Forums > Kitesurfing Gear Reviews

2012 BWS Noise vs 2012 North Rebel

Reply
Created by Snowy > 9 months ago, 18 Jan 2012
Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
24 Feb 2012 12:58PM
Thumbs Up

getfunky said...

Geez tuff cowd!

If I owned a Rebel I'd probably be talking and talking about it too.. they ARE that good IMO.

Most kites are hyped beyond a kn joke. Although I don't ride heaps of diff kites the Rebel is the first kite that has made me sit up and woot woot for some time.

Alas, not enough spendies in the pocket to buy a 2012 Rebel for me... yet.

Thumb away but at least Eppo isn't on the payroll and pimping a kite for $$$.

Same can't be said of some people in the previous 3-4 pages.


Thats a lie. according to most of the BWS people here, all the 2012 north rebel owners just bought crappy quality over-priced kites and now we're trying to justify to ourselves why we bought them.

What is obvious about this is that most of the BWS riders must get extra discount through red thumbs because every time someone posts anything remotely negative about BWS (even if it happens to be true), they get red thumbed more than someone who parks in the handicapped zone.

blueprint
WA, 321 posts
24 Feb 2012 12:22PM
Thumbs Up

Saffer said...

getfunky said...

Geez tuff cowd!

If I owned a Rebel I'd probably be talking and talking about it too.. they ARE that good IMO.

Most kites are hyped beyond a kn joke. Although I don't ride heaps of diff kites the Rebel is the first kite that has made me sit up and woot woot for some time.

Alas, not enough spendies in the pocket to buy a 2012 Rebel for me... yet.

Thumb away but at least Eppo isn't on the payroll and pimping a kite for $$$.

Same can't be said of some people in the previous 3-4 pages.


Thats a lie. according to most of the BWS people here, all the 2012 north rebel owners just bought crappy quality over-priced kites and now we're trying to justify to ourselves why we bought them.

What is obvious about this is that most of the BWS riders must get extra discount through red thumbs because every time someone posts anything remotely negative about BWS (even if it happens to be true), they get red thumbed more than someone who parks in the handicapped zone.


Maybe that's because the Rebel owners are trying to beat the BWS guys into admitting that they bought cheap, poor quality, poor performing kites.....also not true (I assume as I haven't flown one) as they certainly seem happy.

Seriously...............5 pages of drivel interspersed with a handful of useful posts from people who have actually flown both.

Each to their own...

Mask
WA, 293 posts
24 Feb 2012 12:50PM
Thumbs Up

Saffer said...

getfunky said...

Geez tuff cowd!

If I owned a Rebel I'd probably be talking and talking about it too.. they ARE that good IMO.

Most kites are hyped beyond a kn joke. Although I don't ride heaps of diff kites the Rebel is the first kite that has made me sit up and woot woot for some time.

Alas, not enough spendies in the pocket to buy a 2012 Rebel for me... yet.

Thumb away but at least Eppo isn't on the payroll and pimping a kite for $$$.

Same can't be said of some people in the previous 3-4 pages.


Thats a lie. according to most of the BWS people here, all the 2012 north rebel owners just bought crappy quality over-priced kites and now we're trying to justify to ourselves why we bought them.



Isnt that the truth though?
Why would you spend a fortune on kite that has so many problems with its bar and line system.(see other thread/s re north bar and lines.) No one said they are crap kites though, just expensive. Pity BWS dont make a 5 line bar set up, then you guys could use that with your North Rebels and wont have any problems.

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
24 Feb 2012 4:01PM
Thumbs Up

Mask said...

Saffer said...

getfunky said...

Geez tuff cowd!

If I owned a Rebel I'd probably be talking and talking about it too.. they ARE that good IMO.

Most kites are hyped beyond a kn joke. Although I don't ride heaps of diff kites the Rebel is the first kite that has made me sit up and woot woot for some time.

Alas, not enough spendies in the pocket to buy a 2012 Rebel for me... yet.

Thumb away but at least Eppo isn't on the payroll and pimping a kite for $$$.

