Forums > Windsurfing Gear Reviews

Hydrodynamix Skinny RD Wave Boom Review

Reply
Created by gazza > 9 months ago, 19 Jul 2005
gazza
WA, 647 posts
19 Jul 2005 8:03PM
Thumbs Up

I’ve been given the opportunity over the last couple of months to try the hydrodynamix Skinny RD Wave boom. As with Davo I’m not getting a new boom I’m also just giving a honest opinion on my use of this product.

This was the first time I had used a skinny boom and it did take a while to get use to, especially after using a normal boom for 15 years. Once you get used to it, though, you won’t go back. It feels better for wave riding and the weight savings are awesome giving a whole new feel to your sail.

I’ve had to wait some time to write this review as I didn’t think it was fair to write a review until I could try it in heavy conditions that could actually break a boom.

I used the boom in all wind ranges from being under and over powered on my 5.5 to being fully powered on my 4.0. The boom felt very stiff at all times even when the boom was almost fully extended.

The size of the boom is 145-180 cm, which I felt is too small, as I could still adjust it smaller even when using my 4.0. The increase in size would give a bigger range as many guys own 5.7 & 6.0 sails.

The change in diameter looks like it could be a weak spot but after sailing a heavy beach break last week (which HAS cost me a boom in the past) I watched my gear going over the falls of a ½ mast set which snapped my middle batten and my out-haul rope, the boom which I was expecting some damage had none what-so-ever.

My gear got flogged all day by some heavy waves and the boom had no problems with this punishment. I have no doubt about the strength of this boom and would use it with confidence in all conditions.

I did find my hand landing on the part where the diameter changes size but Paul from hydrodynamix is redesigning this so it is further back down the boom and will solve this problem.

I’ve used the same head and rear fitting on past hydrodynamix booms for years and have had no problems at all with the boom or ropes slipping.

I think the change in diameter from a skinny to a normal diameter boom is a great idea as you benefit from the comfort and weight of a skinny boom but still retaining stiffness and strength due to the fact the extension is still the same size as a normal boom.

The booms are $300 for this model, which I think is definitely worth it for the strength and comfort factor.

Well done on a great design.

Greenroom
WA, 7608 posts
22 Jul 2005 11:40PM
Thumbs Up

great review
i have been using a boom 150-200 29 slim grip
its called AERON
i was wondering if anyone knows where these are made
i got it new from PP about $270 give or take a few bucks
i have punished this boom like there is no tomorrow
i snapped the head with my mouth on a huge landing that went wrong
other than that this boom will not be destroyed
for the price and durability i give it a 10 out of 10
i think surf sail have a really good boom in the slim grip
im looking for a boom to use my 5.7m with
the boom is about 180cm for this sail
id like something light weight and that starts around this length and not 150cm or less as the less extension the best for being strong
can the hydros/surfsails/aerons be compared

Paul Kelf
WA, 678 posts
24 Jul 2005 12:23PM
Thumbs Up

Greenroom,
The review by Gazza is great and shows how tough the RD Wave Pro really is.
This 28mm model is purely designed for WA Wave Sailing and based on the 32mm version "Survivor Wave" which has enjoyed a good rep in WA for surviving big wipeouts.
Hydro make booms for all types of sailing and don't just market the one type, in fact we currently have 9 different models and various sizes in each.
As a comparison to the Aeron, Hydro has the 29mm Pro Slimline in
150 - 195 and 170 - 215 at $290, generally a slalom boom.
To my knowledge all brands other than a couple from Europe come out of one or two factories in Asia, including Aeron.
We have checked out the Aerons and the finish is good, very similar to NP but the front fittings just don't look like they are up to it.
Having said that some of the crappiest looking fittings can surprise you with their durability, we repair a lot of booms and see some real gems.
How did you go getting the Aeron repaired?
A lot of people buy popular and colourful gear but don't consider the fact that you can't get parts for minor repairs.
We have a Carbon or should I say (Fibreglass)Boom in for regrip and repair at the moment and can't get a simple extension clip from the importer, now that sucks!
Good luck with looking for a new boom and give us some more detail on eating that boom!

