Forums > Windsurfing   New South Wales

Botany Bay / Airport - Cancer Chemical and Beach Closure

Reply
Created by PeterPaan > 9 months ago, 4 Jan 2025
PeterPaan
NSW, 67 posts
4 Jan 2025 11:17PM
Thumbs Up

Just saw this news today. I wonder if the cancer causing chemical has been an existing issue, or they only discovered it now?

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14248549/tower-beach-sydney-airport-pfas-chemicals.html

powersloshin
NSW, 1835 posts
5 Jan 2025 8:28PM
Thumbs Up

another reason not to miss your jibes

berowne
NSW, 1522 posts
6 Jan 2025 7:58AM
Thumbs Up

But the teflon makes me go faster!

MobZ
NSW, 457 posts
8 Jan 2025 8:54PM
Thumbs Up

Maybe the author of this story is a windsurfer and keen to get parking for a go at the airport.
I'd love to try it there.

MrBlean
NSW, 11 posts
18 Jan 2025 11:36PM
Thumbs Up

Whilst no form of pollution is good news, this is a typical tabloid click-bait story. First, the beach isn't closed as per the headline. Whilst I haven't seen them myself (as I haven't looked), it appears there are signs saying you should not swim in the water. So the water is 'closed', not the beach. Ingesting the chemicals is the issue, not being in contact with them. So going on the beach is not dangerous. Swallowing lots of sea water is probably not a good idea, for this and a host of other reasons. There are plenty of pathogens in the form of various enterococci in the sea that would make you very sick or could kill you within days if were you unfortunate enough to get infected. Plus the heavy metal pollution in Sydney harbour makes it one of THE most polluted estuaries in the world. Given it's tidal, a percentage of this will get washed into the open sea. Second, the chemicals concerned have been 'linked' to cancer, there is not yet proof they are cancer inducing. The source is almost certainly fire-fighting foam used at Sydney airport that has leeched into the local water sources.

stehsegler
WA, 3542 posts
31 Jan 2025 2:09PM
Thumbs Up

Botany Bay always has and always will be the most polluted body of water in Sydney. From toxic ground water on foreshore road to the toxic cocktail coming out of Cooks River after every rain. Never mind the Sewer outfall at Bondi which adds to the problems if the wind direction is right. I think PFAS is the least of your problems.

berowne
NSW, 1522 posts
2 Feb 2025 11:37AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
MrBlean said..
Whilst no form of pollution is good news, this is a typical tabloid click-bait story. First, the beach isn't closed as per the headline. Whilst I haven't seen them myself (as I haven't looked), it appears there are signs saying you should not swim in the water. So the water is 'closed', not the beach. Ingesting the chemicals is the issue, not being in contact with them. So going on the beach is not dangerous. Swallowing lots of sea water is probably not a good idea, for this and a host of other reasons. There are plenty of pathogens in the form of various enterococci in the sea that would make you very sick or could kill you within days if were you unfortunate enough to get infected. Plus the heavy metal pollution in Sydney harbour makes it one of THE most polluted estuaries in the world. Given it's tidal, a percentage of this will get washed into the open sea. Second, the chemicals concerned have been 'linked' to cancer, there is not yet proof they are cancer inducing. The source is almost certainly fire-fighting foam used at Sydney airport that has leeched into the local water sources.


Beach was closed last weekend for cleanup operation. Bobcat moving sand around and truck vacuum cleaner doing 'something'

And yes, I was also wondering if it was the firefighting chemicals.

JustinL
NSW, 468 posts
Site Sponsor
5 May 2025 11:16AM
Thumbs Up

Apparently, Homebush Bay near Olympic Park can never be thanks to Union Carbide.

Back in another life I worked on the Sydney Olympic Bid. I was drafting the masterplans. We were marketing ourselves as Green and Clean so didn't go through with a proposal of digging up the ground and putting it into concrete bunkers underground.

stehsegler
WA, 3542 posts
8 May 2025 3:43PM
Thumbs Up

Never mind the toxic sludge coming out of Cook River every time it rains... and what about all the chemicals on Foreshore Road on the other side of the bay leaking through from across the road.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing   New South Wales


"Botany Bay / Airport - Cancer Chemical and Beach Closure" started by PeterPaan