Same can't be said of some people in the previous 3-4 pages.


Thats a lie. according to most of the BWS people here, all the 2012 north rebel owners just bought crappy quality over-priced kites and now we're trying to justify to ourselves why we bought them.



Isnt that the truth though?
Why would you spend a fortune on kite that has so many problems with its bar and line system.(see other thread/s re north bar and lines.) No one said they are crap kites though, just expensive. Pity BWS dont make a 5 line bar set up, then you guys could use that with your North Rebels and wont have any problems.




The thing you forget about is because North actually sells so many kites, the failure rates actually appear on this forum. BWS probably only sell 10 kites a year in Aus (mostly to their team riders) so even at a 1% failure rate, its unlikely you'll see any issues here.

Same reason you see so many Cabs in trees. Its a numbers game.

eppo
WA, 9731 posts
24 Feb 2012 1:57PM
Thumbs Up

someawe said...

^^^ dude look how many red thumbs your getting! You must be spewing, so now your puking too!! Oh that's my contribution to light entertainment






Well i Intend to get entertained by riding one of the kites this thread is about. Your offering of light entertainment is peculiar and remarkably stupid. Get riding, then comment on your observations, I'm starting to think we need another forum that culls such ignorance and keep it focussed on what this forum was originally about. Cheap laughs, you must be a very strange little man. Ridden a rebel or a bws, what was your technical oberservations? Or is this another opportunity for your strange attempt at humor?

eppo
WA, 9731 posts
24 Feb 2012 2:01PM
Thumbs Up

Mask said...

Saffer said...

getfunky said...

Geez tuff cowd!

If I owned a Rebel I'd probably be talking and talking about it too.. they ARE that good IMO.

Most kites are hyped beyond a kn joke. Although I don't ride heaps of diff kites the Rebel is the first kite that has made me sit up and woot woot for some time.

Alas, not enough spendies in the pocket to buy a 2012 Rebel for me... yet.

Thumb away but at least Eppo isn't on the payroll and pimping a kite for $$$.

Same can't be said of some people in the previous 3-4 pages.


Thats a lie. according to most of the BWS people here, all the 2012 north rebel owners just bought crappy quality over-priced kites and now we're trying to justify to ourselves why we bought them.



Isnt that the truth though?
Why would you spend a fortune on kite that has so many problems with its bar and line system.(see other thread/s re north bar and lines.) No one said they are crap kites though, just expensive. Pity BWS dont make a 5 line bar set up, then you guys could use that with your North Rebels and wont have any problems.








Yeh mask you may have a point about the bars although I haven't had any trouble myself. There are better bars out there. But you don't buy a kite on how good it's bar is? The performance of the kite is surely what matters. I also agree they are expensive. I'm willing to pay though for performance, but yes you would think with the economies of scale driven by increasing sales would have lowered the price by now. But maybe the technological innovations and quality of material used has negated this. Who knows.

Mask
WA, 293 posts
24 Feb 2012 2:37PM
Thumbs Up

eppo said...

Mask said...

Saffer said...

getfunky said...

Geez tuff cowd!

If I owned a Rebel I'd probably be talking and talking about it too.. they ARE that good IMO.

Most kites are hyped beyond a kn joke. Although I don't ride heaps of diff kites the Rebel is the first kite that has made me sit up and woot woot for some time.

Alas, not enough spendies in the pocket to buy a 2012 Rebel for me... yet.

Thumb away but at least Eppo isn't on the payroll and pimping a kite for $$$.

Same can't be said of some people in the previous 3-4 pages.


Thats a lie. according to most of the BWS people here, all the 2012 north rebel owners just bought crappy quality over-priced kites and now we're trying to justify to ourselves why we bought them.



Isnt that the truth though?
Why would you spend a fortune on kite that has so many problems with its bar and line system.(see other thread/s re north bar and lines.) No one said they are crap kites though, just expensive. Pity BWS dont make a 5 line bar set up, then you guys could use that with your North Rebels and wont have any problems.








