Forums > Kitesurfing General

Who's right is it to ban people to kite?

Reply
Created by poonarny > 9 months ago, 26 Dec 2011
poonarny
WA, 2 posts
26 Dec 2011 12:38AM
Thumbs Up

i've been living in safety bay all my life now and just started kitesurfing this time last year the pond has been my second home but i've noticed since then people are getting more aggresive towards who should be in the pond and should'nt. not mentioning any names but one person has been getting around lately, letting kites down and resorted to cutting lines of people that have tryed to lern in the pond also threataning to "ban" them for the future... later that arvo this person was teaching a friend right in the middle... who has the right to do this...

Underoath
QLD, 2433 posts
26 Dec 2011 4:12AM
Thumbs Up

I'm not learning but if I witnessed anyone cutting someone's lines id stab them with their scissors.

How pathetic.

Plummet
4862 posts
26 Dec 2011 8:24AM
Thumbs Up


Why not name and same them? a cock like that deserves abit of karma.

surfingboye
NSW, 2707 posts
26 Dec 2011 11:35AM
Thumbs Up

I felt like stabbing that dudes leading edge of his trainer kite at Maroochy yesterday. Seriously, did the dude have a brain? Anyone else see him?

Edgeguts
WA, 69 posts
26 Dec 2011 9:28AM
Thumbs Up

Underoath said...

I'm not learning but if I witnessed anyone cutting someone's lines id stab them with their scissors.

How pathetic.


yes i agree,violence isnt the answer, but if anyone touches my kite or lines i will break their effing legs

cauncy
WA, 8407 posts
26 Dec 2011 9:44AM
Thumbs Up

Sounds like a great story for an episode of home and away, I reckon it was alf

stuntnaz
NSW, 540 posts
26 Dec 2011 12:44PM
Thumbs Up

Spoke to the lifeguards at my local the other day they can not ban us from the beach they can't take your gear off you all they can do is call the police to come and remove you from the beach because you are stopping the lifeguards from doing there job. Cut my lines or pop my kite and you will be sorry.

GalahOnTheBay
NSW, 4188 posts
26 Dec 2011 7:50PM
Thumbs Up

My understanding is that the police can remove you and/or take your gear (regular and water), but only councils can put in place bans.

If you try really hard I guess a court could also ban people / spots, but you would really have to try something special on for that to happen.

For the person cutting lines, call the cops if you have proof as they are destroying people's property and will earn themselves a little something special.

Than again karma will eventually get them:

rickwindt
WA, 245 posts
26 Dec 2011 4:51PM
Thumbs Up

when you see him next time.. land his kite and then cut his lines.. see how he likes that..

Jared888
WA, 389 posts
26 Dec 2011 5:10PM
Thumbs Up

What a tool[}:)]

Localism is quite bad in my town too,

I've only lived and surfed the break for 10+ years but depending on whos out tensions can rise from there belief you dont belong,

Just smile and enjoy your surf, kite

its there issue they need to deal with while they have a **** sesh becasue there worried that there not getting all the surf.

But being a red blooded ozzy touch my gear and

iandvnt
QLD, 581 posts
26 Dec 2011 7:33PM
Thumbs Up

"letting kites down and resorted to cutting lines of people that have tried to learn in the pond"

Bullsh1t. Never seen any behavior like this before in kiting - never will. Kiting is too closeknit for anyone to get away with anything like this anyway. At least get 20 or 30 posts under your belt first lol

One of my fave sayings "ah yeah, you own the ocean do ya, good on you mate"

Jonopark
WA, 400 posts
26 Dec 2011 6:09PM
Thumbs Up

Interesting first post. I call bull**** aswell. He didn't cut your lines did he?? So who's did he cut and they don't seem to be posting.

jas73
QLD, 796 posts
26 Dec 2011 8:24PM
Thumbs Up

Not sure if it is the same Australia wide but an instance of bans is Wellington Pt in Brisbane. The local council will give you an on the spot fine for just having your gear on the grass in the park but once you go below the high water mark they cant touch you. It's up to Harbours and Marine from there that does not have a ban in place.

GalahOnTheBay said...

