Forums > Kitesurfing General

Wind strength yesterday at Pinnaroo?

Reply
Created by oceanfire > 9 months ago, 27 Jan 2011
oceanfire
WA, 718 posts
27 Jan 2011 11:13AM
Thumbs Up

Does anyone know how many knots were blowing at Pinnaroo yesterday between 4 & 6pm?

I had my 11m out, was fully depowered via the trim strap but it still had heaps of grunt.
In fact the wind seemed to be picking up a tad too much getting closer to 6pm so I called it a day early.
Needless to say, it was lots of fun!

Just trying to increase my learnins about the wind range I can take my kite out in.

Charl dv
WA, 2485 posts
27 Jan 2011 11:20AM
Thumbs Up

go look at the graphs, there is a section that shows previous days' wind speeds

oceanfire
WA, 718 posts
27 Jan 2011 11:38AM
Thumbs Up

Cheers for that , though the graphs only show for Oceanreef up that way, which is a good guide, but it felt a lot stronger than the graph shows; I was hoping someone who was out yesterday arvo at Pinnaroo would have a better idea of the wind speed at ground zero, so to speak.

RPM
WA, 1549 posts
27 Jan 2011 12:00PM
Thumbs Up



Correct answer is 23 knots with guts to 25/26

That's the top end for your 11m. (less if it's an aids bucket cabrinha) When your fully depowered and staning on the shoreline on your tippy toes then maybe it's time to drop a kite size or sit the rest out.

oceanfire
WA, 718 posts
27 Jan 2011 12:12PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks for that, I think I have to get my wind sense more developed; it seemed a lot stronger than that.
And yeah, I did sit the rest out earlier than I wanted to, commonsense always prevails.

I've got an 11m 2010 Waroo, it's meant to be good for up to 28knots, but that's for a 75kg rider; I'm 90kg- I figure I should be good for 30knots at least on this kite.

Wasn't on tippy-toes standing on the beach, but the gusts were feeling pretty strong.
I was checking the graphs after I went out & I'm pretty sure Ocean Reef was showing 28knots between 5:30 & 6pm.

I've only got the one kite, would love to have had a 9m yesterday.

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
27 Jan 2011 12:14PM
Thumbs Up

Was punchy breeze yesterday around Swanny-Scarbs. Certainly enough to get going on my 7m and stronger by far than the swanny graph shows.

Ocean reef graphs looked about right for what I felt further south.



OceanAddicts
QLD, 357 posts
Site Sponsor
27 Jan 2011 2:30PM
Thumbs Up

I've got an 11m 2010 Waroo, it's meant to be good for up to 28knots, but that's for a 75kg rider; I'm 90kg- I figure I should be good for 30knots at least on this kite.


Thats nonsense.

At 30 knots you should be on an 8 or 9 at the biggest.

The biggest mistake made these days on '100% depower' kites is guys overestimating the wind that their kite can handle.

At 30 knots you would be overpowered and uncomfortable on an 11m

little o
WA, 405 posts
27 Jan 2011 12:44PM
Thumbs Up

check out a search for "beaufort scale" it tells you what to look for on the ocean and around you to guesstimate the wind speed.

I generally use the sand. If you spend enough time at the beach and ask people around you what they think you can hone your skills. Proud to say I've predicted a wind speed while a guy held up his wind meter and I guessed the same as him. (But I've only tried it once)

oceanfire
WA, 718 posts
27 Jan 2011 12:45PM
Thumbs Up

OceanAddicts said...

I've got an 11m 2010 Waroo, it's meant to be good for up to 28knots, but that's for a 75kg rider; I'm 90kg- I figure I should be good for 30knots at least on this kite.


Thats nonsense.

At 30 knots you should be on an 8 or 9 at the biggest.

The biggest mistake made these days on '100% depower' kites is guys overestimating the wind that their kite can handle.

At 30 knots you would be overpowered and uncomfortable on an 11m


Thanks for the input, but, chill dude , as I said in my first post, I'm just trying to increase my knowledge.
Which is why I'm asking about the wind speed yesterday, I was certainly very powered up, but not that uncomfortable; however, I do have common sense & did sit it out early due to the conditions and my kite size.

Aren't we meant to either ad or subtract a kite's wind range according to the rider's weight?

