Forums > Windsurfing General

wing ding craze offically over

Reply
Created by musorianin > 9 months ago, 2 Jan 2024
musorianin
QLD, 597 posts
2 Jan 2024 1:23PM
Thumbs Up

Step aside for this...

Gestalt
QLD, 14627 posts
2 Jan 2024 1:37PM
Thumbs Up

Remind me of 1986

Subsonic
WA, 3354 posts
2 Jan 2024 11:51AM
Thumbs Up

Looks like a fairly advanced design.

segler
WA, 1656 posts
2 Jan 2024 12:50PM
Thumbs Up

Needs more downhaul.

I wonder how he goes upwind.

Doggerland
222 posts
2 Jan 2024 6:24PM
Thumbs Up

Arnaud would have rocked it



aeroegnr
1731 posts
2 Jan 2024 8:12PM
Thumbs Up

Looks like they figured out what to do with their failed excess "budget airliner escape device" inventory.

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8225 posts
3 Jan 2024 8:28AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
musorianin said..
Step aside for this...


I saw that one.. I wonder how compact it is? May be good for seakayaking although I know there are purpose built ones for them.

boardsurfr
WA, 2454 posts
3 Jan 2024 9:34AM
Thumbs Up

Amazing find - even uses a boom instead of soft handles. Please

Select to expand quote
musorianin said..
Step aside for this...


Amazing find - even uses a boom instead of soft handles. You should get one and report how it works.

Had a bit of an eye opener today, when I wind foiled at a new-to-us spot in Florida. Back home on Cape Cod, windsurfers still often outnumber wingers, and kiters outnumber both at some spots. But here, the three windsurfers and three windfoilers were vastly outnumbered by wingers. One or two teachers seemed quite busy, teaching mostly younger folks (albeit in a manner where the being dragged back upwind behind the jet ski may have been the most fun part). Lots of wingers in various age and skill groups out in mostly marginal wind, from never-evers and the large group of intermediates to a couple of experts. If the fat lady has sung, then it sure was not about winging!

musorianin
QLD, 597 posts
3 Jan 2024 11:47AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
boardsurfr said..
You should get one and report how it works.

I considered that, but not quite sure I'm ready to entrust financial details to Temu

wsurfn
97 posts
3 Jan 2024 10:45AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
boardsurfr said..
Amazing find - even uses a boom instead of soft handles. Please

musorianin said..
Step aside for this...



Amazing find - even uses a boom instead of soft handles. You should get one and report how it works.

Had a bit of an eye opener today, when I wind foiled at a new-to-us spot in Florida. Back home on Cape Cod, windsurfers still often outnumber wingers, and kiters outnumber both at some spots. But here, the three windsurfers and three windfoilers were vastly outnumbered by wingers. One or two teachers seemed quite busy, teaching mostly younger folks (albeit in a manner where the being dragged back upwind behind the jet ski may have been the most fun part). Lots of wingers in various age and skill groups out in mostly marginal wind, from never-evers and the large group of intermediates to a couple of experts. If the fat lady has sung, then it sure was not about winging!


Peter, just sailed BIB New Years Eve. Wings out numbered windsurfers 4:2 (what an evolution). I did both, but I would rather sail the bay for both winging and windsurfing now.

Cuchufleta
201 posts
4 Jan 2024 1:59AM
Thumbs Up

Over here in the Netherlands the Wingers are outnumbering the windsurfers by 10:1 below 20 knots. Stronger winds and it's getting diluted. More and more Wingers seem to be getting on with stronger winds. Sea state is another thing. When it gets fun windsurfing (waves, shorebreak), it is still the windsurfers in charge.

However the demographic of Wingers and windsurfers is pretty much the same here. Kitesurfing still has the younger demographic.

When my mates return from the dark side on windy days they all can't stop about how good windsurfing is. So windsurfing is definitely not dead here but it's not really attracting the youngsters either.

MarkSSC
QLD, 642 posts
4 Jan 2024 9:33AM
Thumbs Up

Is it just me or do windsurfers just look fast? The sail looks like it is built for speed, compact and colourful. The alternatives look about as sleek as a rubber balloon.

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8225 posts
4 Jan 2024 11:03AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
MarkSSC said..
Is it just me or do windsurfers just look fast? The sail looks like it is built for speed, compact and colourful. The alternatives look about as sleek as a rubber balloon.


Windsurfing is definitely more interesting to photograph.

MikeyS
VIC, 1509 posts
4 Jan 2024 11:28AM
Thumbs Up

Does it come as an asymmetric version too?

airsail
QLD, 1535 posts
4 Jan 2024 11:08AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
MarkSSC said..
Is it just me or do windsurfers just look fast? The sail looks like it is built for speed, compact and colourful. The alternatives look about as sleek as a rubber balloon.


That's a common comment from windsurfers, winging definitely isn't fast, if you want fast stay on a sailboard. But if you want to ride wave/swell in not so perfect conditions, winging is a great option. And you can get going in much lighter conditions without using a huge sail.

MarkSSC
QLD, 642 posts
5 Jan 2024 6:48AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
airsail said..

