a few goes on her brother-in-law's 8m kite and really liked it. We then bought a kitesurfer rig hoping to kite surf when the wind was too light for windsurfing.

We definitely found it easier in many ways to learn than windsurfing and in fact I accidentally did three small jumps in a row on one run, landing it each time after only a few goes. It is indeed quite fun and requires a lot less skill to get airborne. Just pendulum the kite and up you go.

However, I found that our 12m kite needed just as much wind to get going in light winds as my 6m sail and it was only guys with monster 20m kites that were able to sail in the really light conditions.

Now I love the waves and chop hopping and jumping on my JP wave slalom windsurfer. However, I always found kiting, that as with water skiing, chop is murder on your legs and we usually ended up kiting on rather boring flat water as otherwise you were just fighting the waves. It was particularly hard work angling the board to get up wind in rougher conditions (we sailed with a slalom kite board so I can't speak from experience regarding bi-directional boards). Because all the force of the wind in the kite goes down thru your body and legs, whereas in windsurfing you can just hang from the boom and let the mast foot take all the pressure, I often found kiting took it out of my legs a lot more (particularly in rough water).

I can be out windsurfing for 6 or more hours on a strong day and in that time loads of kiters go out and come back in again with very little endurance. (mind you I do see lots of windsurfers who don't have much stamina as well!)

I also got very tired of spending ages on the beach all the time untangling the blasted lines and re-launching the downed kite out on the water when things got tangled was murder - always with the fear of getting a finger sliced off by the lines if the kite re-launched when I was in the middle of it all. It was always a pain having to get someone to help launch and land the kite on the beach - not so good when you want to head out for a quick bit of solo sailing.

I also felt very guilty about how much beach and water I took up with my kite and lines and if I dropped it in the drink - oh the embarrassment - and the swim of shame if I couldn't re-launch!

I then had a near-death experience on the river when I came off the board and was dragged underwater towards rocks on the shore and couldn't reach any of the safety releases because of the water pressure and I started to lose my enthusiasm. My brother-in-law-in-law also had a nasty kitemare (funny there is no equivalent term in windsurfing) and he suddenly developed an intense liking for sea kayaking and hasn't kited since.

Then that experienced kiter was killed down at Safety Bay and I couldn't help but notice the 100+ kiters who had died from massive head injuries, garroting, drowning etc up to that time and my occupational therapist cousin telling me of the large number of kiters who she works with in hospital with back, neck, ankle and knee injuries and hearing about all those who'd lost fingers or ears including that female pro kiter who was garrotted by a fellow competitor's kite lines in a race and my enthusiasm dimmed even further. Video of kiters being suddenly lofted 30 feet in the air in split seconds or dragged along the ground at high speed like rag dolls into the sides of concrete ablution blocks also didn't do my determination any good.

I also noticed that I am usually out sailing on my old 7m Gaastra or new 6.2m RS slalom in winds that are too light for most kiters to do much and I'm always faster than any kite out on the water no matter what conditions and the good 'ol windsurfing kit seemed to grow in fun.

It's now been a few years and my kite gear is still hanging in my store room, but we just haven't felt the urge to get it out as when the conditions are right, all we ever want to do is break out the windsurfing kit. Maybe one day I'll try kiting again... someday soon, I'm sure...hmm.

YMMV

-Mart

lotofwind
NSW, 6451 posts
26 Nov 2010 6:44AM
Thumbs Up

sounds like you need to get some good lessons.

mrrt
WA, 72 posts
26 Nov 2010 8:30AM
Thumbs Up

lotofwind said...

sounds like you need to get some good lessons.


And that would fix all the issues I mentioned?

-Mart

lotofwind
NSW, 6451 posts
26 Nov 2010 12:58PM
Thumbs Up

mrrt said...

lotofwind said...

sounds like you need to get some good lessons.


And that would fix all the issues I mentioned?

-Mart


Yep,
You learn how to fly the kite and not be out of controll accidently doing jumps,as you put it.
You would learn how to safely launch and land, so is not a pain as you said finding someone to help you.
You would learn how to relaunch your kite so you dont get tangled lines.
You would learn to let your harness take all the weight in choppy water,,sounds like you had the classic poo man learner stance bouncing out of controll.
All the things you mentioned,are just all part of learning.
Who was your instructor????
think you might have given up too easy.Thats cool,its not for everyone,some people get a bit overwhelmed and scared by the power a kite can produce and of hurting themselves.

