Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

Which Catamaran would be suitable

Reply
Created by Jayse > 9 months ago, 6 Jan 2015
Jayse
1 posts
6 Jan 2015 1:57PM
Thumbs Up

Hi all.

I have just arrived home from Vanuatu and while there the resort I stayed at had 14 ft Calypso Catamarans for guests to use and being a first timer my first sailing ended with me flipping the boat but as each day went I got better and better and on my final day I entered a catamaran race that the resort held and won the race.

I now love sailing and would like to purchase my first catamaran and I would like to know which would better for a beginner such as myself waiting just freely cruise the bay at home in Portland, Vic.

I have looked at the 14 ft Calypso as I used in Vanuatu but the Hobie 14 also looks good. Can someone please give me some advice on which I should purchase and what to look for when purchasing my first catamaran?

Thanks in advance.

Jayse

jfunk
QLD, 255 posts
6 Jan 2015 6:50PM
Thumbs Up

Go to a yacht/sailing club near you and see what they sail, then you will have people who can help you develop.

Katz
VIC, 131 posts
6 Jan 2015 8:58PM
Thumbs Up


Like JF says. Best is what works locally and has some support and competition. You'll get bored soon enough just cruising around. Also depends if you are planning sailing by yourself or not. For cheap sailing, old hobies are fine, the 14 nosedives badly, 16 is still great with a crew, 17 a possibility for single handed sailing. Most versatile is the 4.9 Taipan; it has several configurations, good class association and boats remain competitive for a good while.

You are pretty exposed there, so you'll need something pretty reliable.

kiteboy dave
QLD, 6525 posts
6 Jan 2015 8:03PM
Thumbs Up

If you don't flip a cat you're just not trying hard enough!

Generally they're great, fast when going but poor tacking. If you didn't make it round a tack you'd have to do all sorts of tricks to get the nose round.

I had a hobie 14 as a teen, the 'turbo' version which had the jib. Definately go a jib- you can still sail singlehanded, don't need to fuss with the jib apart from reset at tack/jybe and it adds heaps of speed.

I'd also look at the hobie 16 and 17. Bit bigger, bit faster.

For what it's worth I always wanted a nacra when I raced the hobie, more of a pain with centreboards but faster and some have spinnakers which adds a new level after a year or two..

Edit - as kats says they do nosedive - when full blown (~30kts) I'd have me and a mate out on trapeze and we'd be trying to have our feet on the last 1-2 foot of the end of the hull. Had a spectacular air followed by nosedive in a race in moreton bay. We were both right at the back out on trapeze when the nose buried, launched up and out like a slingshot. I swear I landed 10m from the cat. One hull cracked and immediately sank, had to be towed in. Good times.

Scoob
WA, 88 posts
6 Jan 2015 6:14PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
kiteboy dave said..
..... spectacular air followed by nosedive in a race in moreton bay. We were both right at the back out on trapeze when the nose buried, launched up and out like a slingshot. I swear I landed 10m from the cat. One hull cracked and immediately sank, had to be towed in. Good times.



That explains the missing tooth.

myusernam
QLD, 6154 posts
6 Jan 2015 8:14PM
Thumbs Up

If u want to race see what is the most popular class in your area. Nothing worse than having one boat that no one else has.

myusernam
QLD, 6154 posts
6 Jan 2015 8:16PM
Thumbs Up

If u want to race see what is the most popular class in your area. Nothing worse than having one boat that no one else has.

slammin
QLD, 998 posts
6 Jan 2015 9:05PM
Thumbs Up

Windrush 14, is the best 14footer ever built.

No bias.......

The mast floats so is easier to right if you get it turtle, it is harder to capsize or cartwheel than others and they are an active class in many areas.

locateg
NSW, 33 posts
6 Jan 2015 10:49PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Jayse said..
Hi all.

I have just arrived home from Vanuatu and while there the resort I stayed at had 14 ft Calypso Catamarans for guests to use and being a first timer my first sailing ended with me flipping the boat but as each day went I got better and better and on my final day I entered a catamaran race that the resort held and won the race.

I now love sailing and would like to purchase my first catamaran and I would like to know which would better for a beginner such as myself waiting just freely cruise the bay at home in Portland, Vic.