Paul

www.hydrodynamix.com

Greenroom
WA, 7608 posts
24 Jul 2005 3:57PM
Thumbs Up

hey paul
the part that actually broke was the clamp thinging that goes around the boom. im not really too sure what you call it? i launched off a wave into a big jump and back foot came out and board spun around and on the way down i still had front foot in strap and i was over the boom and when landed back on the water i face planted the boom and scored a fat lip, a swim in, and broken boom which only cost me $20 from a windsurfing shop which i dont remember where i got it from and it wasnt the shop where i got the boom.
i will put a photo in the other photo section have a look

i really do like the slim grip booms 29mm
im not that keen on carbon
so the ali ones seem fine
i will definately check out the hydro boom as these seem very popular

what are the front fittings and what are they not up to on the aeron?
how do they differ from the hydros?

my concern was that using a boom that starts at lets say 135cm and extending it to 180cm you have less strength than a boom starting at 165cm and extenting it to 180cm? would i be correct in saying this?
there would be more of the extension inside the boom

so i was after a boom for my sail of 180cm give or take a few cm in the slim grip and ali construction with light weight around the 2.5kg's for wave sailing

Paul Kelf
WA, 678 posts
24 Jul 2005 6:35PM
Thumbs Up

Greenroom,
You are right about the length, Use the biggest possible boom and have the maximum stiffness and strength.
Booms with huge extensions are a compromise as the boom is only as stiff and strong as the weakest part and that is usually the extension tube, 25mm diameter and full of holes.
I would recommend the Slimline 170 - 215 as it would probably be lighter than the RD Wave Pro but still super stiff and strong with minimal extension. www.hydrodynamix.com/assets/images/pro-slim-boom.jpg.
The Slimline aluminium is actually thicker than any other brand but still slightly thinner than the RD & Skinny Wave which are 30% thicker than other brands. The Slimline purposely has only 45cm of extension to reduce flexing. Why have stiffness in the boom and loose it in a massive extension?
Hydro also make a lot of custom booms for people who want specific sizes and sail coverage so they don't have to carry a quiver of booms.
Feel free to drop into the factory and have a look at all the options available and compare with the imported brands before shelling out your hard earned!

Paul

gazza
WA, 647 posts
15 Nov 2005 6:30PM
Thumbs Up

Just a quick up date the hydrodynamix Skinny RD Wave boom is still going strong

Ive used it all winter in all conditions and it still feels very stiff even when fully extended on my 5.5

Ive used it in exmouth on a 4.0m sailing offshore waves on my own with total confidence on its strength.

Used it at Gnaraloo last week again apart from a few cuts on the grip from the reef (sorry Paul!) its still like new

i haven't tried a carbon booms to compare it to, but if you budget is aluminium then i can't recommend these booms enough super strong and comfortable and the weight is very competitive with other brands.

i know i wont go back to using a normal diameter boom after using the Skinny RD Wave boom as its definitely helped improve my sailing

so if your after a new boom this season or your usual model keeps breaking check them out you wont be disappointed

Paul Kelf
WA, 678 posts
18 Nov 2005 10:38AM
Thumbs Up

Gazza,
Glad to hear the boom is going strong.
Don't worry about the grip, I know a guy that does good regrips.
We will swap it with next years model soon anyway.
We have now added a 155 - 190 to the existing model range in both the RD Wave and Skinny Wave, to suit the bigger sails.
Hope you can make it up to Greenhead this weekend for the Wave Comp, it's gunna go off like last year.
We will be giving away trophies and gear which will include wave booms!
Not just the winners of the various divisions will get prizes either.
We have included an under 21's division for the young guns too.

Any one interested can contact Geoff Golder for more info on 0408 900351

ju_724
231 posts
26 Nov 2005 1:35PM
Thumbs Up

hmmmm i think i'm sold. who sell's them in Perth?

gazza
WA, 647 posts
29 Nov 2005 6:35PM
Thumbs Up

Call Paul at Hydrodynamix on (08) 9433 5450

Great bloke should be able to put you in the right direction

bubbas
WA, 27 posts
29 Nov 2005 8:05PM
Thumbs Up

Does anyone know the quality/strength of the chinook booms?
Surf Sail Australia has a chinook wave alu. ,29mm diameter, 137-198cm, only 300$... If its strong, its a bargain! The boom will fit all my sails.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing Gear Reviews


"Hydrodynamix Skinny RD Wave Boom Review" started by gazza