Yeh mask you may have a point about the bars although I haven't had any trouble myself. There are better bars out there. But you don't buy a kite on how good it's bar is? The performance of the kite is surely what matters. I also agree they are expensive. I'm willing to pay though for performance, but yes you would think with the economies of scale driven by increasing sales would have lowered the price by now. But maybe the technological innovations and quality of material used has negated this. Who knows.


Their prices will come down in the next yr or two. They will have to as there is more and more competition from good quality cheaper kites.
Who knows, maybe my next kite will be a Rebel?

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
24 Feb 2012 6:13PM
Thumbs Up

Mask said...

Their prices will come down in the next yr or two. They will have to as there is more and more competition from good quality cheaper kites.
Who knows, maybe my next kite will be a Rebel?


I beg to differ. Pricing has come down over the years, but only by a limited amount which is largely attributed to the growth of the sport and the changes to the manufacturing processes.

BWS is certainly not the first cheap kite on the market and they aren't the first to go direct. Best started this years ago, and even though Best is one of the bigger brands these days, the market pricing hasn't dropped a whole heap as a result. Best have subsequently increased their prices compared to the early days. People keep saying brands like Switch are going to change things, but there have been heaps of cheaper brands around for ages and they haven't changed things. I know some of these brands are getting far more penetration in the US market with the recession, but in Vic, I've seen heaps of new premium brands on the beaches include Slingshots, North's, Cabrinha's, Naish's etc and not a whole heap of low end brands.

I think part of the problem is these cheaper brands tend to compete head on with last's year's new kites and the resale on established brands is better or kiters tend to go with brands they know.

I'm not a North lackey by any standards. I was flying Fluid (cheaper brand) last year, Slingshot the year before, Takoon the year before that, Takoon and Naish before that, Cabrinha etc. The rest of my gear has been a mix of Naish, Liquid Force, North, Dakine etc. I tend to replace my kites every year and I buy what I like at that point. I personally don't have an issue with the north bar. I actually really like it. The 5th line only starts 3/4 of the way up so people who say the extra line is more effort obviously haven't look at it too carefully.

Mask
WA, 293 posts
24 Feb 2012 3:47PM
Thumbs Up

Whatever.
You beg to differ with everything.
Your just a big begtodifferer.

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
24 Feb 2012 6:57PM
Thumbs Up

Mask said...

Whatever.
You beg to differ with everything.
Your just a big begtodifferer.


It was a nice way of saying you're wrong, I'm right

eppo
WA, 9731 posts
24 Feb 2012 4:56PM
Thumbs Up

Yeh agree with you saffer. The increase in best prices over the years has confirmed this. As they produced a better quality kite so did their manufacturing costs, hence the increase in prices. In the early days we were paying as much as we do now, so prices in relative terms have probably dropped indexed to inflation.

But we still shouldn't blanket the whole argument with saying that cheaper kite brands are not as good for the user as more expensive kites. For instance back in 2007 to 2009 I rode best waroos and they suited where I was at and Did the job really well. Infact my bro still uses an old 2009 waroo and again it does the job.

But then I went on a mission as my skill level increased where the finer points of a kites performance became necessary and more noticeable. From kahoonas to cores to a large number of demos in several type and brands. The rebel suited my style and my need to capitalize on what a quality kite can offer. It was a huge relief to be content on a kite.

But I would not say that the cheaper brands such as bws should not be considered, for beginners and advanced crew. It depends on the rider.

But if we go right back to the start of this thread, the rebel and bws are completely different concepts, suited for different riders.

So contrary to some comments made I am by no means one eyed nor do I subscribe to others knocking the bws concept.

With regard to the bar, one good thing not mentioned yet about the fifth line is that the tension on the fifth line gives you a direct indication your lines need tuning. It is amazing to feel the difference when a set of lines have been retuned. Line stretching was not as obvious on the four line kites before hence I very rarely tuned them. Wish I had now. Makes a big diff.

inside grunt
WA, 72 posts
24 Feb 2012 6:45PM
Thumbs Up

eppo said...

Agreed, last post on this. Each to their own. Was an interesting discussion though, but yes, time to let this one go.