MarkSSC said..
Is it just me or do windsurfers just look fast? The sail looks like it is built for speed, compact and colourful. The alternatives look about as sleek as a rubber balloon.



That's a common comment from windsurfers, winging definitely isn't fast, if you want fast stay on a sailboard. But if you want to ride wave/swell in not so perfect conditions, winging is a great option. And you can get going in much lighter conditions without using a huge sail.


I was just looking at it from the aesthetic perspective. All categories have their pros and cons.

richw
NSW, 133 posts
5 Jan 2024 8:59AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
MarkSSC said..

airsail said..


MarkSSC said..
Is it just me or do windsurfers just look fast? The sail looks like it is built for speed, compact and colourful. The alternatives look about as sleek as a rubber balloon.




That's a common comment from windsurfers, winging definitely isn't fast, if you want fast stay on a sailboard. But if you want to ride wave/swell in not so perfect conditions, winging is a great option. And you can get going in much lighter conditions without using a huge sail.



I was just looking at it from the aesthetic perspective. All categories have their pros and cons.


Why not do both and live the Dream

flix123
NSW, 1 posts
5 Jan 2024 9:35AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Cuchufleta said..
Over here in the Netherlands the Wingers are outnumbering the windsurfers by 10:1 below 20 knots. Stronger winds and it's getting diluted. More and more Wingers seem to be getting on with stronger winds. Sea state is another thing. When it gets fun windsurfing (waves, shorebreak), it is still the windsurfers in charge.

However the demographic of Wingers and windsurfers is pretty much the same here. Kitesurfing still has the younger demographic.

When my mates return from the dark side on windy days they all can't stop about how good windsurfing is. So windsurfing is definitely not dead here but it's not really attracting the youngsters either.


Not sure about 10:1 ratio. I surf in scheveningen (NL wave spot ) all the time, its only more wingers when it's just not possible to windsurf (keep in mind nobody has big sails there, as we are blessed with a lot of wind usually).

Cuchufleta
201 posts
5 Jan 2024 7:42AM
Thumbs Up

Hence the below 20 knots. Of course I am only writing about my observations. Wijk aan Zee (my homespot, bit more north of Scheveningen). From my group of hard core windsurfers a lot have gone to the dark force. But hey at least the are not kiting

segler
WA, 1656 posts
5 Jan 2024 11:30AM
Thumbs Up

One day in July in Hood River, my wife and I counted 290 wingers and NOT ONE SINGLE WINDSURFER/WINDFOILER. The wind was blowing 20 kts.

Imax1
QLD, 4925 posts
5 Jan 2024 8:08PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
segler said..
One day in July in Hood River, my wife and I counted 290 wingers and NOT ONE SINGLE WINDSURFER/WINDFOILER. The wind was blowing 20 kts.


Thats disgusting, the world has gone mad.

ptsf1111
WA, 458 posts
5 Jan 2024 8:24PM
Thumbs Up

To be honest, after listening to Guy in below podcast my opinion about winging might have changed a bit. He has an interesting take on it and believes it's windsurfing. I don't necessarily agree but have a listen and it kinda makes sense. Unfortunately, it's no good news for our sport.

?si=4pXT_mSQh46KDIF1

Paducah
2785 posts
5 Jan 2024 9:22PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
ptsf1111 said..
To be honest, after listening to Guy in below podcast my opinion about winging might have changed a bit. He has an interesting take on it and believes it's windsurfing. I don't necessarily agree but have a listen and it kinda makes sense. Unfortunately, it's no good news for our sport.



But, his take is that it is our sport. All that separates us is a u-joint. I agree with him in many ways (please don't blow up my inbox ). I, too, agree with him. I tell people if they have zero experience and want to foil something, that wing is the easiest and quickest way there - just be prepared to swim. A lot. Which is one of the reasons I rarely wing since our wind can be so variable in the warm months and I'm in no mood to spend lots of time in the water in the colds ones.

All the same, I love windsurfing and talk it up every time I can. While it will have its challenges vis-a-vis winging as a "beach" sport, everything from the IQ, LT, freestyle to wave sailing still says that windsurf has aspects other windsports can't match and probably won't for a while. I think it's the kites that will suffer most as I wouldn't be surprised if wings get the Olympic nod in 28 or 32.

Back to the topic, there is a local guy who uses an umbrella to get back home after fishing on his paddle board. He is intrigued about learning to windsurf, though. Fishing off your board is another thing we've got on wings.

Subsonic
WA, 3354 posts
5 Jan 2024 10:02PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Paducah said..

Back to the topic, there is a local guy who uses an umbrella to get back home after fishing on his paddle board. He is intrigued about learning to windsurf, though. Fishing off your board is another thing we've got on wings.


if you've seen children of the wind (documentary) that sounds like how the "bonaire boys" got their start. They simply wanted to be able to fish further out away from shore, so the local windsurf(hire/coach?)would let them paddle/float out on a tethered windsurf board. Then he stuck a sail on for them so they could go further, etc etc. Eventually they competed at PWA level.