Gorgo
VIC, 5104 posts
26 Nov 2010 2:14PM
Thumbs Up

mrrt said...

Well, a few years back after 20 years of windsurfing my wife and I had a few goes on her brother-in-law's 8m kite and really liked it. We then bought a kitesurfer rig hoping to kite surf when the wind was too light for windsurfing.

...


In the history of kiteboarding everything you say is true. In current terms, most of it is based on history or your lack of skill/practice.

When you say "...a few years back..." I'm guessing that's pre-2005, maybe 2004. That's like comparing a wally windsurfer to a modern board and sail. Things changed in mid-2005 and consolidated in 2006. Safety, range and performance got huge.

As for riding on a 5-6-7m sail when kiters can't do much, I'll call BS on that. We (me and my mate) are often out riding on our conventional gear (12-13m kite and 140cm twintip board) when other people don't even bother going to the beach. We often do the tour out the back to keep on idea on the sailboards bobbing along half submerged.

You could be standing on a fully floating windsurf platform, and you could be moving and maintaining ground (as in SUP sailing). There's no way you would be planing.

Either way, pointing out all the possible negatives of kiteboarding is just as futile as pointing out all the negatives of windsurfing. You know that tens of thousands of people have quite happily and safely learned to do both sports and continue to do them and will continue to do them as long as the sun shines and the wind blows.

mrrt
WA, 72 posts
27 Nov 2010 12:06AM
Thumbs Up

Hey, the only reason I'm pointing out some negatives of kitesurfing is to counter the attitude that some of you bring to this forum "the dancer forum is so empty,numbers are dwindeling". 'pole dancers" etc

It's important that people see the negatives as well as the positives if they are going to make educated decisions when considering whether to spend big money moving into a new sport.

I am regularly passing kiters at Woodies on my 6.2m Neil Pryde RS Slalom on light days and doing likewise on the flat water down at Safety Bay on my 7m Gaastra Race sail on the lightest days (10-15 knots). I never said kiters weren't doing much when I am on a 5m myself though even then I am always faster than the kites. However, they jump a lot higher and longer than me on my wave slalom of course. Horses for courses. :-)

Mind you, my old very deep draught 7m Gaastra is also leaving most of the other windsurfers for dead as well on those light days, but the fact remains that I have not had occasion where any kiter has been sailing in lighter winds than I except on a few occasions when they had enormous kites - but then my biggest sail is only 7m. Maybe the kiters are all slow at Woodies and Safety Bay?

In terms of my skill, sure, there's a heck of a lot I can learn and i wasn't saying I didn't enjoy jumping my kiteboard (on purpose or not). On the contrary, I was stating how easy it is to do so. I love jumping and do so on my windsurfer on the lightest days whenever there is the merest suggestion of a ramp.

I get tangles in anything I roll up, so maybe I'm just jinxed, but every day I see kiters with lines stretched off down the beach untangling lines, so I don't think my experience is all that uncommon.

I pointed out some of the dangers and hassles of downed kites and what can go wrong to highlight the differences in risk and consequences between windsurfing and kitesurfing. While it is certainly true that kitesurfing has become significantly safer in recent years, the word kitemare is still common to kitesurfing from all I've seen. Do something wrong or get a really strong gust or wind change at the wrong time - particularly on land or when learning - and it could very easily be fatal or result in serious injury. On a windsurfer, not so much.

At the same time as I say all this, I should repeat that I do still greatly enjoy kite surfing - the big air in particular is fantastic, though I'm not really interested in most of the board tricks - just as I still greatly enjoy windsurfing. They are different and do not mean you have to give up one for the other. I did however want to point out the fact that kiting may not necessarily be the ideal light-wind option that many windsurfers think it is. It may be that a larger, deeper draft sail is all you need. That's certainly been the case for me :-)

Peace.

-Mart

yamigee
WA, 20 posts
27 Nov 2010 10:29AM
Thumbs Up

lightwind option- find a hill and get on your skateboard. fun and/or pain will ensue!



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing   Western Australia


"went kitesurfing today" started by MattWA