My understanding is that the police can remove you and/or take your gear (regular and water), but only councils can put in place bans.

If you try really hard I guess a court could also ban people / spots, but you would really have to try something special on for that to happen.

For the person cutting lines, call the cops if you have proof as they are destroying people's property and will earn themselves a little something special.

Than again karma will eventually get them:




poonarny
WA, 2 posts
26 Dec 2011 10:54PM
Thumbs Up

yer i know its a big topic for my first post but i was hell curious on actually what the process is and if people by them selfes can ban other people?

iandvnt
QLD, 581 posts
27 Dec 2011 6:07AM
Thumbs Up

This story is a lame attempt to discourage learners at safety bay on the slick side, so much better ways to go about it that involve more brain cells lol. Learners gotta know that they will disrupt the traffic flow on the slick side, and instead of 10 or 12 riders + enjoying a freestyle session, only one learner will jam it up on the slick side so that only one person ends up enjoying it with a load of pissed off riders. Get someone older to talk to them, they will be able to sort it out with any dramas and everyone will stay happy.

Jonopark
WA, 400 posts
27 Dec 2011 4:58AM
Thumbs Up

Obviousley no one can ban someone from a beach it is a public place. I still reckon your stirring ****! But if everyone hated you kiting somewhere due to the fact your in there way why would you kite there? To prove what point? You have a right to have fun in expense of 15 others??? Other people would not help and rather hinder your experience. tension high!, and it seems like you would be asking for trouble?? I believe majority rules. If you want to piss people off it's your call. While violence is never the answer it is always a possibility. Some people say localism sucks (I surf a lot and have had to put up with bs for years (and I can surf) but common sense has to prevail. If it does get heated is it worth it?? And if you are causing problems (dropping kite or getting in peoples way) why on earth would you wreck everyone elses day?? At some breaks if you drop in (repeatedly) your going to get your head punched in. Sadly this is the only way some people learn. Everyone has a right. Are your rights better than 15 others?? And cutting lines is bs. Never seen it. And letting kites down hahaha is that really a deterrent?? You do own a pump! I started kiting due to lack of waves and hassling when there is waves (I won't surf metro/and hardly on weekends) I would hate to see kiting go this way. Follow your common sense and I'm sure there will never be problems

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
27 Dec 2011 10:53AM
Thumbs Up

Eh.. someone waking me from my chrissy nap!?




that-guy
WA, 12 posts
27 Dec 2011 12:01PM
Thumbs Up

This story is actually true. a learner set up and launched at the pond next to the big bush thing at the waters edge. he then proceded out of controll to the onshore beach where the storm water outlet is. still trying to keep going he swooped his kite to try water start, but misjudged it and it hit the beach very close to a father and is little girl. close enough to make her cry. said kiter then continues trying to relaunch his kite before it gets deflated by a member of the kiting community.
i dont know if this is the incident you are refering to, but its still a very good example of why deadset newbys shouldnt learn in the pond.

as to this guy teaching befor hand, he wasnt getting in everyones way. he wasnt endangering other kiters or members of the public and when they are ready to get on a board i bet it will be around the corner at shoalwater.

wetwilly
WA, 13 posts
27 Dec 2011 1:47PM
Thumbs Up

The ocean is for all of us to share, but we all should respect the fact that some areas - like the slick bit at the top of the pond and including the landing area 30 metres downwind, should be kept clear for the better guys to do their technical stuff without fear of landing on somone who is learning to keep upwind.

There is plenty of water across to the weedbank for harnessing your skills as a beginner and it actualy gets pretty flat also.

Now regarding that guy who let a kite down. This was my mate and it is intersting to hear the "full story". Some beginner launched in the busy end of the pond. He looped his kite several times before crashing it on the beach. It then relaunched and did another loop before crashing right near a little girl. Seeing this, my mate ran down to see the girl running up to the carpark crying with fear whilst her spectator Dad who knows nothing about kites was about to help this guy launch again ( you know, one of those guys who get knocked over by the kite through launching it too hot). My mate took control of a bad situation and deflated the kite to make the point that beginners (and all of us) should be wary of kiting in areas where there is little room for error.