I have looked at the 14 ft Calypso as I used in Vanuatu but the Hobie 14 also looks good. Can someone please give me some advice on which I should purchase and what to look for when purchasing my first catamaran?

Thanks in advance.

Jayse


Had a nacra 4.5, great little boat. Small enough to set up and sail by myself (very important ).
Also big enough to carry two people without to much problem.
Fast fun and exciting with plenty of buoyancy in the nose so you don't catapult in every gust of wind unless your really giving it some.
Another bonus is that there are no dagger boards to damage.

Craig66
NSW, 2466 posts
6 Jan 2015 10:52PM
Thumbs Up





If its races you want to win

Macroscien
QLD, 6808 posts
6 Jan 2015 11:29PM
Thumbs Up

For single operator electric catamaran will be the best.
then for the money left you could buy kite or windsurfer
- much easier to handle then towing a boat
( say nothing about setting out every time
you got to sail - I hated to rise mast on my Hobbie 16 )

Simondo
VIC, 8024 posts
7 Jan 2015 10:37AM
Thumbs Up

Yes, just check what Cats are being sailed locally... Compete with others in the same class...

Otherwise, go the Hobie14, great Cat, quite common, incase you need spares...
Hobie17's are pretty damn fast too! If the local guys are racing Hobie14's, you could still consider a 17 on the basis of "Mine's-bigger-than-yours"!! LoL!

Hobie14 has more rocker, which is better if you want to 'surf' it...

Simondo
VIC, 8024 posts
7 Jan 2015 10:43AM
Thumbs Up

Simondo said..
Yes, just check what Cats are being sailed locally... Compete with others in the same class...

Otherwise, go the Hobie14, great Cat, quite common, incase you need spares...
Hobie17's are pretty damn fast too! If the local guys are racing Hobie14's, you could still consider a 17 on the basis of "Mine's-bigger-than-yours"!! LoL!

Hobie14 has more rocker, which is better if you want to 'surf' it...


16's are great too...
This 16 has everything... At first you can sail with just the mainsail. Then you start getting used to the trapeze. Plus, on the light win days, get the Jib out...
Can be sailed solo, or with two... Fancy a drive to the Blue Mountains!?

http://www.boatsales.com.au/boats-for-sale/private/used/SSE-AD-3181438/1998-Hobie-16-CATAMARAN?cr=0&psq=%28%28Make%3DHobie%26%28%28%28SiloType%3D%5BDemo%20and%20near%20new%20boats%5D%7CSiloType%3D%5BDealer%20new%20boats%5D%29%7CSiloType%3D%5BDealer%20used%20boats%5D%29%7CSiloType%3D%5BPrivate%20used%20boats%5D%29%29%26Service%3D%5BBoatsales%5D%29&pso=0&pss=Premium

stamp
QLD, 2795 posts
7 Jan 2015 2:02PM
Thumbs Up

jayse - just sailing around will get boring pretty fast. you'll want to be racing soon after you get the basics. contact your local yacht club and, as others have said, find out what the most popular class is.

people are always happy to welcome newcomers into their class and club and give advice. the sailing community generally is very friendly. it doesn't matter what class you sail - if it is competitive you will have a blast & make plenty of new mates.

there used to be a good fleet of plastic cats at portland back in the late 90s & early 2000s, especially nacras and hobies...good luck

Simondo
VIC, 8024 posts
7 Jan 2015 7:31PM
Thumbs Up

You don't even have to in the same "class". Every yacht has a scratch handicap. But after a few races, you will get a personal handicap for that boat, a bit like a golf handicap...
Back in the day, our handicap was something like "118". We had long races, circa 80-100 minutes... So if you were on 120, we would need to beat you by at least 2 (and a bit) minutes, over a 100 minute race...

stamp
QLD, 2795 posts
7 Jan 2015 7:49PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Simondo said..
You don't even have to in the same "class". Every yacht has a scratch handicap. But after a few races, you will get a personal handicap for that boat, a bit like a golf handicap...
Back in the day, our handicap was something like "118". We had long races, circa 80-100 minutes... So if you were on 120, we would need to beat you by at least 2 (and a bit) minutes, over a 100 minute race...


yeah but handicaps and yardsticks are never worked out properly, especially by the vyc committee.
it's much better to be in the same class. over the line placings are more accurate and satisfying than having to get back to the club to know who placed where.

