Forums > Kitesurfing General

Long overdue kite upgrade. What size equivalents?

Reply
Created by guy77 > 9 months ago, 6 Sep 2010
guy77
QLD, 33 posts
6 Sep 2010 12:08PM
Thumbs Up

Hey all,

It's time for a long overdue upgrade to my kiting quiver and I've not really been paying that much attention to modern kite capabilities, so I'm looking for some advise regarding what size / type of kite I should be looking at for a replacement.

Currently I have:

F-one 9m Impact (05)
F-one 13m Tribal (06)
F-one 16m Rival (07)

By far I have always gotten the most use from the 13m, and I think its largely past its use-by date. I am usually comfortable on it from about 15-22 knots give or take, and thats the sweet spot for my local beach. The 9m has all but disintegrated (it was a demo kite as well before I bought it) and didnt get that much use anyway. The 16m is still serviceable with some valve work.

So I'm looking for something to replace mainly my 13m but also hoping it will cover some of the 9m. Should i be looking at a 12m in current kite design? Can anyone guestimate the comparitive power of the 13m tribal against a new kite.

Also any suggestions on where the best value for money is these days because I don't want to pay a premium for the greatest kite on the planet, I just want something quality and useable.

kiter zac
QLD, 295 posts
6 Sep 2010 12:46PM
Thumbs Up

you will be right with about a 12m in any bow kite. 12m switchies are pretty good.

kiter zac
QLD, 295 posts
6 Sep 2010 12:46PM
Thumbs Up

you will be right with about a 12m in any bow kite. 12m switchies are pretty good.

waxman
SA, 1390 posts
6 Sep 2010 12:35PM
Thumbs Up

It does look like you are overdue for a upgrade, a lot has changed, most people now only have a 2 kite quiver to get the full wind range. Other people are using a single kite to cover a range from 14-30kts with ease.

There are a lot of different kite designs around now, from bow, SLE, c, delta, bridled c and many other hybrids. A lot of these kites can be used as all round kites but excel in certain areas.

So depending on riding style, board and weight plus your skill level will all be factors when choosing a kite.

If you plan to only upgrade one kite this year than another next year a 12/13m would be a good option, it would replace both your bigger kites, then next year you could get a 8/9m to complete your quiver and get rid of all your old kites.

If you plan on only getting one kite and not looking to replace any others for a couple of years i would get depending on your weight around a 10m it would out perform both your 9 and 13m kites easily getting you going in 15kts and heaps of depower for 30+. Then keep the 16m for the light stuff or get a light wind board and just use one kite.

There are lots of options so do your homework, there will be a lot of new products released in the next 2 months so there will be a lot of reviews. Try talking to your local kite shop and grab some demo gear to try out. Or if you are looking for second hand gear there will be a lot of last years gear available allso at great prices and its all fairly easy to find reviews on.

guy77
QLD, 33 posts
6 Sep 2010 1:47PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks Waxman, yea that's the sort of info I'd been hearing already. A 10 in my head seems way too small for 15 knots, but I'll get out on some demo kites and see how it feels. It's just a surprise for me with my archaic gear to comprehend a kite that can do 15-30 knot range. Thats what I'll be looking for though, and if I can find an appropriate one, I expect a single kite would suffice. My board is a 132 and I'm about 85kg, so sounds like somewhere between a 10-12 will be on the money.

waxman
SA, 1390 posts
6 Sep 2010 1:32PM
Thumbs Up

On my bandit 3 i could go as low as 15 kts on my 9m on a TT134, Im 95kgs, the top end would be over 40 kts. I did try the 10m was gruntier and would suit a one kite quiver for your size, but for my size i would have used the 11m as a one kite quiver super nice kite. Even the 13m i could use in winds gusting to 30kts(not fun, but didn't die).

