Forums > Kitesurfing Gear Reviews

SS fuel vs Naish torch

Reply
Created by ewan kite > 9 months ago, 10 Dec 2008
ewan kite
VIC, 928 posts
10 Dec 2008 5:05PM
Thumbs Up

any comment. i am about to buy some torches but am also looking at fuels. i am looking at 6m and 10m torch or 7m and 11m fuels (i weigh 53 kgs and kite in melbourne) i ride freestyle and currently am on switchblades but am looking for a c-kite for better unhooked performance and kiteloops.

thanks

ewan

BrisKites
QLD, 1292 posts
11 Dec 2008 7:22PM
Thumbs Up

These 2 kites are very different in feel so ideally you would want to try them before you make up your mind.

A few thoughts that might help though-

Size for size the Fuel seems quite a bit more powerful.

The Torch seems to handle gusty winds a bit better.

Fuel is 4 line but I found the reverse relaunch very easy.

Torch is the same 5th line system as past models.

Total de-power by releasing the bar is about the same for both (obviously not as much as a bridled kite)

Overall turning speed is similar but the Fuel waits for more bar input before it turns. This can be good to help prevent unwanted movement of the kite when passing etc.

Both bars are below the bar cleated power adjustments this year.




ewan kite
VIC, 928 posts
12 Dec 2008 10:11AM
Thumbs Up

thanks,
i tried the 9m torch in 25 knots yesterday and loved it.
looks like i am gettin a torch

ewan

juggler
VIC, 243 posts
16 Dec 2008 6:57PM
Thumbs Up

Don't do it!!!
The fuel rocks!
get yourself a 5m & a 9m and your set!!!
Man i have a 9m as my biggest and i way 70kg
thinking about a 5m or 7m as a second kite

Anyone used a 2009 5m fuel???

surfingboyo
QLD, 318 posts
16 Dec 2008 11:21PM
Thumbs Up

juggler said...

Don't do it!!!
The fuel rocks!
get yourself a 5m & a 9m and your set!!!
Man i have a 9m as my biggest and i way 70kg
thinking about a 5m or 7m as a second kite

Anyone used a 2009 5m fuel???


how is that possible. my biggest kite is an 11m REV, and that doesnt seem to be big enough.

whats the wind like in VIC. is it pretty good.

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
17 Dec 2008 12:23AM
Thumbs Up

Maybe in dreamy dream land. If you're 75 kg's you'd need a 12m in Vic. Two kite quiver is going to be a 12 and 9. No one can feed me this "My biggest kite in Vic is a 9m crap" unless they weighed 60kg's.

juggler
VIC, 243 posts
17 Dec 2008 6:32PM
Thumbs Up

Saffer said...

Maybe in dreamy dream land. If you're 75 kg's you'd need a 12m in Vic. Two kite quiver is going to be a 12 and 9. No one can feed me this "My biggest kite in Vic is a 9m crap" unless they weighed 60kg's.


Have you used a 2009 9m fuel??? lots and lots of low down power

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
17 Dec 2008 6:52PM
Thumbs Up

juggler said...

Saffer said...

Maybe in dreamy dream land. If you're 75 kg's you'd need a 12m in Vic. Two kite quiver is going to be a 12 and 9. No one can feed me this "My biggest kite in Vic is a 9m crap" unless they weighed 60kg's.


Have you used a 2009 9m fuel??? lots and lots of low down power


The basic principles of surface areas apply. Unless its mysterious taken on a Bandit shape or some other ultra flat since the last time I saw it. I did however see a rider on a 13m one in lightish wind and he looked no more powered than anyone else on the water who was riding comparatively sized 12m bows...

Now if you're coming from riding C kites (like the Naish Alliance which has less grunt than most 10m bows), I'm sure Mr "9m wonder-fuel" will have lots of low down grunt, but compared to a 12m Cabrinha SB or most other flat kites, I'm pretty sure Mr "9m wonder-fuel" is going to feel fast turning, but pretty ordinary in the power department.

juggler
VIC, 243 posts
17 Dec 2008 6:56PM
Thumbs Up

once again have you used one?