The wind direction at the pond means that an out of control kite could end up hitting the spectators or even end up on the road. Maybe if you need some more practice with kite control etc i would suggest kiting somewhere safer for all.

Underoath
QLD, 2433 posts
27 Dec 2011 3:54PM
Thumbs Up

wetwilly said...

Now regarding that guy who let a kite down. This was my mate and it is intersting to hear the "full story". My mate took control of a bad situation and deflated the kite to make the point that beginners (and all of us) should be wary of kiting in areas where there is little room for error.


That's almost like taking the car keys off a drunk driver.

Your mate did a good job. Im glad he didnt resort to cutting lines.

Spacemonkey!
SA, 2288 posts
27 Dec 2011 5:47PM
Thumbs Up

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
27 Dec 2011 8:53PM
Thumbs Up

Underoath said...

wetwilly said...

Now regarding that guy who let a kite down. This was my mate and it is intersting to hear the "full story". My mate took control of a bad situation and deflated the kite to make the point that beginners (and all of us) should be wary of kiting in areas where there is little room for error.


That's almost like taking the car keys off a drunk driver.

Your mate did a good job. Im glad he didnt resort to cutting lines.



I suspected this was the case. Most people wouldn't resort to this unless the person in question was being a complete douche bag. cutting lines would only be used if they person in question refuses to listen to reason and keeps pumping their kite after the guys deflate it.

gmd
WA, 97 posts
27 Dec 2011 6:09PM
Thumbs Up

we have tourists coming regularly to the pond, not knowing about local customs. I learned at safety bay and did not go into the pond until a year after and when I could hold upwind and could turn quickly, because I was instructed about the meaning of the flat water and the dangers of the location. Whenever I can I try and inform people the same way, some take it with grace some take it with ignorance, but at least we all should try to "inform" and not "complain". Common sense is not the same for everyone. so please be surprised that some tourists are even grateful for being informed in a "friendly" way. Of course there are a few who may not take it the right way. But the more popular the sport becomes the more important it is that we all "talk" to each other and not assume everyone knows or thinks the same way.

Merry Christmas and a happy new year to all of you.

ilGrezzo
WA, 8 posts
29 Dec 2011 2:06PM
Thumbs Up

it's **** to see how bad the pond is getting lately, since a lot of "local" riders are talking smack here on seabreeze and supporting the fact that people should be able to learn in the pond so more people keep doing it, old mate got hurt the other day and snapped his collarbone cause of some dude's girlfriend learning in the shallow bit and dove her kite on him and to dodge it he ran into the boyfriend that apparently wasnt really paying any attention. other guy just yesterday was doing downwind runs right in the shallow bit, smashed his kite on the beach a few times and all that, and i reckon some of the so-called local beginners think they own the joint and are pushing this attitude just to try and prove a point but just end up pissing other people off and ruining everybody's session. and in the end of it all just ruining the vibe in the pond causing everyone to have a **** time, putting people in danger. the point im trying to make is that there is no need for all this animosity in the pond and you smart asses that keep telling yourselves that it's ok to teach in the pond, well it's not. what's it gonna take to understand it? another kite in the power lines? or maybe a kite crashing on a truck that loses control and kills someone? just think about that, would you keep kitesurfing after you know that your behaviour took someone's life?
the big problem this year in the pond i think is that a lot of people that ride there don't know each other and just tell each other off on forums and there's a lot of tension created by that.
a lot of crew that just started last year are riding in the pond, loving it and respecting everybody, i taught a couple of them personally last season and i'm very stoked to see them riding and progressing, but there's a couple of guys that hide behind nicknames and just push all this tension and bad vibes and personally i dont know who they are and i don't care, all i'm trying to say is that there is no need for this, there's plenty of room for everyone and nobody is trying to claim the spot for themselves, we're just trying to get COMPLETE beginners out of there before something major happens and we get the pond shut.
so stop being smart arses about it.