Darkspi
SA, 171 posts
8 Jan 2015 11:02AM
Thumbs Up

youtube gunboat :) big boys wet dream heheh

evlPanda
NSW, 9207 posts
8 Jan 2015 12:51PM
Thumbs Up

I was originally going to buy a catamaran about 8 years ago. Then I realised nobody really wanted to come out with me, "What if there's no wind? We'll get wet. Do I have to help you?" so I looked at smaller, more portable alternatives.

I was (****ing) lucky enough to go out sunset sailing on Sydney harbour last night, out through the heads and back to rushcutter's bay, the ultimate harbour cruise. 15 knot seabreeze and perfect conditions. Even an almost full moon came up just after sunset. I mean it doesn't really get any nicer than that on a sailboat.

But I tell you it was like walking uphill. Pushing through the water. Being pushed to leeward. All the time. Apparent wind coming from, huh what?... behind us?
To be clear and fair it's not like I can go cruising like that on a windsurfer very easily. I think. There are certainly advantages to a sailboat.

As was hinted above maybe you might consider windsurfing, or god forbid even kitesurfing. Once you lose all that drag and start planing, and the rig leans into the wind, like a wing, it's Sailing ++. It's like everything is breathing freely instead of being pushed. You're pretty much flying. I'd even go so far as to say you haven't really sailed unless you've done it.

Well, that's my sales pitch. Pun intended.

Rails
QLD, 1371 posts
9 Jan 2015 12:40PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
evlPanda said..
I was originally going to buy a catamaran about 8 years ago. Then I realised nobody really wanted to come out with me, "What if there's no wind? We'll get wet. Do I have to help you?" so I looked at smaller, more portable alternatives.

I was (****ing) lucky enough to go out sunset sailing on Sydney harbour last night, out through the heads and back to rushcutter's bay, the ultimate harbour cruise. 15 knot seabreeze and perfect conditions. Even an almost full moon came up just after sunset. I mean it doesn't really get any nicer than that on a sailboat.

But I tell you it was like walking uphill. Pushing through the water. Being pushed to leeward. All the time. Apparent wind coming from, huh what?... behind us?
To be clear and fair it's not like I can go cruising like that on a windsurfer very easily. I think. There are certainly advantages to a sailboat.

As was hinted above maybe you might consider windsurfing, or god forbid even kitesurfing. Once you lose all that drag and start planing, and the rig leans into the wind, like a wing, it's Sailing ++. It's like everything is breathing freely instead of being pushed. You're pretty much flying. I'd even go so far as to say you haven't really sailed unless you've done it.

Well, that's my sales pitch. Pun intended.


panda is on to something here
God created kites so than man (and women) wouldn't need a towbar!

stamp
QLD, 2795 posts
9 Jan 2015 8:23PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
evlPanda said..
I was originally going to buy a catamaran about 8 years ago. Then I realised nobody really wanted to come out with me, "What if there's no wind? We'll get wet. Do I have to help you?" so I looked at smaller, more portable alternatives.

I was (****ing) lucky enough to go out sunset sailing on Sydney harbour last night, out through the heads and back to rushcutter's bay, the ultimate harbour cruise. 15 knot seabreeze and perfect conditions. Even an almost full moon came up just after sunset. I mean it doesn't really get any nicer than that on a sailboat.

But I tell you it was like walking uphill. Pushing through the water. Being pushed to leeward. All the time. Apparent wind coming from, huh what?... behind us?
To be clear and fair it's not like I can go cruising like that on a windsurfer very easily. I think. There are certainly advantages to a sailboat.

As was hinted above maybe you might consider windsurfing, or god forbid even kitesurfing. Once you lose all that drag and start planing, and the rig leans into the wind, like a wing, it's Sailing ++. It's like everything is breathing freely instead of being pushed. You're pretty much flying. I'd even go so far as to say you haven't really sailed unless you've done it.