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
17 Dec 2008 7:03PM
Thumbs Up

I'll try yours on the weekend. $20 says it doesn't have more grunt than my 12m and mine is not a grunty 12.

axis
VIC, 399 posts
28 Dec 2008 12:46AM
Thumbs Up

Saffer said...

I'll try yours on the weekend. $20 says it doesn't have more grunt than my 12m and mine is not a grunty 12.


So, who got the $20-???????

C'mon!

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
28 Dec 2008 2:20PM
Thumbs Up

Haven't tried it yet, I didn't realise people were waiting. Bundi, what happened to you coming to Altona yesterday?

Charl dv
WA, 2485 posts
29 Dec 2008 12:49AM
Thumbs Up

profile depth and position in wind window greatly affects power.

i think fuels sit back in the window a bit more hence feeling of more grunt. also deeper sail profile compared to torches.

juggler
VIC, 243 posts
29 Dec 2008 11:55PM
Thumbs Up

Saffer said...

Haven't tried it yet, I didn't realise people were waiting. Bundi, what happened to you coming to Altona yesterday?


Peak hour!!!!

juggler
VIC, 243 posts
30 Dec 2008 12:01AM
Thumbs Up

Saffer said...

Maybe in dreamy dream land. If you're 75 kg's you'd need a 12m in Vic. Two kite quiver is going to be a 12 and 9. No one can feed me this "My biggest kite in Vic is a 9m crap" unless they weighed 60kg's.

I just re-read what you originally posted...
And yes still very happy with the 9m as my biggest kite, looking at maybe getting a 5m as well, funds permitting...

You don't "need" a 12m if you know what your doing

mattj
WA, 5 posts
16 Jan 2009 9:30AM
Thumbs Up

i bought a 9m fuel recently as a stronger wind alternative to my 12 Airush flow (4 line C kite). and im now going to have to sell because it's way too powerful. it has near the same power as my flow.

But i fly it on 4 lines, any comments on the 5th line ?? i have never used one.

carbine
WA, 1445 posts
16 Jan 2009 8:11PM
Thumbs Up

varies depending on year.


07 and 08 fuels vs any torch apart from 05 they are way less grunty.

09 fuel vs torch about on par eg 11 fuel vs 12 torch.

juggler
VIC, 243 posts
23 Jan 2009 6:41PM
Thumbs Up

Bit more info on the 2009 Fuel 9m
I have changed the chicken loop over to the old style as i'm finding the hole in the bar is a bit small for 3 lines so problem all fixe now
I've recently fitted 20m lines, still have good bottom end at about 18knts, and yesturday was holding it down in a good 30-35knts, Had to keep the kite down low to edge hard against it, but god damm did it boost well

Still an awesome kite, get one & you'll be hooked

extreme
VIC, 74 posts
23 Jan 2009 10:28PM
Thumbs Up

my missus has a good bottom end . i weigh 129 kilos and my biggest kite is a uncle petes toys 1m single liner that gets me going in any wind, but still pretty impresive to have a bottem end of 18 knots

ewan kite
VIC, 928 posts
24 Jan 2009 1:21PM
Thumbs Up

i have now got naish torches and after havig them for 2 weeks i love them. the 12 has a little bit better bottom end than a 11m fuel after trying them side by side. the torch performs soo well unhooked and is incredebly stable. the torch bigger sizes are nicer than the smaller ones and i find the fuel smaller sizes nicer than the bigger ones. the kites have amazing boost and hangtime especially after flying the 12m in 25 knots and me being 52 kgs. the torch has sooo much depower for a c-kite and has close to any bow/sle whereas the fuel has very little. the fuel does kiteloop very well (i have only tried the 7m fuel for kitelooping in 25-30 knots) and so does the torch but when you get the torches i find they need a bit of tuning before they are right.
i also got the thorn 128cm and it is a sick board. it has so much pop and because of the big fins is soo grippy but you can still make it have that 'skatey feel'. the tips of the board are quite flexy aswell which increases the pop. the only down side to the board is that the screws are a little bit short so you have to put loctite in the holes or else you pull the straps out every 2 sesions.

O

O

VIC, 118 posts
28 Jan 2009 3:39PM
Thumbs Up

Ewan did you demo the torches through one of the shops? If so which?



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing Gear Reviews


"SS fuel vs Naish torch" started by ewan kite