Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk

OMG SPRING CUP last minutes Who'll win?

Reply
Created by hardie > 9 months ago, 30 Nov 2010
hardie
WA, 4129 posts
30 Nov 2010 10:11PM
Thumbs Up



gpsteamchallenge.com.au/sailor_session/show?date=2010-11-30&team=16

Will the file have to be split?

mathew
QLD, 2133 posts
1 Dec 2010 12:20AM
Thumbs Up

Realspeed automatically splits the file, by date.... you would need to select the "combined" file to get the full stats.

izaak
TAS, 2013 posts
1 Dec 2010 7:58AM
Thumbs Up

so if kato posts today sometime and the pit end up on top for month, do they get it or was cut off midnight for cup results? witch i think it should be, any way if not it will be close.

AUS02
TAS, 2038 posts
1 Dec 2010 8:07AM
Thumbs Up

I think everyone still has a week to post for it to count, but looks like it's only Kato who we are waiting on!! Perhaps he is still sailing!!

izaak
TAS, 2013 posts
1 Dec 2010 8:15AM
Thumbs Up

yes i thought that was the case, well it would not surprise me if he still was.

Wineman
NSW, 1412 posts
1 Dec 2010 9:37AM
Thumbs Up


You sure those Pit Boys are not pulling your leg Izaak?? [}:)]

Nah. They wouldn't do that, would they.

Old Salty
VIC, 1271 posts
1 Dec 2010 9:58AM
Thumbs Up

Rumour mill is the MAN MACHINE is still going
GO Kato

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
1 Dec 2010 7:18AM
Thumbs Up

553.5 km

buzzy
TAS, 2433 posts
1 Dec 2010 10:38AM
Thumbs Up

I just drove through Hobart and there was a blonde guy waveing severne and starboard flags. He was being restrained by four big blokes in white, they were trying to get a big white back to front jacket on him. He was frothing at the mouth scream something about 'He can't do this, he can't, its mine all mine, he can't, I wont let him, dam you kato i'll have my revenge...' then they hit him with a tazer and stuffed him into a padded van.

AUS02
TAS, 2038 posts
1 Dec 2010 11:30AM
Thumbs Up

... and he was never heard of again!

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
1 Dec 2010 8:57AM
Thumbs Up

buzzy said...

I just drove through Hobart and there was a blonde guy waveing severne and starboard flags. He was being restrained by four big blokes in white, they were trying to get a big white back to front jacket on him. He was frothing at the mouth scream something about 'He can't do this, he can't, its mine all mine, he can't, I wont let him, dam you kato i'll have my revenge...' then they hit him with a tazer and stuffed him into a padded van.


evets
WA, 685 posts
1 Dec 2010 11:53AM
Thumbs Up

AUS02 said...

... and he was never heard of again!


Who said that?

yoyo
WA, 1646 posts
1 Dec 2010 12:27PM
Thumbs Up

Nebs , in cases like this do you go off daylight saving time (an artificial construct, not applied universally across Australia) or the UTC/GMT time, which would be 1am.

My feeling is Kato should be able to count his Ks up to 1am for the November month.

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
1 Dec 2010 2:31PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Yoyo,

It's a tricky one allright. The most defensive is to say "Midnight local time", whatever that happens to be, whether daylight savings are applied or not.

Ie if you were to ring the talking clock in that area, the cutoff is when it says "Twelve am precisely".

This is because the session is all keyed by date, and the date changes over at midnight local time.


It sucks having to split Kato's file in half though, I wish there were some way of showing just how far he went in one 24 hour period... maybe that's what GPS-SS is for.

kato
VIC, 3507 posts
1 Dec 2010 5:36PM
Thumbs Up

nebbian said...

Hey Yoyo,

It's a tricky one allright. The most defensive is to say "Midnight local time", whatever that happens to be, whether daylight savings are applied or not.

Ie if you were to ring the talking clock in that area, the cutoff is when it says "Twelve am precisely".

This is because the session is all keyed by date, and the date changes over at midnight local time.


It sucks having to split Kato's file in half though, I wish there were some way of showing just how far he went in one 24 hour period... maybe that's what GPS-SS is for.