Just trying to get a feel for real conditions and how they relate to the specified wind range of my kite as well as my ability or lack there of, as a guide for next time I go out.
I'm pretty analytical & like to equip myself with as much knowledge as I can.

sebol
WA, 753 posts
27 Jan 2011 12:55PM
Thumbs Up

Why would you want to kite at the max range for your kite?????
Unless if you have only one kite, smaller kite = more fun.
Always go for the small one and if the wind drop,it fine tune your flying skills and practices your kite loops

oceanfire
WA, 718 posts
27 Jan 2011 12:57PM
Thumbs Up

little o said...

check out a search for "beaufort scale" it tells you what to look for on the ocean and around you to guesstimate the wind speed.

I generally use the sand. If you spend enough time at the beach and ask people around you what they think you can hone your skills. Proud to say I've predicted a wind speed while a guy held up his wind meter and I guessed the same as him. (But I've only tried it once)


I'm familiar with the beaufort scale, but certainly need to study it a lot more; spose I better pull my finger out and do it.


graceful
WA, 773 posts
27 Jan 2011 1:00PM
Thumbs Up

Hey mate
I weigh in at 110 kg and go from my 10 to my 8 anything over 22 knots and have plenty of power on my 6 around 30... Could even go smaller... Never flown your kite but you'll have slot more fun on smaller kites

RPM
WA, 1549 posts
27 Jan 2011 1:00PM
Thumbs Up

little o said...

check out a search for "beaufort scale" it tells you what to look for on the ocean and around you to guesstimate the wind speed.

I generally use the sand. If you spend enough time at the beach and ask people around you what they think you can hone your skills. Proud to say I've predicted a wind speed while a guy held up his wind meter and I guessed the same as him. (But I've only tried it once)


right on 20kts the sand starts top lift of the beach. So taking that into account buy a windmeter of ebay if your not sure.

That way you won't need to ask anymore or open yourselves up to getting sledged. I wouldn't be using an 11m in more than 25. Turning speed sucks and it's more fun on an 8 or 9m.

oceanfire
WA, 718 posts
27 Jan 2011 1:10PM
Thumbs Up

sebol said...

Why would you want to kite at the max range for your kite?????
Unless if you have only one kite, smaller kite = more fun.
Always go for the small one and if the wind drop,it fine tune your flying skills and practices your kite loops


Didn't say I wanted to, but I've only got the one kite & the limited times I've been out I haven't been close to being overpowered.

You know how it is, when the wind's a blowin', I'm a goin', as long as I feel safe to do so.
I don't over estimate my abilities, if I feel it's too much, I'll happily sit on the beach and cry until I've saved up enough for my next smaller kite to ad to my quiver.

oceanfire
WA, 718 posts
27 Jan 2011 1:23PM
Thumbs Up

If people want to sledge someone for asking questions instead of carrying on in blissful ignorance, that's cool with me; sucks to be them.

Not saying it should be done all the time, but surely there must be some value in learning how to handle a kite in overpowered conditions?

markonz
VIC, 68 posts
27 Jan 2011 4:56PM
Thumbs Up

Geez man, no-one is having a go at you, chill out and listen to the advice. Just because they say the kite will handle up to 27 knots doesnt exactly mean its safe to do so!! We just had a guy die in my hometown on xmas eve from being too powered up and when a decent gust came he was carried away into some trees!!

iti
QLD, 417 posts
27 Jan 2011 4:01PM
Thumbs Up

is ocean fire = rsc

NickT
WA, 1094 posts
27 Jan 2011 2:06PM
Thumbs Up

I am around 90 myself and my 11m is good for up to 26-27 kts but its just not fun in that sort of wind. Basically I try to not use the trim strap at all and edge out the gusts. Once I feel I am at the point where I need to start trimming it's time for the 8m.

AKSonline
WA, 925 posts
Site Sponsor
27 Jan 2011 2:12PM
Thumbs Up

Hi Oceanfire,

I hit the water yesterday at Pinnaroo at about 6pm on the green 9m Ozone Edge.

The wind wasn't that strong. I reckon it was about 22 knots maybe gusting to ~25 max. It was nowhere near 28 or 30 knots.

There was very little sand blowing along the beach although all the footprints were gone an hour later so it was windy, just not as windy as everyone thinks. Most people over estimate the wind strength IMHO.

