Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk

Well We Had Wind!!!!

Reply
Created by izaak > 9 months ago, 20 Aug 2010
izaak
TAS, 2013 posts
20 Aug 2010 8:20PM
Thumbs Up

take a look and let me know if someone can have a look at my tracks to see if i can get the 40 but i dont think so.

gpsteamchallenge.com.au/sailor_session/show?date=2010-08-20&team=27

easty
TAS, 2213 posts
20 Aug 2010 9:11PM
Thumbs Up

Gutsy effort to all of you.

elmo
WA, 8868 posts
20 Aug 2010 7:32PM
Thumbs Up

PM 'd you Izaak

yoyo
WA, 1646 posts
23 Aug 2010 2:00PM
Thumbs Up

Tom Chalko's Fourier program will get a 40.276 for you if you are desperate but if everyone else is calculating using Realspeed, KA72 etc it does defeat the point a little.

http://sci-e-research.com/Fourier.zip

izaak
TAS, 2013 posts
23 Aug 2010 6:22PM
Thumbs Up

thanks for that but i will leave it at that till i get it though real speed doppler or KA72.i hope it wont be long.

yoyo
WA, 1646 posts
23 Aug 2010 4:57PM
Thumbs Up

In a peaky run like the one you did at Henty I think Tom's Fourier program may be more accurate as the Fourier program blends the speeds in a more natural "real world" way whereas the Realspeed joins the instantaneous recording points with a straight line. But then again when you look at the points on Tom's graph it does also look like it adds changes which are not there. Tom shows a small drop in speed at 33 on the acceleration but the actual recorded points continue to rise. Doesn't look like a best fit curve to me.



At a place like SP where you plateau for a fair way at your top speed the straight line in RealSpeed probably makes very little difference.

sailquik
VIC, 6165 posts
23 Aug 2010 7:45PM
Thumbs Up

GPS-Results uses the GPS-SS approved method to integrate the curve. Toms Fourier method is not approved. In GPS-Results it uses the Cubic Spline method by default for 10 sec and 20 sec. You can switch the options to trapezoidal or quadratic spline for 2/10/20 sec. Worth a play if you have the program. If you don't, send your track to me and I will send you the results.

izaak
TAS, 2013 posts
23 Aug 2010 7:58PM
Thumbs Up

andrew i will send the track to ya and see what ya think,im not too fussed what the out come is.

yoyo
WA, 1646 posts
23 Aug 2010 6:35PM
Thumbs Up

Izaak, Gps-Results is a nice program and you can have a free trial period.

You find it at www.gps-speed.com

sailquik
VIC, 6165 posts
23 Aug 2010 9:02PM
Thumbs Up

Cubic spline and Rectangular give the same result (it does not integrate the 2 sec on this filter setting) in GPS-Results: 40.364+/-0.301
Note the correction factor. Even if you take this off you get a 40+ two sec.
This result of worked out from 2 data points.
Trapezoidal (the default in most versions of RealSpeed) uses 3 data points and in GPS-Results it gets 39.902+/-0.306. Note that this is +/- 0.306 so your real speed could have been as high as 40.2 even with this system.
Quadratic integration also uses 3 data points and gives 40.170+/-0.314.
I think you should be confident that in this case there is a very high probability that you did 2 seconds over 40 knots!

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
23 Aug 2010 8:14PM
Thumbs Up

I think there's a high probability that you went faster than I've ever gone, and I'm very jealous!!!

We have had a couple of instances where people have tried to use different programs and methods to bump up their scores, and it always ends badly. For me as well as them!

In all seriousness, you're best off with just going by what your usual program gives you. That way you keep your integrity, no-one will accuse you of cheating and you get to sleep at night.

You should be immensely proud of that special day, and I know that next time conditions are right you're going to smash that 40 knot barrier into tiny little pieces!

izaak
TAS, 2013 posts
23 Aug 2010 10:21PM
Thumbs Up

yes thanks for the help guys, i will leave it at that.but will say to others ive done 40 im am very pleased with what i did any way

pity it still isn't a 2 sec average in Doppler cause thats what we use on GPSTC so why not make it 3sec on it.

decrepit
WA, 12767 posts
23 Aug 2010 9:08PM
Thumbs Up

izaak said...
[>>>>
pity it still isn't a 2 sec average in Doppler cause thats what we use on GPSTC so why not make it 3sec on it.


Not sure what you mean here Izaack, but if you're querying why 3 points are used to calculate doppler 2 seconds. The answer is fairly simple, each doppler data point is close to instantaneous, so for a second, you need 2 points, the start and the end of the second. For 2 seconds you also need the start and the end, this means 3 points. So it's quite possible you actually went a bit faster than your peak speed, a point in between the 2 fastest readings

Trackpoints only needs 2, because each point is the distance travelled in that second.

slowboat
WA, 560 posts
23 Aug 2010 11:56PM
Thumbs Up

next stop 500m NM would be great if there were more than 2 places in the world where this was possible, but most countries can post a respectable 500m. Even if it involves aeroplanes. Great effort seeing 40 on the dial. I remember when I first did that and was jumping for joy (despite the fact it was probably a spike on mine ). Hopefully it blows at speed fortnight. Will catch up for a beer (with your old man )

KenHo
NSW, 1353 posts
24 Aug 2010 7:12AM
Thumbs Up

Congrats Izaak, you give me hope.
I'm curious as to what gear you were on, if you don't mind me asking.
I'm currently trying to buy some speed gear myself, (IF ANYONE WOULD ANSWER THEIR MAIL !!) so I'm keen to hear, though I am pretty settled on what I want.

izaak
TAS, 2013 posts
24 Aug 2010 8:03AM
Thumbs Up

forget i said that decrepit.we may have some cranking NM though summer a henty we think its the right length.

kenho i was using my JP speed 45, Neilpryde RS Racing EVOII 4.7 with a ka lockwood asymmetrical 20cm fin. and wow what a combination !

KenHo
NSW, 1353 posts
24 Aug 2010 8:46AM
Thumbs Up

Neat !!
I'm looking at a similar size board and fin, though will probably need larger sails. I'll stick to a symmetrical fin, as I have fast port tack places to sail too.
It's been too long since I went scary fast.

lao shi
WA, 1338 posts
24 Aug 2010 6:24PM
Thumbs Up

I had a sail on the 45 recently and it needed a lot of wind with my 78kg and a koncept 5m to get it planing. Spent a lot of time swimming on that gusty day. It was certainly quick but I could not get enough use out of one here in WA to justify a purchase.

KenHo
NSW, 1353 posts
24 Aug 2010 8:34PM
Thumbs Up

Run a bigger sail.
I'll start with a 6.4/6.6.

lao shi said...

I had a sail on the 45 recently and it needed a lot of wind with my 78kg and a koncept 5m to get it planing. Spent a lot of time swimming on that gusty day. It was certainly quick but I could not get enough use out of one here in WA to justify a purchase.




Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk


"Well We Had Wind!!!!" started by izaak