Definitely try as many as you can, look out for demo days coming up. There should be a lot around.

koma
VIC, 760 posts
6 Sep 2010 2:44PM
Thumbs Up

It might be worth mentioning that given you've spent so long on the old-school C's that you might not like the way a bow or delta flies. Your definitely going to have to get a few demo's out just to see what you like.

If your used to the way your Tribal flies then i'd be going for one of the new C's as they've got a ton of depower on the bar compared to the oldies, as well as a wider usable wind range... not just for high-wind survival kiting.
Check out the Slingy Fuel, Naish Torch, Ozone C4, North Vegas... and maybe even a Hadlow Pro if you want something that feels a bit more like your old ones. All of those in an 11m would be a perfect replacement as they're more powerful and more usable than your old C. I'm a tiny but under your weight (~80kg) and use a 12m Torch as my usual go-to kite for Melbourne's summer. I could probably drop down to an 11m though and be rewarded with faster turning speed.

Enjoy the demoing. It's a fun situation to be in... cashed up and full of options!

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
6 Sep 2010 3:56PM
Thumbs Up

I think Koma hit the nail on the head. There are bow kites that claim to feel like C's, but none of them actually do and if you're a C kite purist, then all of them are going to feel lifeless and a little mushy. If you can get used to them, then thats fine, but testing will definitely be your best option because I'm pretty sure you'll hate some of them.

djdojo
VIC, 1614 posts
6 Sep 2010 4:29PM
Thumbs Up

waxman said...

On my bandit 3 i could go as low as 15 kts on my 9m on a TT134, Im 95kgs, the top end would be over 40 kts. I did try the 10m was gruntier and would suit a one kite quiver for your size, but for my size i would have used the 11m as a one kite quiver super nice kite. Even the 13m i could use in winds gusting to 30kts(not fun, but didn't die).

Definitely try as many as you can, look out for demo days coming up. There should be a lot around.


15-40+knots. A new benchmark for ludicrous wind range claims. Keep it real eh.

guy77
QLD, 33 posts
6 Sep 2010 4:59PM
Thumbs Up

Saffer said...

I think Koma hit the nail on the head. There are bow kites that claim to feel like C's, but none of them actually do and if you're a C kite purist, then all of them are going to feel lifeless and a little mushy. If you can get used to them, then thats fine, but testing will definitely be your best option because I'm pretty sure you'll hate some of them.



Yea I wouldn't go so far as to say I'm a C purist. I always tended that way previously (obviously looking at my quiver), and I've never owned a bow before but I'm not opposed to them any more either. Also I'm not as aggressive as I was. Plus I rather like the idea of not having those sphincter tightening moments where I'm a couple of knots on the wrong side of a C's upper limit.

@koma Not that cashed up mate, hence the single kite upgrade and hopefully something well under 2k, which seems tight these days for a complete bar / lines / kite. Doubt I'd get anything for my kit if I sold it so nothing to offset the new gear :(

guy77
QLD, 33 posts
6 Sep 2010 5:01PM
Thumbs Up

djdojo said...

waxman said...

On my bandit 3 i could go as low as 15 kts on my 9m on a TT134, Im 95kgs, the top end would be over 40 kts. I did try the 10m was gruntier and would suit a one kite quiver for your size, but for my size i would have used the 11m as a one kite quiver super nice kite. Even the 13m i could use in winds gusting to 30kts(not fun, but didn't die).

Definitely try as many as you can, look out for demo days coming up. There should be a lot around.


15-40+knots. A new benchmark for ludicrous wind range claims. Keep it real eh.


maybe the 15 kt was on a surfboard and the 40 kt was a paddle pop stick hahah.