You would have been powered about how you described on your Waroo in the conditions I felt. Don't fly your kite in more than about 25 knots, that's max on the kite you were on, despite what the website says. It will be more fun on a smaller kite and you'll be safer.

There is a difference in holding onto a maxxed out big kite when everything is all going well, it's when things go wrong that the risk is massively amplified to the point of possible fatality, so maybe be a little careful about flying so powered up, especially considering your experience.

Cheers,

DM

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
27 Jan 2011 2:26PM
Thumbs Up

AKSonline said...

Hi Oceanfire,

The wind wasn't that strong. I reckon it was about 22 knots maybe gusting to ~25 max. It was nowhere near 28 or 30 knots.



+1... I was on my medium sized sail and wasn't fully powered. 20 knots gusting to 25 maybe when i went out (3-5pm).

No way I'd put up an 11m though!

27 Jan 2011 5:58PM
Thumbs Up

oceanfire said...

Does anyone know how many knots were blowing at Pinnaroo yesterday between 4 & 6pm?

I had my 11m out, was fully depowered via the trim strap but it still had heaps of grunt.
In fact the wind seemed to be picking up a tad too much getting closer to 6pm so I called it a day early.
Needless to say, it was lots of fun!

Just trying to increase my learnins about the wind range I can take my kite out in.



The trim strap does not make a kite smaller, it does not depower it, despite what everyone seems to think!
The trim strap TRIMS the front lines, as in shortens them, thats all it does. This does not tip the kite forward, etc, as some kiters seem to think.
When you shorten the front lines, by pulling in on the trim strap or cleat, you effectively make the rear lines longer, which allows you to keep riding without going into "poo stance", thats all the trim system does.
A side effect of trimming is reduced angle of attack movement of the canopy, and a further side effect of this is that steering control is decreased and thats why its dangerous to fly kites "fully trimmed" or using the wack word of the century, fully "depowered".

SO - if you are at the limit of the trimmer on a 11M kite, even at 90kg's, thats a sign that you should be on a smaller kite, and that you would have heaps more fun, boost bigger, stay on your line easy if wave riding, etc.

oceanfire
WA, 718 posts
27 Jan 2011 4:37PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks everyone for the great advice, much appreciated.

Yes, I flew an 11m yesterday, I didn't feel uncomfortable on it or out of control, but I did realise I was very powered up and hence I did not fly it for very long, I packed up before it became uncomfortable for me as I knew that if I wasn't careful things can always get out of hand in those conditions with the size kite I have; safety is always my first priority.

I won't say who I had my lessons through as they may not like it that I was compared to rsc (man, that was below the belt iti )
However, I had my lessons with a very reputable school, safety was always stressed, always, and I have taken that away with me.

As I have said, I am trying to develop my knowledge & hence skills so I can participate in this awesome sport in a safe & controlled manner, which is why I asked the question about the wind speed yesterday, so I could compare and evaluate my experience from that session with the knowledge of other more experienced kiters.

Part of my question about the wind speed related to the fact that I was out on Monday arvo & there seemed to be more sand flying about than yesterday, and I was flying fully powered up on Monday quite comfortably.

It was mentioned that asking questions could open you up to sledging; I don't believe anyone was having a go at me, my comment about sledgers was purely based on the fact that if someone is asking questions, they are showing that they want to learn.
I hope it hasn't come across that I haven't been listening to the advice, because I have, very seriously.
If you don't ask questions, you don't learn.

I appreciate everyone who has taken the time to respond to this thread, I've taken everything onboard that's been said.

And it's great that I've recieved advice that I didn't expect, but is valuable stuff to know.

Thanks guys & good winds to you all!

Bigwavedave
QLD, 2057 posts
27 Jan 2011 8:18PM
Thumbs Up

OceanAddicts said...

I've got an 11m 2010 Waroo, it's meant to be good for up to 28knots, but that's for a 75kg rider; I'm 90kg- I figure I should be good for 30knots at least on this kite.


Thats nonsense.

At 30 knots you should be on an 8 or 9 at the biggest.

The biggest mistake made these days on '100% depower' kites is guys overestimating the wind that their kite can handle.

At 30 knots you would be overpowered and uncomfortable on an 11m


oops!

That was me using OA computer. Those are my views and not necessarily those of Ocean Addicts!!!

Still silly to take an 11m out in 30 knots.