Daffy,s on to it. The 24hr is 540km,the distance will be around 490ish

kato
VIC, 3507 posts
1 Dec 2010 5:54PM
Thumbs Up


nearly all colored in

sausage
QLD, 4873 posts
1 Dec 2010 5:46PM
Thumbs Up

Out of interest is that the world record for most number of gybes in 24hours.
(Hurry up Kato and count them)

elmo
WA, 8868 posts
1 Dec 2010 4:32PM
Thumbs Up

my vote

it was one session, count it as that

Wineman
NSW, 1412 posts
1 Dec 2010 7:42PM
Thumbs Up

elmo said...

my vote

it was one session, count it as that


Nuh!

Don't go changing the rules now Elmo just because of unusual circumstances.

We ALL know he done it, & like Dave's effort (on same day of year - weird) it is just out there as freakin' amazing.

izaak
TAS, 2013 posts
1 Dec 2010 7:53PM
Thumbs Up

sorry a great effort, but rules are rules.It could stuff up the outcome of this month or any another month it may occur again. if he sailed past twelve PM there should be one for yesterday and session for today.

sick_em_rex
NSW, 1600 posts
1 Dec 2010 8:48PM
Thumbs Up

I vote it counts just for the sheer audacity of the feat and the committment....BUT, rules are rules I guess and final say should go to Nebs and Hards in my opinion. Whatever they decide I am happy to live by.
Well done Craig, truly astounding

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
1 Dec 2010 7:22PM
Thumbs Up

You're right, sick_em, the sheer audacity of this effort is astounding. I have immense respect for anyone who can go more than 200 k's in a day, and to more than double that is just... plain... superhuman.

There's no doubt in my mind that Kato did that distance, and there's also no doubt that it is an incredible achievement.


However this track has thrown up an interesting conundrum, in that no-one to my knowledge has ever sailed past midnight and kept going ... So we have two options:

Option 1) Allow people to pick and choose which 24 hour period they want to sail in. My problem with this is that someone could easily sail 100 km from midday till sunset, then have a nice meal, a sleep, wake up early the next morning and sail another 100 k's, for a total of 200 km in one 24 hour period. This isn't nearly as muscle-wrenching as a solid 200km in one session, and I really don't want to encourage this sort of manipulation. Apart from anything else, do you say that the session happened on the date that you started, or the date that you finished?

Option 2) Set the cutoff at midnight local time. This has the benefit of being clear, concise, there's no argument about which day you choose to take it as, and most GPS programs are set up to split files by date anyway.

I think we have to choose option 2) here, just from a parity / rulekeeping / keep it simple viewpoint.


It's worth remembering that although the GPS Team Challenge works well as a log of your sessions, it is first and foremost a competition, and we only have 6 categories to record performance in.

This has worked well for most things, however every now and again someone throws us a curve ball which shows that our system isn't perfect.

I would dearly love to record this amazing effort somehow, please remember that splitting the file by midnight doesn't mean that Kato hasn't done that distance, it just means that we don't have a way to record it!

If GPS-SS allows posting of any 24 hour period, then I would recommend posting the track on there, and making a link on your GTC session to the GPS-SS page.


On a personal note Kato, you are un... be... lievable!!!! I can't express just how amazing that effort is.

Wineman
NSW, 1412 posts
1 Dec 2010 10:42PM
Thumbs Up


Well said Nebs (almost sage like)

I think you covered it perfectly

Ian K
WA, 4155 posts
1 Dec 2010 8:39PM
Thumbs Up

Well if someone had previously set a notable distance but stopped at midnight because that's how they'd interpreted the rules then reclarifying them now would be an issue. But I doubt anybody has? And all existing distances are still going to be valid, or increased, if it's 24 hrs start any time.

I think 24 hrs makes sense. There's plenty of other 24 hr events, Le Mans, the bike race in Canberra. None of them start at midnight. Why would you? Sail the afternoon, have a break and sail the morning. What's wrong with that? Kato's distance will still take some beating.

What an effort, it can't be pruned!


REDhat
37 posts
1 Dec 2010 9:47PM
Thumbs Up

Windsurfing as an organised sporting competition has had a long suffering history,in pre GPS teamchallenge days, of people gathering on specific days at specific locations and occasionally getting the wind required to run a competative event.
The GPS team challenge has liberated the sport from the fickleness of the wind.
Does Kato now have to wait till he can find a wind window which stretches from midnight to midnight to have his achievments recognised.
As a single ,reasonably continuous session of 24 hours, Katos achievement would pass any fairness test and does not infringe any reasonable interpretation of the refreshingly minimilist GPS teamchallenge rules.

mathew
QLD, 2133 posts
2 Dec 2010 12:31AM
Thumbs Up

This problem has come up before... and the standing was "its close enough - we arn't playing for sheep stations".