Paducah
2785 posts
5 Jan 2024 10:33PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Subsonic said..

Paducah said..

Back to the topic, there is a local guy who uses an umbrella to get back home after fishing on his paddle board. He is intrigued about learning to windsurf, though. Fishing off your board is another thing we've got on wings.



if you've seen children of the wind (documentary) that sounds like how the "bonaire boys" got their start. They simply wanted to be able to fish further out away from shore, so the local windsurf(hire/coach?)would let them paddle/float out on a tethered windsurf board. Then he stuck a sail on for them so they could go further, etc etc. Eventually they competed at PWA level.


Caught that about four months ago. Agree with you, worth a watch for anyone who windsurfs and even those who don't as it's a great "human interest" doc. Much respect for those kids walking miles just to get a windsurf lesson. That they became world champs was just icing on the cake.

MarkSSC
QLD, 642 posts
6 Jan 2024 9:39AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
richw said..

MarkSSC said..


airsail said..



MarkSSC said..
Is it just me or do windsurfers just look fast? The sail looks like it is built for speed, compact and colourful. The alternatives look about as sleek as a rubber balloon.





That's a common comment from windsurfers, winging definitely isn't fast, if you want fast stay on a sailboard. But if you want to ride wave/swell in not so perfect conditions, winging is a great option. And you can get going in much lighter conditions without using a huge sail.




I was just looking at it from the aesthetic perspective. All categories have their pros and cons.



Why not do both and live the Dream


The dream was to windsurf. I can die happy.

stehsegler
WA, 3542 posts
6 Jan 2024 7:46AM
Thumbs Up

I think that thinking that Windsurfing is faster than winging comes from the fact that the majority of people winging are still at the beginner stage or at least are using stable foils with lots of lift. Smaller high aspect ratio foils can easily keep up with with the average windsurfer as far as speed is concerned. It's just that not a lot of people are using them yet.

aeroegnr
1731 posts
6 Jan 2024 7:52AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
ptsf1111 said..
To be honest, after listening to Guy in below podcast my opinion about winging might have changed a bit. He has an interesting take on it and believes it's windsurfing. I don't necessarily agree but have a listen and it kinda makes sense. Unfortunately, it's no good news for our sport.

?si=4pXT_mSQh46KDIF1


That was a really good listen. It almost made me want to try winging again...

But with already having windsurf fin and foil gear it doesn't make a whole bunch of sense. The biggest benefit of winging over windfoiling to me right now would be much easier to transport. Throw a small board in the trunk with foil and the wing. But I still get way more excited about windsurfing than the thought of winging. And windsurf fin skills hep the windfoil skills and vice versa.

It's a bit more involved with windsurf boards on the roof and the car stuffed with masts, saila, and booms. But I've gotten better at reading forecasts and predicting what I'll need.
It does make me wonder what it'll be like in a few years with lots of pwa racers being dropped by sponsors. IQFoil has some legs though.

Subsonic
WA, 3354 posts
6 Jan 2024 7:59AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
stehsegler said..
I think that thinking that Windsurfing is faster than winging comes from the fact that the majority of people winging are still at the beginner stage or at least are using stable foils with lots of lift. Smaller high aspect ratio foils can easily keep up with with the average windsurfer as far as speed is concerned. It's just that not a lot of people are using them yet.



Yeah but nah. Gone up against wingers that are pushing for speed with higher aspect wings, and have the skills, and yeah they are a lot quicker, but ultimately when you are lit on some slalom kit, it's still no contest. I think the open ended kite wing is what ends up holding them back.

A lot of the ones i've spoken to say the wing just has too much flex going on to get max power out of the area.

wsurfn
97 posts
6 Jan 2024 10:30AM
Thumbs Up

I will always be a windsurfer, but reality of time and conditions, I am currently winging 85% of the time now. When Ben or Paul talk about it, Paul has never even tried it. Ben has, but I suspect there is a pretty big skills gap between his wing and windsurf skills. Both live in windy venues with flexible schedules. I initially got a slalom kit for lightwind, then just did lightwind freestyle with a big freestyle board and a light 6.3m2 S1 to improve my skills for when planing conditions came, then windfoiled with SB freeride foils and smaller sails, then finally to the wing foil. Wing foil is king in light wind compared to freeride windfoil due to foot pumping in addition to sail (wing) pumping. There is no question the wing is more fun and surfy off the wind since you can ditch the power. The only thing that is more efficient in light wind is a kite foil with a foil kite. Rather be on the wing if the wind shuts off. As I my wing skills get better, my windsurf skills have plateaued, what was only a light wind activity is competing with higher wind windsurfing. That said, when the conditions are right, I still love windsurfing the most.

aeroegnr
1731 posts
6 Jan 2024 10:50AM
Thumbs Up

I saw this video come up from a local here who gets some great footage. This is what a good day on the west coast of Florida looks like. One finner, the rest on foils (one windfoiler, at least 2 wingers). On days like this I'd usually be on fin and try to ride ways as best as I can, as I hate dealing with shorebreak and a foil.

But, all are having fun.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"wing ding craze offically over" started by musorianin