Forums > Windsurfing General

carbon booms

Reply
Created by grich62 > 9 months ago, 1 Aug 2016
grich62
QLD, 672 posts
1 Aug 2016 8:52PM
Thumbs Up

a question for the race boarders can a carbon boom be used at maximum extension ie 260 mm for a 210 to 260 boom on a 9.5 raceboard sail,i have a 230 to 290 alloy and it bends like a banana,i am trying to cut down on the amount of booms i need

Imax1
QLD, 4925 posts
1 Aug 2016 9:49PM
Thumbs Up

I'm not a racer , but I am heavy , I have found out over multiple crashes that carbon is waaaaay stronger and stiffer than alloy . I wish that I bit the bullet and gone carbon because after thrashing three economical alloy booms it would have paid for a carbon one. Less extension is better. I now have a big and small carbon boom and so far with consistent crashing have not busted one ( touch wood ) . I believe that there are extreme conditions and manufacturing oddities , but , carbon is way better than alloy.

Tardy
5262 posts
2 Aug 2016 3:52AM
Thumbs Up

Yes ,using big sails ,carbon is a big advantage .less bend means more forward thrust.
Pro limit make a alloy - carbon ..which is a little cheaper ..and very stiff .
if your using a alloy at max it's going to bend ,then cracks appear ,then it breaks .
carbon is stiff and also very strong ....start saving ,it's worth it .

John340
QLD, 3363 posts
2 Aug 2016 8:55AM
Thumbs Up

The carbon boom at its full extension will be much better than the alloy at kid extension

seanhogan
QLD, 3424 posts
2 Aug 2016 5:42PM
Thumbs Up

^like he said !

BSN101
WA, 2374 posts
2 Aug 2016 5:27PM
Thumbs Up

So no problems going out to 229 on a 180-230 enigma? EVO 8.6

Why do they generally extend 50cm? Another tail piece that gives 220-250 would be an economical option (numbers are examples)

Piv
WA, 372 posts
2 Aug 2016 8:32PM
Thumbs Up

When i bought my enigma they said no problem at max extension. I ended up getting a longer boom in case i go bigger so no first hand experience

BenKirk
NSW, 600 posts
3 Aug 2016 11:04AM
Thumbs Up

BSN101 said..
So no problems going out to 229 on a 180-230 enigma? EVO 8.6

Why do they generally extend 50cm? Another tail piece that gives 220-250 would be an economical option (numbers are examples)



These guys do exactly that. Had one of their booms back in the early 2000's http://www.mkwindsurfing.co.uk/booms_solus.php.

Brett Morris
NSW, 1204 posts
3 Aug 2016 11:50AM
Thumbs Up

Modern Carbon booms at max extension is no problem at all.
So much stiffer and stronger than Alloy.
Carbon obviously costs a lot more, but if you sail regularly and want performance, then it is worth it, as you potentially never have to replace it.


grich62
QLD, 672 posts
3 Aug 2016 12:56PM
Thumbs Up

ok you have convinced me i have ordered one today,thank for the replies.cheeres greg

petermac33
WA, 6415 posts
3 Aug 2016 1:26PM
Thumbs Up

Steve Stratfold glued my extension of my 180-226 Fibrespar carbon boom to a fixed setting of 198 cms to fit my 7m.

It saved the added weight of the clips etc.

But the biggest difference I've noticed is how much stiffer it is.

The play where the extension fits into the boom is a huge factor in boom stiffness.

Anyway,including the 200g for harness lines - the booms weighs 2.45kg

My super light carbon Maui Wave boom 170-230 including lines weighs 2.7kg which is actually 200g under spec.

Do I notice a big difference with a 250g lighter boom - carrying the rig to the water yes.

gybing - definitely

planing - not really

Tardy
5262 posts
3 Aug 2016 2:11PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
grich62 said..
ok you have convinced me i have ordered one today,thank for the replies.cheeres greg


hey grinch ,,,get a size that you will use the most .I have a 180 -240.
or 6.0 to 8.5 ..do still have a alloy but only for the small sails ,that don't get used much .boo hoo.
good thing about the carbon boom ,you don't have to wash them . ..no hidden surprises like a alloy that has been in ya
shed for 6 month ....forgot to wash it ,and hello it stuck together ...
enjoy ...you'll like it .

grich62
QLD, 672 posts
3 Aug 2016 5:10PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Tardy said..

grich62 said..
ok you have convinced me i have ordered one today,thank for the replies.cheeres greg



hey grinch ,,,get a size that you will use the most .I have a 180 -240.
or 6.0 to 8.5 ..do still have a alloy but only for the small sails ,that don't get used much .boo hoo.
good thing about the carbon boom ,you don't have to wash them . ..no hidden surprises like a alloy that has been in ya
shed for 6 month ....forgot to wash it ,and hello it stuck together ...
enjoy ...you'll like it .


i ordered a 210 to 260,that will fit my 9.5 loft and my 8.5 ezzy and just scrape in the 7.5 i use these sails the most .i dont have a problem with alloys on my smaller sails, touch wood

Tardy
5262 posts
3 Aug 2016 3:55PM
Thumbs Up

PERFECT.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"carbon booms" started by grich62