Forums > Kitesurfing Gear Reviews

2012 BWS Noise vs 2012 North Rebel

Reply
Created by Snowy > 9 months ago, 18 Jan 2012
Mask
WA, 293 posts
19 Mar 2012 5:14PM
Thumbs Up

yllek said...

really BWS??? my mate has 1 and absolutely loved it..... until he tried the rebel.
I was on EVO'S and Rebels,I liked both, the EVO had some issues with Drift and flew like **** when it had any de-power on at all,the rebel was by far the superior kite thats until i demoed the Vegas best kite I have ever ridden by far!!! I don't get in to mowing the lawn so this is all based on riding in the surf
BTW isn't the BWS is a slightly re-tweaked REV, fair enough its not as pricey as some but it's old tech
[}:)]


Ha, ha. Fifth line is tecnology that is a lot older.

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
19 Mar 2012 9:30PM
Thumbs Up

Mask said...

yllek said...

really BWS??? my mate has 1 and absolutely loved it..... until he tried the rebel.
I was on EVO'S and Rebels,I liked both, the EVO had some issues with Drift and flew like **** when it had any de-power on at all,the rebel was by far the superior kite thats until i demoed the Vegas best kite I have ever ridden by far!!! I don't get in to mowing the lawn so this is all based on riding in the surf
BTW isn't the BWS is a slightly re-tweaked REV, fair enough its not as pricey as some but it's old tech
[}:)]


Ha, ha. Fifth line is tecnology that is a lot older.


Loaded 5th is actually newer than the bridle, in fact even the old 5th line, not even when it was loaded. Bridles go back to the original Wipika which was long before the 5th even appeared and there were a couple if different iterations that came out after that with other brands.

The loaded 5th then only arrived after the original bow kite was invented. It was North's answer to the bow kite concept.

------------------
End of history lesson and my attempt to help this hit 10 pages

blueprint
WA, 321 posts
19 Mar 2012 8:05PM
Thumbs Up

Really, does this thread need to go to 10 surely 8 is MORE than enough for what has been said here.

Subculture
443 posts
19 Mar 2012 10:45PM
Thumbs Up

blueprint said...

Really, does this thread need to go to 10 surely 8 is MORE than enough for what has been said here.


Sorry mate, AFAIK, only the original creator of the thread can rename it the 'Seinfeld thread'... Maybe Laurie can help?

As bjw mentioned on page 7, like the show, it's a thread about nothing... zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

bjw
QLD, 3686 posts
20 Mar 2012 10:50AM
Thumbs Up

I haven't flown a Rebel for years but I hate the colours. I think this makes them fly badly. With lime green on a kite they never get enough high or low end.

You can fix this issue though by wearing boardshorts over your wetsuit then discussing this on a forum.

Prawnhead
NSW, 1317 posts
21 Mar 2012 5:48PM
Thumbs Up

BWS forum page sizing applies
6 really feels 8 ,8 really feels like 10 .......

just doing my bit

dave......
WA, 2119 posts
23 Mar 2012 9:21PM
Thumbs Up

I just called EPPO an " eletist cocksucker" by his own post??? Ha only dogs can do that...

dave......
WA, 2119 posts
23 Mar 2012 9:22PM
Thumbs Up

dave...... said...

I just called EPPO an " eletist cocksucker" by his own post??? Ha only dogs can do that...













Trying to add to the 9 page awesomeness

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
24 Mar 2012 2:14PM
Thumbs Up

bjw said...

I haven't flown a Rebel for years but I hate the colours. I think this makes them fly badly. With lime green on a kite they never get enough high or low end.

You can fix this issue though by wearing boardshorts over your wetsuit then discussing this on a forum.


Not quite, the Rebel has extravagant colors. It makes the kite fly extravagantly unless you're used to a kite with such a varied personality. It's a little like dating one of those arty bisexual girls that swings the ball both ways, some guys like it, others don't. Sure, they have some emotional issues, but it's exciting side of the relationship makes up for it and the sweet wouldn't be as sweet without the sour.

The Noise on the other hand has pretty boring colors. This makes it a boring flyer, but boring is good when you're focussing on waves and not the kite. They're more like the girl next door kind of kite. She's nice, but your mates are never really going to be overly impressed or jealous of you when you're riding with it. Sure, she'll never cheat on you, she'll stay at home and produce average looking babies but you'll always be staring at that hot girl in the mini dress wondering "what if".

