Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

FRACCING

Reply
Created by barbarian > 9 months ago, 2 Oct 2014
barbarian
NSW, 218 posts
2 Oct 2014 9:29PM
Thumbs Up

after reading up on Fraccing I remembered I saw this YouTube a while back and couldn't help thinking that surely a lesson might be learnt about the environmental consequences of fraccing... Surely we can wait to see how badly the USA damages their environment before we do the same here?

Your thoughts?

FormulaNova
WA, 15090 posts
2 Oct 2014 9:08PM
Thumbs Up

I saw an ad on TV today where one of the companies that want to do it, is arguing that 'its a good thing'.

No mention of the risks, no mention of the benefits to us, just that 'they' think its a good thing.

It was pointed out in an article recently that gas consumption has fallen, and that the demand is coming from exporting overseas. So why fracking? Its not going to help us, its just going to open up more gas for exports.

We get the risk, someone else gets the profit.

I found an old gas bill today, and prices have increased a lot. Fracking is not going to bring them down, so there doesn't seem any benefit for us at all unless we want bubbly water coming from our taps.

Poida
WA, 1922 posts
2 Oct 2014 9:52PM
Thumbs Up

much bigger profits from gas atm, compared to coal and iron ore

cameron2156
WA, 149 posts
3 Oct 2014 6:40AM
Thumbs Up

Friggin crazy

Rails
QLD, 1371 posts
3 Oct 2014 8:58AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
barbarian said..
after reading up on Fraccing I remembered I saw this YouTube a while back and couldn't help thinking that surely a lesson might be learnt about the environmental consequences of fraccing... Surely we can wait to see how badly the USA damages their environment before we do the same here?

Your thoughts?



What the heck does the video have to do with hydraulic fracturing of rock formations to decrease hydrostatic pressures?
Why worry about where the gas is coming from while you chug at least 100l of oil every day from a decreasing resource base

Cobra
9106 posts
3 Oct 2014 8:21AM
Thumbs Up

minor or miner mentality.

barbarian
NSW, 218 posts
3 Oct 2014 10:34AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Rails said..

barbarian said..
after reading up on Fraccing I remembered I saw this YouTube a while back and couldn't help thinking that surely a lesson might be learnt about the environmental consequences of fraccing... Surely we can wait to see how badly the USA damages their environment before we do the same here?

Your thoughts?




What the heck does the video have to do with hydraulic fracturing of rock formations to decrease hydrostatic pressures?
Why worry about where the gas is coming from while you chug at least 100l of oil every day from a decreasing resource base


Definitely not directly related.

only commonality is mankind's ability to wreck the environment...

Rails
QLD, 1371 posts
3 Oct 2014 10:49AM
Thumbs Up

Some would call it innovative use of natural resource to increase technological efficiencies and raise the standard of living
Og course given that the main drivers of capitalism are avarice and short term gain the finite and interconnected nature of the planet is often ignored
And those that directly benefit from externalities of natural resource consumption would prefer not to pay as it would decrease their profit margin
So the social and environmental costs of the economic paradigm are still borne by the majority
Regulation of industry to impose a cost on externalities is the only reasonable course of action within the current paradigm
Ps the merchants of capitalism will continue to do as they please because they have all the money and all of the guns I.e. They on the means of production

vanders1
QLD, 3809 posts
3 Oct 2014 6:12PM
Thumbs Up

Got to laugh at the bumper stickers "No Gas - No Coal - No Pipelines" Interested to know how people are going to be able to log onto the Breeze without electricity?



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"FRACCING" started by barbarian