Best to see what others are riding and opt for a 7, 8 or 9.

Testing the limit of your kite is not smart. Mistakes and injuries at 30 knots are amplified by inexperience.

However, it's all about what you feel comfortable on. Just be safe!!

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
27 Jan 2011 6:41PM
Thumbs Up

Agree with Darren about overestimating the actual wind speed. I'm sure i still do it

IMO when you are learning everything over 20kts feels like 25kts and everything over 24kts feels like 30kts. No pizz taking.

I know there has been all sorts of discussions on wind strength and density in the past, (summarising winter thicker wind has more power for same speed than summer due to air density)but some days - like yesterday - the wind just feels thicker and punchier for the actual speed shown on the graphs.

Like totals whatevs - yesterday rocked.

Hey OF, save up for an 7/8m - you may not need it a hell of a lot, so go 2nd hand and you won't have to spend heaps of $$$ but it sure is nicer (and safer) to be out on the right sized kite when it's cranking.

TurtleHunter
WA, 1675 posts
27 Jan 2011 7:08PM
Thumbs Up

It's not your lack of skill holding on to a powered kite it's the over estimate of the wind range of the kite. It doesn't pay to advertise a kite with an underestimated wind range. Learn what you like riding in and don't listen to the hype.
what do you do when your on red alert

Chris6791
WA, 3271 posts
27 Jan 2011 7:12PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
[quotewhat do you do when your on red alert



tie some string to a shopping bag and head of to the beach for a kite

Bo
WA, 192 posts
27 Jan 2011 7:36PM
Thumbs Up

You can normally take off around 4 knots from the Seabreeze graph because the meter is high up on the dune at Ocean Reef boat harbour and Pinna's is a bit sheltered by the marina.

As far as kite choice is concerned, was on a 7.5 Kahoona and perfectly well powerd. If I had to choose a Waroo size it would be a 9, it would not have been much fun on an 11. Then again if you only have an 11 then you have no choice ....the numbers on the Best website are max values.

Charl dv
WA, 2485 posts
27 Jan 2011 8:28PM
Thumbs Up

oceanfire said...

Thanks for that, I think I have to get my wind sense more developed; it seemed a lot stronger than that.
And yeah, I did sit the rest out earlier than I wanted to, commonsense always prevails.

I've got an 11m 2010 Waroo, it's meant to be good for up to 28knots, but that's for a 75kg rider; I'm 90kg- I figure I should be good for 30knots at least on this kite.

Wasn't on tippy-toes standing on the beach, but the gusts were feeling pretty strong.
I was checking the graphs after I went out & I'm pretty sure Ocean Reef was showing 28knots between 5:30 & 6pm.

I've only got the one kite, would love to have had a 9m yesterday.



i cant be bothered reading the entire thread so i duno if someone already answered.

but WA wind has a lot more punch to it per knot that other places. e.g i can still ride a 13 in 18 -20 in Brisbane but like hell i would be doing as well over here in the same strength. colder wind = denser air = more power. oh and our wind is rediculously consistant and doesn't gust and lull as much as other places.

you'd be doing well holding an 11 in a consistent 25 +

dave......
WA, 2119 posts
27 Jan 2011 10:12PM
Thumbs Up

Yesterday, was a blast, It was windier at 2-5pm than any part of the day at woodmans point. 11m is overkill, I went out on an 8m and was fully lit, I could have had fun on my grunty 5m on a twin-tip. If something goes wrong at those windspeeds, you still have 11meters squared of sail in the air! Small kites above 25 knots are way more fun.

rongroen
WA, 74 posts
27 Jan 2011 11:30PM
Thumbs Up

I also have the advantage of a 1 kite quiver, that I don't agonize over which kite to take :-)
I fly an 11, and at 86kg find it suitable for most days. I did not think that yesterday was too strong, although I was at Quinns and out by 3.30

I would suggest a demo on a much smaller kite, 7 or 8, both in moderate and heavier conditions to appreciate the value of a second kite and the difference in handling.

Well done for asking the question, and thinking about the safety of the conditions.

little o
WA, 405 posts
27 Jan 2011 11:39PM
Thumbs Up

hmmm you guys should try riding a 5....it turns when i blink. But it's the only way i can even think about 30 knots



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing General


"Wind strength yesterday at Pinnaroo?" started by oceanfire