by the way, i'm Luca, the smelly italian rastaman
just so we stop hiding behind nicknames

that-guy
WA, 12 posts
29 Dec 2011 2:26PM
Thumbs Up

We are Also looking at pond police to sentence newbs and general kook behavior

puppetonastring
WA, 3619 posts
29 Dec 2011 3:03PM
Thumbs Up

Who's right is it to ban people to kite?
Its not a 'right' its a 'responsibility'.
Every kiter should do whatever necessary to educate other kiters to the local rules & guidelines at any location. It took a lot of cooperative effort of all "interested parties" (esp the poleys) to keep the Pond open to kiting at all. It is considered by ALL parties (council; DEC; WAKSA; local kiters; poleys; boaties; sailors; dog walkers; bird watchers etc) to be an advanced kiters ONLY area.
It is offshore. No newbs should kite in offshore - esp where there are roads, powerlines etc downwind.
If kiters dont take the responsibility of keeping the Pond being kited as per the agreed conditions then you can all stop arguing cos you will have nothing to argue about.
Cutting lines is super drastic - dont know that Id resort to that - BUT - if its a matter of safety to third parties then cut lines are a far better option than someone else being injured or killed.
Educate rather than intimidate; dont launch anyone who shouldnt be there etc etc but whatever it takes, if its not controlled it will be lost to all.
Blame the offenders? Yep - but also blame those who arent prepared to step up to the responsibilty of controlling the situation and the site.

Subculture
443 posts
29 Dec 2011 9:42PM
Thumbs Up

puppetonastring said...

Who's right is it to ban people to kite?
Its not a 'right' its a 'responsibility'.
Every kiter should do whatever necessary to educate other kiters to the local rules & guidelines at any location. It took a lot of cooperative effort of all "interested parties" (esp the poleys) to keep the Pond open to kiting at all. It is considered by ALL parties (council; DEC; WAKSA; local kiters; poleys; boaties; sailors; dog walkers; bird watchers etc) to be an advanced kiters ONLY area.
It is offshore. No newbs should kite in offshore - esp where there are roads, powerlines etc downwind.
If kiters dont take the responsibility of keeping the Pond being kited as per the agreed conditions then you can all stop arguing cos you will have nothing to argue about.
Cutting lines is super drastic - dont know that Id resort to that - BUT - if its a matter of safety to third parties then cut lines are a far better option than someone else being injured or killed.
Educate rather than intimidate; dont launch anyone who shouldnt be there etc etc but whatever it takes, if its not controlled it will be lost to all.
Blame the offenders? Yep - but also blame those who arent prepared to step up to the responsibilty of controlling the situation and the site.



Why - oh - why does common sense so often have to be spelled out for people... Well said Phil!!

CJF91
WA, 26 posts
31 Dec 2011 11:25AM
Thumbs Up

Agent 554 said...

We are Also looking at pond police to sentence newbs and general kook behavior



Ahhh f**k im screwed,
body dragging is still ok yeah, been doing it for 3 years now wouldnt say im a learner.

at the end of the day leaners and newbees should stay out of the pond at peak times during the summer until they know kite customs, rules and can handle their s**t
as for cutting lines and letting kites down, very excessive no matter what situation, a simple chat and point in the right direction (aka shoalwater) probally wouldve been sufficeint
xoxo Cody (local mad dog)

ilGrezzo
WA, 8 posts
31 Dec 2011 11:59AM
Thumbs Up

nobody's been cutting freaking lines.... yet [}:)]

ahah no just kidding, that's excessive unless someone's being really a knobhead.
but letting kites down is quite fair in some cases.

that-guy
WA, 12 posts
1 Jan 2012 12:21PM
Thumbs Up

Yet been the crucial word there. It won't take long before someone gets annoyed at the stupid behavior and goes that far

giBiLatoR
QLD, 147 posts
1 Jan 2012 2:43PM
Thumbs Up

jas73 said...

Not sure if it is the same Australia wide but an instance of bans is Wellington Pt in Brisbane. The local council will give you an on the spot fine for just having your gear on the grass in the park but once you go below the high water mark they cant touch you. It's up to Harbours and Marine from there that does not have a ban in place.


Not that it stops us here hehe =]



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing General


"Who's right is it to ban people to kite?" started by poonarny