How much longer till we hit 10 pages?

sammyd
QLD, 101 posts
24 Mar 2012 1:39PM
Thumbs Up

I got flamed by eppo because I drop my kite -

Well I did it again the other day - and it got rolled inverted and completly did a horizontal rotation

If i was on a 5th line I would have had a nice bow tie or my kite ripped in half and a swim in

but on my noise it relaunched after copping 3 waves - the rear line had one twist around the front lines but it launched and flew fine which allowed me to finish the downwinder

So can someone tell how the 5th line is better in the surf

I think they put 5 th line on there as they cant get the kite to fly properly on 4
Flame on North lovers!!!!
( this should take us to 10 )

Jedibrad
NSW, 527 posts
24 Mar 2012 3:52PM
Thumbs Up

i took out my inner trailing edge battens, well because they broke, anyway i recon the kite flew better. more pivoty and drifty

9m reb, low end gusty, strapped sb

eppo
WA, 9724 posts
24 Mar 2012 5:29PM
Thumbs Up

sammyd said...

I got flamed by eppo because I drop my kite -

Well I did it again the other day - and it got rolled inverted and completly did a horizontal rotation

If i was on a 5th line I would have had a nice bow tie or my kite ripped in half and a swim in

but on my noise it relaunched after copping 3 waves - the rear line had one twist around the front lines but it launched and flew fine which allowed me to finish the downwinder

So can someone tell how the 5th line is better in the surf

I think they put 5 th line on there as they cant get the kite to fly properly on 4
Flame on North lovers!!!!
( this should take us to 10 )






Actually I agree with you, you drop a fifth line kite in the water and it gets inverted, it is all over. Only happened to me the other day , so again your point is totally valid.
But the performance of these kites for me outweighs these this problem. What im saying is, why would you choose your kite based on the bar setup?. The fifth also allows for no pulleys...and along comes the ozone argument !

Hey tell me about the noise kites man, one of my mates wants to begin, just surfing, nothing else. Would you recommend them? I have heard some stories about build quality (from people I know) what you can you tell me?

bjw
QLD, 3686 posts
25 Mar 2012 8:11AM
Thumbs Up

I rode a fuel with a 5th line for years. Everyone would tell me how is was dangerous because if a wave would take my kite the 5th would rip it in 2.
My kite spent more time underwater than in the air, yet I never tore it in 2.

I wouldn't worry about a 5th line tearing your kite. I reckon it is just urban myth!

speed brother
QLD, 126 posts
1 Apr 2012 4:22AM
Thumbs Up

I have a rebel

speed brother
QLD, 126 posts
1 Apr 2012 4:23AM
Thumbs Up

Its a 12 m

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
1 Apr 2012 12:08PM
Thumbs Up

bjw said...

I rode a fuel with a 5th line for years. Everyone would tell me how is was dangerous because if a wave would take my kite the 5th would rip it in 2.
My kite spent more time underwater than in the air, yet I never tore it in 2.

I wouldn't worry about a 5th line tearing your kite. I reckon it is just urban myth!


In all my years of kiting, I have only ever seen a 5th line kite torn in half once, and that happened to be a slingshot many years back before bow kites were even invented. The risk of it happening is pretty low in reality. We're not talking airbags here where if you don't have them you die, there is maybe a .0001% chance of having your kite torn in half.

Damn, this 10 pages is taking ages. I'm actually having to think of things to post about now

pintofpale
SA, 229 posts
1 Apr 2012 3:30PM
Thumbs Up

Jedibrad said...

i took out my inner trailing edge battens, well because they broke, anyway i recon the kite flew better. more pivoty and drifty

9m reb, low end gusty, strapped sb


Thats interesting... are they the fibreglass battens or the flexy plastic ones... I presume you are referring to the ones closest to the wingtip on the rebel?

Jedibrad
NSW, 527 posts
6 Apr 2012 10:19PM
Thumbs Up

fiberglass inner ones

give it a go, see what you think



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing Gear Reviews


"2012 BWS Noise vs 2012 North Rebel" started by Snowy