From pg 3!

winter
VIC, 155 posts
24 Feb 2012 10:36PM
Thumbs Up

But how else will saffer get to 2500 posts we can't stop now!

stoff
WA, 248 posts
24 Feb 2012 8:18PM
Thumbs Up

eppo said...



With regard to the bar, one good thing not mentioned yet about the fifth line is that the tension on the fifth line gives you a direct indication your lines need tuning. It is amazing to feel the difference when a set of lines have been retuned. Line stretching was not as obvious on the four line kites before hence I very rarely tuned them. Wish I had now. Makes a big diff.


Many lols, you didn't retune you four line kites because you don't need to!

the walks
WA, 448 posts
24 Feb 2012 9:29PM
Thumbs Up

o.k, enough of the tit 4 tat, can anyone confirm that Ben is now fly'in the REO

dave......
WA, 2119 posts
24 Feb 2012 10:10PM
Thumbs Up

^^^ I can confirm that Ben is testing a a low aspect bridled C-kite prototype. Its the best kite Ive ever ridden, but I havent ridden it yet.
5 pages...WOW.

eppo
WA, 9731 posts
24 Feb 2012 10:16PM
Thumbs Up

inside grunt said...

eppo said...

Agreed, last post on this. Each to their own. Was an interesting discussion though, but yes, time to let this one go.


From pg 3!




Yes lol.

eppo
WA, 9731 posts
24 Feb 2012 10:17PM
Thumbs Up

stoff said...

eppo said...



With regard to the bar, one good thing not mentioned yet about the fifth line is that the tension on the fifth line gives you a direct indication your lines need tuning. It is amazing to feel the difference when a set of lines have been retuned. Line stretching was not as obvious on the four line kites before hence I very rarely tuned them. Wish I had now. Makes a big diff.


Many lols, you didn't retune you four line kites because you don't need to!





Lines stretch. Where do we find these guy???

eppo
WA, 9731 posts
24 Feb 2012 10:18PM
Thumbs Up

eppo said...

stoff said...

eppo said...



With regard to the bar, one good thing not mentioned yet about the fifth line is that the tension on the fifth line gives you a direct indication your lines need tuning. It is amazing to feel the difference when a set of lines have been retuned. Line stretching was not as obvious on the four line kites before hence I very rarely tuned them. Wish I had now. Makes a big diff.


Many lols, you didn't retune you four line kites because you don't need to!





Lines stretch. Where do we find these guys?


stoff
WA, 248 posts
24 Feb 2012 10:41PM
Thumbs Up

Pull on more depower yo! All tuned up like a boss!

toppleover
QLD, 2067 posts
25 Feb 2012 12:46AM
Thumbs Up

eppo said...

eppo said...

stoff said...

eppo said...



With regard to the bar, one good thing not mentioned yet about the fifth line is that the tension on the fifth line gives you a direct indication your lines need tuning. It is amazing to feel the difference when a set of lines have been retuned. Line stretching was not as obvious on the four line kites before hence I very rarely tuned them. Wish I had now. Makes a big diff.


Many lols, you didn't retune you four line kites because you don't need to!





Lines stretch. Where do we find these guys?





Here endeth the lesson

Berg K1t3r
QLD, 106 posts
25 Feb 2012 12:25PM
Thumbs Up

Have only had the dissappointment of riding a BWS....
'MY' opinion....
- No additional settings on the bar or the kite ,
- slowest turning kite i have ever ridden, based on the 12mtr BWS i have ridden, ive ridden a 14 catalyst, bandit, rpm, that will turn faster than a BWS 12mtr,
- Put it next to a Slingshot rev 2 the same size and u will be looking for the rev for a week. even though they are the exact same kite, a 12 is actually a 14, , except the BWS has more bridles
- Very poor build quality (you get what u pay for i guess), had a mate get 3 replacements within 6-8 weeks of purchase. chicken loop and donkey are rubbish when your trying to trim the kite they just pop out, because trim line gets stuck in the cleat everytime.