Well, that's my sales pitch. Pun intended.


i agree with you when it comes to big boats.

but being on the trapeze of a skiff or a fast off-the-beach cat on a reach in 20 knots or more is easily as much of a buzz as planing on a windsurfer or kite board. especially when you're racing.

ggh
VIC, 190 posts
9 Jan 2015 9:54PM
Thumbs Up

Mate I used to sail Nacras and loved it would have one now if I had more time infact I have been checking out the nacra 17 which is the Olympics mixed class, Howere the missus is not interested so that will have to wait.

Sailing a cat at speed is an absolute rush especially on trapeze as stamp said.

Check out out the following web sites hobie , nacra and depending on your budget A class , but do check your local sailing club and see what class they are Sailing .

Harrow
NSW, 4521 posts
10 Jan 2015 9:47AM
Thumbs Up

Are Maricat still around? You'd pick up an old 4.3 for a song I'd guess.

TheSailingMoose
VIC, 142 posts
10 Jan 2015 10:11PM
Thumbs Up

This website is your friend. Has information on many, many types of catamaran dinghies. What to look for when buying a second hand boat etc etc... http://www.sailingproshop.com/catamaran_guide.aspx

In the 14ft size im surprised no one has mentioned Paper Tigers yet. For single handed sailing they are just about perfect, very light, small, easy to manage.
They are a pretty quick 14 footer, you can generally find a relatively good condition one for under $1400, maybe even under a grand if you're lucky. You can find ones in need of repair for under $400 though.
They are also an olympic class boat and can be as technical or as simple as you want to rig them and sail them.



If i was getting a cat though i probably wouldn't go with a hobie 16/14 because im not a fan of the banana hulls, they have a horrible tendency to pitchpole due to lack of bouyancy and surface area up the front.


In my experience:
Hobie 14/16's are cheap, single-handed and fun.
Hobie 18's and more technical but and you can push them harder than the 16's but you generally need two people when the wind gets up.
Nacra's can be quite pricey but are really fun boats, also need two people.
Paper Tigers are cheap and fun and single-handed.

Craig66
NSW, 2466 posts
11 Jan 2015 12:12AM
Thumbs Up

Hobie 17

cauncy
WA, 8407 posts
10 Jan 2015 11:17PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Craig66 said..




If its races you want to win


pretty sure johnny Heineken cleaned this up in the bridge to bridge race on a chrono foil and race board by a big distance, save some coin and buy one

kiteboy dave
QLD, 6525 posts
11 Jan 2015 12:35PM
Thumbs Up

Beach rollers & registered trailer would be good things to have, but $1000 is cheeep

www.seabreeze.com.au/Classifieds/Boating-Sail-Boats/~tubxp/Hobie-14-Turbo-Catamaran-14-0.aspx

ggh
VIC, 190 posts
11 Jan 2015 10:30PM
Thumbs Up

TheSailingMoose said..
This website is your friend. Has information on many, many types of catamaran dinghies. What to look for when buying a second hand boat etc etc... http://www.sailingproshop.com/catamaran_guide.aspx

In the 14ft size im surprised no one has mentioned Paper Tigers yet. For single handed sailing they are just about perfect, very light, small, easy to manage.
They are a pretty quick 14 footer, you can generally find a relatively good condition one for under $1400, maybe even under a grand if you're lucky. You can find ones in need of repair for under $400 though.
They are also an olympic class boat and can be as technical or as simple as you want to rig them and sail them.


If i was getting a cat though i probably wouldn't go with a hobie 16/14 because im not a fan of the banana hulls, they have a horrible tendency to pitchpole due to lack of bouyancy and surface area up the front.


In my experience:
Hobie 14/16's are cheap, single-handed and fun.
Hobie 18's and more technical but and you can push them harder than the 16's but you generally need two people when the wind gets up.
Nacra's can be quite pricey but are really fun boats, also need two people.
Paper Tigers are cheap and fun and single-handed.


Funnerly enough after posting I thought oh should have mentioned a paper tiger especially if you are going to go with 14 ft, Yer I would defiantly throw the paper tiger in the mix .



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"Which Catamaran would be suitable" started by Jayse