When did it occur? Apparently you dont have to worry about the time of day if you happen to be sailing in Karpathos, etc. relative to your team.

Note that the "localtime" rule as specified, wont work as where is localtime? Local to the team? Local to the individual?

decrepit
WA, 12767 posts
1 Dec 2010 10:47PM
Thumbs Up

mathew said...

>>>
Note that the "localtime" rule as specified, wont work as where is localtime? Local to the team? Local to the individual?


Think it has to be local to the sailor, (that's how the Karpathos situation was interpreted), but then there could be another problem if a time line is crossed. ie, take off from Queensland and end up in NSW in summertime you could have a 25hr day.

sausage
QLD, 4873 posts
2 Dec 2010 9:56AM
Thumbs Up

elmo said...

my vote

it was one session, count it as that


Not wanting to diminish Kato's feat, but well no technically it really wasn't one session as Kato had a sleep (albeit short)and got up to finish his 24 hour window. Reading the initial posts from GPSTC I believe his primary aim was to break the GPSSS 24 hour record (which no doubt he has) and that Neb's stance on splitting the file correctly falls into the current rules of the GPSTC.

If it aint broke don't fix it.

Magnus8
QLD, 366 posts
2 Dec 2010 9:56AM
Thumbs Up

nebbian said...

You're right, sick_em, the sheer audacity of this effort is astounding. I have immense respect for anyone who can go more than 200 k's in a day, and to more than double that is just... plain... superhuman.

There's no doubt in my mind that Kato did that distance, and there's also no doubt that it is an incredible achievement.


However this track has thrown up an interesting conundrum, in that no-one to my knowledge has ever sailed past midnight and kept going ... So we have two options:

Option 1) Allow people to pick and choose which 24 hour period they want to sail in. My problem with this is that someone could easily sail 100 km from midday till sunset, then have a nice meal, a sleep, wake up early the next morning and sail another 100 k's, for a total of 200 km in one 24 hour period. This isn't nearly as muscle-wrenching as a solid 200km in one session, and I really don't want to encourage this sort of manipulation. Apart from anything else, do you say that the session happened on the date that you started, or the date that you finished?

Option 2) Set the cutoff at midnight local time. This has the benefit of being clear, concise, there's no argument about which day you choose to take it as, and most GPS programs are set up to split files by date anyway.

I think we have to choose option 2) here, just from a parity / rulekeeping / keep it simple viewpoint.


It's worth remembering that although the GPS Team Challenge works well as a log of your sessions, it is first and foremost a competition, and we only have 6 categories to record performance in.

This has worked well for most things, however every now and again someone throws us a curve ball which shows that our system isn't perfect.

I would dearly love to record this amazing effort somehow, please remember that splitting the file by midnight doesn't mean that Kato hasn't done that distance, it just means that we don't have a way to record it!

If GPS-SS allows posting of any 24 hour period, then I would recommend posting the track on there, and making a link on your GTC session to the GPS-SS page.


On a personal note Kato, you are un... be... lievable!!!! I can't express just how amazing that effort is.


Option 2 is the only option.

sausage
QLD, 4873 posts
2 Dec 2010 10:00AM
Thumbs Up

Option 2 isn't actually an option - it's the existing rule.

Just as a comparison
Dave Morehead - On the water at 5:20am and off the water at 7:45pm with two short stops. Total 511km in 14hours and 25mins
Craig Hollins - On the water at 7.15 am and finised at 7.30 the next day. The best 24 hr window in GPS-Results produced 540.9 km's. Reading GPSTC log, approx 490kms were achieved between 7.15am and 11.30pm. Total 490kms in 16hrs & 15mins

Both phenominal efforts of endurance (and slight craziness to boot)

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
2 Dec 2010 9:04AM
Thumbs Up

I think Nebbs has got it right.

The Challenge is a Monthly Team Based competition with the program written to allocate points and rankings accordingly.

A separate issue is Kato's Outstanding world record individual performance which also needs recognition. Certainly it is a WSSRC & GPSSS issue. How we do this in the GTC I'm not sure. Whether a manual entry could be done where the 555km's is shown in bold or brackets, beside or next to the requirements of the GTC? I dunno, and Nebbs does enuff free work for all of us, that i dont want him having to write a complete program to work this out.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk


"OMG SPRING CUP last minutes Who'll win?" started by hardie