+ low bar pressure for riding unhooked is nice. maybe a little bit to light. Would be nice to be able to adjust the bar pressure as desired

+ Black is by far the best kite colour, no stain.

Cant say i have ridden a rebel, but the rebel has been a reputable north kite for yrs which has been improved and improved over the yrs, so i dont think you could really compare the two.
Rant over!
Call me a Hater, Call me what u like. Once again this only 'my' opinion,
others might like some of the things i dislike

eppo
WA, 9731 posts
25 Feb 2012 1:46PM
Thumbs Up

Ah thank god, a decent post from someone who has purchased and ridden one of the bloody kites mentioned. You have contributed to the knowledge base albeit always an opinion. Thank you again. Yeh I really liked the bws unhooked, it is designed for this and hence beats the rebel in this regard. I rarely unhook on the rebel, if I do it is adequate and useable but the the rides I've had on the bws are better for this, Infanct I preferred it unhooked. Agreed on the slowness but when you are hurtling down a 6 foot indo wave, barreling and spitting behind you, you want a steady slow kite. In Perth, well enough said.

Mask
WA, 293 posts
25 Feb 2012 9:21PM
Thumbs Up

Berg K1t3r said...

Have only had the dissappointment of riding a BWS....
'MY' opinion....
- No additional settings on the bar or the kite ,
- slowest turning kite i have ever ridden, based on the 12mtr BWS i have ridden, ive ridden a 14 catalyst, bandit, rpm, that will turn faster than a BWS 12mtr,
- Put it next to a Slingshot rev 2 the same size and u will be looking for the rev for a week. even though they are the exact same kite, a 12 is actually a 14, , except the BWS has more bridles
- Very poor build quality (you get what u pay for i guess), had a mate get 3 replacements within 6-8 weeks of purchase. chicken loop and donkey are rubbish when your trying to trim the kite they just pop out, because trim line gets stuck in the cleat everytime.

+ low bar pressure for riding unhooked is nice. maybe a little bit to light. Would be nice to be able to adjust the bar pressure as desired

+ Black is by far the best kite colour, no stain.

Cant say i have ridden a rebel, but the rebel has been a reputable north kite for yrs which has been improved and improved over the yrs, so i dont think you could really compare the two.
Rant over!
Call me a Hater, Call me what u like. Once again this only 'my' opinion,
others might like some of the things i dislike



Good thing you havent tried the Rebel bar and lines yet!

strin
2 posts
26 Feb 2012 7:44AM
Thumbs Up

North has the best bar in the industry.

woodys
WA, 218 posts
26 Feb 2012 10:02AM
Thumbs Up

dave...... said...

5 pages...WOW.



to tell kiters that you cant compare apples to oranges
just as well kiting only requires physical skills


@ strin > try adding "IMO". Some pl may like other ones.
Like the guy we had in the other day wanting a different brand bar to match to his North kite.
We are all individuals. Thank the good lord for that.

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
26 Feb 2012 4:25PM
Thumbs Up

woodys said...

dave...... said...

5 pages...WOW.



to tell kiters that you cant compare apples to oranges
just as well kiting only requires physical skills


@ strin > try adding "IMO". Some pl may like other ones.
Like the guy we had in the other day wanting a different brand bar to match to his North kite.
We are all individuals. Thank the good lord for that.


As a retailer you really should know better than to slag off brands you don't stock.

poor relative
WA, 9105 posts
26 Feb 2012 1:43PM
Thumbs Up

woodys
WA, 218 posts
26 Feb 2012 3:36PM
Thumbs Up

Saffer said...

As a retailer you really should know better than to slag off brands you don't stock.


No slagging Saffer. IMO the North bar is right up there with the best of them. Im sure any inspection by any kiter would have them come to the same conclusion.
Just making the point that an opinion is just that. Not everyone is going to agree.

Dan Fletcher
NSW, 114 posts
26 Feb 2012 10:35PM
Thumbs Up

North: bar is good, lines are rubbish



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing Gear Reviews


"2012 BWS Noise vs 2012 North Rebel" started by Snowy