TurtleHunter
WA, 1675 posts
6 Sep 2010 3:09PM
Thumbs Up

Time to demo a few different styles I think. You will probably feel more at home on the new c's but the sle,bow and delta's will give you a bigger windrange

rusty7
QLD, 504 posts
6 Sep 2010 5:28PM
Thumbs Up

demo, demo ,demo ...... you are from North side Brisbane so Talk to the guys at kitepower they have a heap of demos. Kites are way more powerful these days than some of your gear so you really are going to have to find out for yourself. The way the season is shaping up, you will have plenty of oppurtunity to test fly kites before you make up your mind.

koma
VIC, 760 posts
6 Sep 2010 6:18PM
Thumbs Up

guy77 said...
Yea I wouldn't go so far as to say I'm a C purist. I always tended that way previously (obviously looking at my quiver), and I've never owned a bow before but I'm not opposed to them any more either. Also I'm not as aggressive as I was. Plus I rather like the idea of not having those sphincter tightening moments where I'm a couple of knots on the wrong side of a C's upper limit.

@koma Not that cashed up mate, hence the single kite upgrade and hopefully something well under 2k, which seems tight these days for a complete bar / lines / kite. Doubt I'd get anything for my kit if I sold it so nothing to offset the new gear :(


I started out flying what i would call second-gen C's ('04 Naish Aero II & '05 Fuel), i can assure that most of today's C kites will feel completely soft in comparison! That's not a bad thing though, it just means they've evolved and taken the safety and benefits of a high depower design and mixed it in with the original C kites flight characteristics. If your not used to that level of depower then your in for a bit of a surprise - dropping the bar on a modern C without the stopper pulled in will give you about 80-85% depower in most cases, unlike the 40-60% depower of the old C's.

$2k should get you almost any kite on the market these days, all except for the boutique brands like Flysurfers. If you want to play around with the new Naish Torch and Bolt i'm pretty sure Jason @ BrisKites got his hands on them recently. The Naish Park might be one that does interest you if the Torch is a little too aggressive for your liking... although given your current quiver i highly doubt that to be the case.

waxman
SA, 1390 posts
6 Sep 2010 6:07PM
Thumbs Up

djdojo said...

waxman said...

On my bandit 3 i could go as low as 15 kts on my 9m on a TT134, Im 95kgs, the top end would be over 40 kts. I did try the 10m was gruntier and would suit a one kite quiver for your size, but for my size i would have used the 11m as a one kite quiver super nice kite. Even the 13m i could use in winds gusting to 30kts(not fun, but didn't die).

Definitely try as many as you can, look out for demo days coming up. There should be a lot around.


15-40+knots. A new benchmark for ludicrous wind range claims. Keep it real eh.


The 9m is my smallest kite and i weigh over 100kgs wet, and i have been out in conditions gusting to 40kts. FOne claim on there website the 9m b3 will handle wind squalls gusting to 50kts(survival mode not lets have fun). When riding my 9m in a average 30kts i hardly need to depower the kite let alone adjust the middle line. It is a very stable predictable kite in strong winds.

I think top end of a kite is a personal thing, if you don't feel comfortable head back in. Just because someone claims a higher top end dont assume you will be able to handle it. Stick to the wind range chart for a start and go from there. So on the 9m bandit 3 the wind range is 15-30kts for a 75 kg ridder with average skills.

radman4
678 posts
6 Sep 2010 4:55PM
Thumbs Up

waxman said...

djdojo said...

waxman said...

On my bandit 3 i could go as low as 15 kts on my 9m on a TT134, Im 95kgs, the top end would be over 40 kts. I did try the 10m was gruntier and would suit a one kite quiver for your size, but for my size i would have used the 11m as a one kite quiver super nice kite. Even the 13m i could use in winds gusting to 30kts(not fun, but didn't die).

Definitely try as many as you can, look out for demo days coming up. There should be a lot around.


15-40+knots. A new benchmark for ludicrous wind range claims. Keep it real eh.


The 9m is my smallest kite and i weigh over 100kgs wet, and i have been out in conditions gusting to 40kts. FOne claim on there website the 9m b3 will handle wind squalls gusting to 50kts(survival mode not lets have fun). When riding my 9m in a average 30kts i hardly need to depower the kite let alone adjust the middle line. It is a very stable predictable kite in strong winds.

I think top end of a kite is a personal thing, if you don't feel comfortable head back in. Just because someone claims a higher top end dont assume you will be able to handle it. Stick to the wind range chart for a start and go from there. So on the 9m bandit 3 the wind range is 15-30kts for a 75 kg ridder with average skills.




Yea i'll go along with that im over 100kg wet and have been out on a 9 griff in winds gusting 43knots and could get riding from 15 no probs,50 knots would be crazy but low 40+ no worries,just depends on weight skill level and how fn crazy you are,you see a lot of guys run in and panic at the first sign of a gust ,your only gonna find out what your capeable of if you hang in there.

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
6 Sep 2010 7:01PM
Thumbs Up

waxman said...

djdojo said...

waxman said...

On my bandit 3 i could go as low as 15 kts on my 9m on a TT134, Im 95kgs, the top end would be over 40 kts. I did try the 10m was gruntier and would suit a one kite quiver for your size, but for my size i would have used the 11m as a one kite quiver super nice kite. Even the 13m i could use in winds gusting to 30kts(not fun, but didn't die).

Definitely try as many as you can, look out for demo days coming up. There should be a lot around.


15-40+knots. A new benchmark for ludicrous wind range claims. Keep it real eh.


The 9m is my smallest kite and i weigh over 100kgs wet, and i have been out in conditions gusting to 40kts. FOne claim on there website the 9m b3 will handle wind squalls gusting to 50kts(survival mode not lets have fun). When riding my 9m in a average 30kts i hardly need to depower the kite let alone adjust the middle line. It is a very stable predictable kite in strong winds.

I think top end of a kite is a personal thing, if you don't feel comfortable head back in. Just because someone claims a higher top end dont assume you will be able to handle it. Stick to the wind range chart for a start and go from there. So on the 9m bandit 3 the wind range is 15-30kts for a 75 kg ridder with average skills.




I think you'll find that people don't consider the gusts as the top end and any claims to be using such are likely to result in people calling you up on it. If you're out in 33 knots and its gusting 40, then the range is to 33 knots, not 40 or every idiot would be sitting claim top ends of the last gust that came through and then by your theory, my old Takoon Nova 2 had a range of 14-45 because I happened to survive some hectic gusts one day when in reality, its not a hell of a lot of fun in anything over 28 knots for my 75kg's.

waxman
SA, 1390 posts
6 Sep 2010 6:58PM
Thumbs Up

I always include average wind speed, and max gusts, as it better describes of the conditions. eg if you describe 25kts average a lot of people would say i could handle that. but if you said 25(average) to 40(max) kts people would be more hesitant to go out as it would indicate the wind could be dropping below 20kts(min) then gusting to 35/40kts, or on the other side it could be 25 to 28 kts nice consistent conditions.

I know the BOM site list both for this reason, there are also a lot of manufacturers that claim there wind range is to be MAX wind speed or gusts, not average.

KnutH
VIC, 427 posts
6 Sep 2010 9:15PM
Thumbs Up

waxman said...

On my bandit 3 i could go as low as 15 kts on my 9m on a TT134, Im 95kgs,

The low end sounds a bit ambitious, but let's not be too picky as 1 or 2 knots make a big difference in low end. I could see something like 15-17,5kn though, no problem.

Regarding high end I agree with the man in wax, especially in winter you have those "20-30 knots, possible gusts to 40" forecasts, so I want to know if I can hold my kite in those kind of winds, or do I have to come in every time I see somewhat dark clouds. Not talking about vicious looking ones, common sense is still the best safety system.
40+kn gusts doesn't seem unrealistic to me, most likely the kite flies crappy and you need a good amount of bar throw as well, but at least you can make it back to the beach without getting teabagged.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing General


"Long overdue kite upgrade. What size equivalents?" started by guy77